Carter: Crucial season for MotoGP

Eurosport - Fri, 02 Jan 14:50:00 2009

Eurosport expert Tony Carter believes that 2009 will be a crucial one for MotoGP racing - with elbow-to-elbow action lacking in the last campaign.

MOTORCYCLING - MotoGP at Brno - 0

When will MotoGP get exciting again?

I'm not talking about the technical excitement that each factory brings to the party, or the individual skills of the riders.

But when are we going to see the sort of elbow-to-elbow action in the class again that so excited us all during Laguna Seca last season, when Valentino Rossi and Casey Stoner gave us a few laps of absolutely thrilling action?

Because, apart from that race and the odd bit of thrilldom elsewhere over the 18-round championship - God, it felt long - the MotoGP races were mind-crushingly dull.

For the majority of fans, the races that we saw last year weren't enough to keep them hooked. Only anoraks could find interest in what size front wheel John Hopkins was running or if Casey Stoner was using the new rear wheel grommet for the first time this year.

There's nothing more dull than an anorak like me telling a mate with a passing interest in bike racing the Dani Pedrosa's third-place finish is very interesting because it's the first time he's been on the pneumatic-valve Honda engine as opposed to the old motor which Nicky Hayden was on in a particular race.

Eyes glaze over when people need 'interesting' points explained to them. What they, and we, want is the sort of racing that need no qualification. That needs no explanation.

Fairing-bashing, tooth-and-nail racing that leaves your heart pounding and palms sweating. Racing that is almost as exciting to watch as it is to be taking part in on track.

And that's something that's been missing from MotoGP recently.

Is it any wonder then that Rossi has said that he would like to race in WSB, just to get back to the sort of excitement and on-track barging that the likes of Bayliss, Haga, Corser and Xaus gave us week-in, week-out in 2008?

But what can be done to spice up MotoGP again? To stop these races finishing with seven, 10 or 13 seconds between first, second or third?

The one-make tyre rule will help matters, and it needs to because we can't have another season of hard-to-watch MotoGP racing on the cards - especially with such a terrifically exciting World Superbike Championship and British Superbike Championship on the cards.

MotoGP is really going to have to up its game to compete with WSB where we have something like 17 factory machines out there, a host of race-winnable satellite teams and five geed-up Brits ready to provide us with the most incredible racing we've seen for a long time.

Or maybe that Rossi move might just find its way to being a little more permanent - maybe he'll stay for a complete season before he finally leaves bikes behind and makes the full-time switch to the World Rally Championship.

A lot rests on the coming season in MotoGP. Maybe a lot more than even the MotoGP circus wants to admit to itself.

Tony Carter / Eurosport

Comment 6 - 25 of 25

Sort comments by: Most recent
  1. 17 or so bikes on the grid won't make for exciting­ racing I'm afraid, nor will Rossi and Stoner­ clearing off into the distance again like last season.

    From Holty, on Tue 6 Jan 4:22PM
  2. i think that 2009 sesson will be just as bad as last­ sesson

    From jason.clulow, on Mon 5 Jan 6:34PM
  3. As for safety, ofcourse, we don't want a rider­ killed at any point of a season. But, the past has­ shown us that rider error cannot be taken out of the­ equation. Look at WSB, Yasutomo Nagai lost his life at­ the esses at Assen. But, rider error was to blame. With­ a case like Katoh's, both some degree of rider­ error and track design were blamed. In any sport,­ danger is present. A few years ago the Bridgestone tyre­ exploded on the start like at Mugello and sent Nakano­ flying down the track at a little under 200MPH. Who­ could have predicted that? In the same race,­ Tamada's rear Bridgestone exploded. Personally, the­ riders sign up to race bikes that exceded 200MPH, that­ if crashed could cause serious injuries, or life­ threatening injuries. They know the risks, as do we...­ Bring back the 990cc bikes, or better still, birng back­ the pure 500 two strokes..WHy not allow 600 two strokes­ instead...then Motogp could claim to have the best­ riders...Personally, I doubt they do.

    From EGK, on Mon 5 Jan 6:08AM
  4. I also remember Shinichi Itoh on an NSR500 V4 using­ fuel injection slip between Schwantz and Barros, taking­ pole and breaking the 200MPH barrier in both race and­ qaulifying. During the Doohan years, the 500 two­ strokes were made user friendly, because the likes of­ Biaggi couldn't ride them. The downfall was, they­ became slower and heavier. The last seasons of two­ strokes, the fastest bike on the grid ran at­ 189MPH....The shame was, had Honda kept pushing forward­ and gone all out, the two strokes would never have­ died....Also, I wanna see Rossi ride the Isle of Man,­ or Knockhill, what about Cadwell park? I wonder, would­ he even get close to the BSB boys?

    From EGK, on Mon 5 Jan 5:49AM
  5. The problem is, most TV channels are hooked on Rossi­ and the leader. No matter if he's ten seconds ahead­ of the pack, they still follow him round and round for­ too many laps. Whilst behind them, battling for 4th­ through to 9th is a group of hard riders of lesser­ bikes. Like in Australia, the battle was for 4th spot­ and it brought excitement. This season we can look­ forward to Toni Elias elbowing Rossi again, like he did­ a few seasons back in Turkey, Alex De Angeles pushing­ harder and showing what he was like in the 250 class,­ fast and aggressive. For the most part, the best races­ I've ever seen so far were back in 1988 and 1989­ when Rainey, Schwantz, Lawson, Gardner and Sarron took­ the stage and battled hard in every race. Since then,­ the only highlight has been Rossi Vs Gibernau...And­ without any bias, on a few occasions, Rossi enjoyed­ being beaten. Because, even though his arch rival­ crossed the line first, it was a battle he loved­ fighting in. That was what made those races so good,­ because Gibernau gave as good as he got with lots of­ hard over taking, late breaking and knee/elbow bashing.­ Problem is, Stoner would rather back off and complain­ than fight for it. Pedrosa sinply hasn't got what­ it takes, Lorenzo could be a challenge and a hard­ battle for Rossi if only he could stay on and Dovisioso­ is alreayd known for his whining and complaining about­ hard riding around him. Please none, he and his team­ lodged no less than 5 complaints about Toseland last­ year!

    From EGK, on Mon 5 Jan 5:44AM
  6. did Rossi say he wanted to race in wsb to get back to­ barging, i think not, he wants to race and to win, he­ would be happy winning wsb races by 10 seconds, and who­ is there to stop him, will a group of very good riders­ who grace thier stage well be able to beat the G.O.A.T.­ over a season, i hope to find this out before Vale­ finally retires, he is the best, how can anyone doubt­ it

    From VALE FOR 6, on Sat 3 Jan 5:10PM
  7. I think that the problem with MotoGP theses days, is­ that the bikes have way too many things to adjust and­ find the right settings for. I guess traction control­ is one, but there are many more, such as tyre­ pressures, multitude of suspension adjustments, seating­ position (specially if ur not a 4"10 pedrobot on a­ Honda), engine mapping, slipper clutch adjustment, and­ many more. God knows how they try to get them set-up in­ such little track time.

    Superbikes have limits on what­ can changed; and as there are many similar spec­ superbikes racing in the different series around the­ world, riders have better baseline settings, fewer­ choices to try, and the difference is more balls than­ brains.

    As to Glen M's suggestion of different­ tracks, I'd love to see MotoGP try Mount Panorama­ at Bathurst NSW Australia. I loved watching the­ H2r750's (and TZ750s) break 190 MPH on Conrod­ straight in the mid'70s. And back then the tyres­ were nothing like as good as today.

    From SS_A9X, on Sat 3 Jan 12:22PM
  8. oh dear m.smith, can you not recognise junk mail? That­ was probably posted on 1,000 sites just to get you to­ join up mate... Jeez a dit of desparation there after a­ word from a "female" on a bike site! hehe...

    From Slim, on Fri 2 Jan 9:42PM
  9. dear diaihenry 10 i am a very tall man and have­ bikes,like to go all over the wold!!!!!
    but can not­ find you on ---tallhub co m--- help

    From MARTIN, on Fri 2 Jan 9:32PM
  10. dear diaihenry 10 i am a very tall man and have­ bikes,like to go all over the wold!!!!!
    but can not­ find you on ---tallhub co m--- help

    From MARTIN, on Fri 2 Jan 9:13PM
  11. WSB produces fine racing, as does BSB. The trouble is­ the best riders are in MotoGP. You can watch good­ football in the vauxhall conference league but most­ people prefer the premiership.

    From Nigel, on Fri 2 Jan 4:56PM
  12. He is obviously slanted in the WSB camp. Towards the­ end he uses the term 'we' when referring to­ WSB. Very professional that.

    From philliec, on Fri 2 Jan 4:29PM
  13. Invalid comment, almost every time I try and post I get­ this message. I would not mind if I had something bad­ to say or was swearing. I even change the text but it’s­ the same (Invalid comment) why

    From barry.riddell, on Fri 2 Jan 3:12PM
  14. What Carter is saying here is an opinion shared by A­ LOT of people, so saying it's purely because­ Eurosport has lost the TV rights is a bit daft!

    From Slim, on Fri 2 Jan 2:41PM
  15. gah, invalid comment. Anyone else getting this?­ Eurosport getting worried about use calling out their­ writers on their slanted articles?

    From philliec, on Fri 2 Jan 2:16PM
  16. i disagree with this article.what made him think motogp­ is boring?maybe he doesn't watch f1.the truth­ is,motogp is far better than f1.even wsbk is better­ than f1.nothing is not interesting in motogp.no boring­ races,season,battles unlike f1.

    From Guyver_3, on Fri 2 Jan 2:15PM
  17. t

    From philliec, on Fri 2 Jan 2:08PM
  18. Only Spa is a current F1 circuit. The old Hockenheim­ and Suzuka are not.

    I think what Glen M is saying is­ that the modern F1 circuits that are used are too wide­ , flat and have no character and i have to agree. As­ for danger, if we really want MotoGP to be safe we­ might as well just watch the riders asleep in bed.­ Danger is exciting. Sure, deaths are a tragedy and Kato­ will always be remembered as a great rider and human­ being and he died doing what he loved most.
    I love­ motorbikes and I hate the fact that so called fans, not­ the riders or their families, want bike sport to be so­ safe it’s boring. Long live the TT and Irish­ road races.

    From bikernut, on Fri 2 Jan 12:40PM
  19. i dont agree, i think the wsb is far from the standard­ of the motogp, when i went to brands hatch for the wsb­ it was boring and seemed slow, unlike when i went to le­ mans for the moto gp it was thrilling and enjoyable,­ moto gp will survive.

    From Stuart, on Fri 2 Jan 11:42AM
  20. Glen, 2 of those tracks are F1 circuits anyway only­ Suzuka is not and that is too dangerous anyway(Kato­ says it all)

    I'm not one for the sour grapes­ theory guys i have to agree the past few years have­ been boring and yes WSBK is full on and they use some­ fantastic tracks. I remember seeing the race from­ Valelunga and what a track that is and also­ Portamino(the new one) will be a spectacle.

    I hope the­ tyres rule brings them closer and i am one that wants­ the electronics reduced( just go watch some old footage­ of the 1st few years of the 990cc and see how good they­ look power sliding the bikes)

    Back to basics is the­ only way.

    From , on Fri 2 Jan 11:34AM
Sort comments by: Most recent

Not already a Yahoo! user ? to get a free Yahoo! Account