Lions 2009 - Smit worried by appeal loss

Eurosport - Fri, 03 Jul 11:29:00 2009

Springboks captain John Smit hopes Bakkies Botha was being victimised when he was hit by a two-week ban and he fears the game could be changing.

John Smit - South Africa - 0

South Africa lock Botha was suspended for a dangerous charge on Lions prop Adam Jones in the second test that left the Welshman with a dislocated shoulder. Botha lost his appeal against the ban and will miss the final test Saturday.

Springboks flanker Schalk Burger also received an eight-week ban after the game for gouging.

"We are deeply saddened and angered more than anything else by the outcome of the Bakkies Botha appeal," Smit (pictured) said.

"I hope and pray it's just a case of Bakkies being victimised. If it's not, then it could change this wonderful game we play."

South Africa took an unassailable 2-0 lead in the series after winning a brutal encounter in Pretoria 28-25.

Smit said the incident that led to Botha's suspension was part and parcel of every rugby game and suggested the decision could set an unwanted precedent.

"Sanity did not prevail at the appeal and I've had referees phoning me, and support from the Lions management and players that it is very concerning for the future of the game.

"Unfortunately Adam Jones got injured purely because his arm was stuck in the ruck. If Bryan Habana is running down the wing as fast as a cheetah, it would be really poor for the game to make him slow down in case he hurts the tackler."

Smit, who captained South Africa to World Cup glory in 2007, said he expected Saturday's Test to be an excellent contest and hoped it would be played in a good spirit.

"I sincerely hope there's no bad blood between the two teams. Rugby's all about running into each other at a million miles an hour and tackling each other at a million miles an hour, stitching oneself up afterwards and sharing a beer," Smit said.

"There is still a massive amount for us to play for because we don't get the opportunity to play against the Lions for another 12 years.

"It's been a phenomenal series, although it's probably easier for me to say that as the captain that's won."

Smit acknowledged the difficulties the Lions face on tour but said the concept was one envied by other teams.

"The challenge the Lions have is far greater than any other team we face because they have a limited amount of time to gel," he said.

"They spend the Six Nations smashing each other and then they have to come together and create a brotherhood. They've created that camaraderie on this tour and I think the Lions are really envied by other teams."

Reuters

Comment 1 - 13 of 33

Sort comments by: Most recent
  1. Lets have a good, hard but clean game tomorrow. Yes,­ Botha was maybe a bit unlucky, but it gives someone­ else a chance to shine. Anyway he probably got away­ with it in the past when he shouldn't have. I­ shall be there and supporting the Boks. To the Lions­ supporters, your chaps have played great rugby and the­ 2 tests have been epic encounters. You have been a bit­ unlucky not to get at least one win, but the players­ have done you proud.

    From Dave, on Fri 3 Jul 2:54PM
  2. Delighted to see such fair and gentlemanly comments­ from the springbok captain, he and his team deserve­ their victory. And I quite agree with him when he says­ that the ban to bakkies botha was harsh.

    From timdalyjnr, on Fri 3 Jul 2:44PM
  3. law 16.2 (b) states "A player joining a ruck must­ bind onto the ruck with at least one arm around the­ body of a team-mate, using the whole arm.
    Penalty:­ Penalty Kick" and as it's an act of foul play,­ carding and banning is reasonable.
    Yes it's a­ contact sport and "it's only illegal if you­ get caught" but he did get caught and should take­ his punishment without whining. That would show he was­ a true rugby player. Whatever happened to "A­ Thug's Game Played by Gentlemen"?

    From sean_oliver, on Fri 3 Jul 2:28PM
  4. Donal d is one of these clever arse*s that likes to try­ and put a monkey boy spanner in the works on every­ site.
    I think he comes from the f1 site and posts these­ snidey little remarks to give hinself a cheap thrill.­
    Dont worry he knows as much about rugby as he does­ f1...(nought)

    From teatotaller, on Fri 3 Jul 2:20PM
  5. My allegiance is London Irish. Well done Exiles for­ last season but please, silverware is needed this­ season. As for South Africa v Lions, the gouging was­ disgraceful and the defence of it, equally disgusting.­ The ban should have been much longer but I guess the­ Board felt 8 weeks is enough for blinding someone. The­ Botha tackle was unlucky and maybe mistimed but I have­ seen mistimed tackles at every Premiership game. I­ think Botha should be reprieved and Burger banned for a­ year.

    From The Xentertainer, on Fri 3 Jul 2:09PM
  6. A serious injury sustained on the pitch moes not stay­ on the pitch - the victim may have to live with it for­ the rest of their life.

    From Donald D, on Fri 3 Jul 2:02PM
  7. i've just watched the botha tackle again and to be­ honest i don't see too much wrong with it. fair­ enough it was a bit late but the challenge itself­ didn't look too bad. it was unfortunate that jones­ got injured but i think the ban could be a reaction to­ the burger incident, i.e a yellow card, 8 week ban etc.­ burger should have had a much more severe punishment­ for intentional gouging while personally i think­ they've been a bit @#$% botha. i'm english by­ the way, not that it matters but for some reason you­ can't comment about rugby anymore without stating­ what country you're from and where your allegiances­ lie.

    From Dave, on Fri 3 Jul 1:17PM
  8. It's simple, what happens on the pitch stays on the­ pitch. It is one of the reasons i have played this­ game for a long time and watched it with admiration. ­ That last game was nothing more than a brilliant epic­ encounter between two excellent teams, i for one­ can't wait for the next one.

    From ben_hampshire, on Fri 3 Jul 1:02PM
  9. i am a little tired of people having a go a English­ fans being vicious and vile etc. It a small minority­ that are morons, but in the main we enjoy a good game­ of rugby, whoever its against. I have watched in pubs­ and watched live many internationals , seven­ tournaments and and have never seen any trouble between­ the fans.
    I for one will support any of the home­ nations when playing teams from around the world and I­ love the the whole concept of the lions. Its a shame­ the supporters cant find the same togetherness.

    From cartman, on Fri 3 Jul 12:22PM
  10. 100% agree we need to protect the game from the pc do­ gooders. There is no reason whatsoever to have cited­ Botha, it was a good hard clean tackle and the injury­ to Adam Jones was pretty much self inflicted by his own­ poor positioning. However, on the other hand Burger­ deserved everything he got. There is no place in this­ glorious game for such cowardly and dirty play.­ I've always rated Burger as a good strong no­ nonsense player and respected him for that. But now?­ Hes just a chicken who has to gouge the eyes of a­ player half his size and from behind? Despicable and I­ hope that next time he's touring in the northern­ hemishpere he gets what should be coming to him. Not a­ gouge, just a bloody good smack in he teeth. Anyway­ he's not playing tomorrow so lets have a really­ good, hard uncompromising but fair end to the series.­ Well done the Boks, you've deserved the victory.

    From Steve, on Fri 3 Jul 12:20PM
  11. During my Rugby playing days in the 1950's thru­ 1960, in the UK and Northern Rhodesia, I have been­ Bashed, Battered in virtually every game, but Rugby is­ Unique, after the game everybody is Pals and we join­ and have A Few (quite a Few) Beers, thats what makes­ Rugby Union the best game in the world "Off the­ Field" all is forgiven over a Drink, TomVumba ex­ Nchanga

    From THOMAS, on Fri 3 Jul 12:05PM
  12. Well,i/we have supported over 500 games in various­ parts of the world and have only experienced anything­ but camaraderie,
    HOWEVER recently returning to England­ have been on the receiving end of vicious and vile­ behaviour from English supporters for being perceived­ as not supporting the English teams.
    I believe that­ some of the barbaric behaviour can be blamed on the­ still tribal,"little mentality" fermented in­ pubs across the country.!!!

    From ,...,, on Fri 3 Jul 12:00PM
  13. Whatever happenned to the civility and cameraderie of­ Rugby Union. It is what set us apart from all other­ sports. Hard, physical contact on the field but mutual­ respect and comradeship off the field, with no­ recriminations whatsoever. In over 500 games of senior­ rugby I witnessed only two off the field acts that­ would be regarded as unacceptable behaviour. But,­ nowadays the games are increasingly being watched by­ people who have never actually played the game and­ experienced that unique on field/off field experience­ and those people show no respect to the game and its­ traditions. How long before supporters start to fight­ with each other. We are on the precipice of a dangerous­ slope and we must all pull together to make sure we do­ not start the irreversable slide into the abyss. Rugby­ officials have a responsibility to encourage players,­ fans and particularly coaches to set an example of very­ high propotion.

    From BigRich, on Fri 3 Jul 11:38AM
Sort comments by: Most recent

Not already a Yahoo! user ? to get a free Yahoo! Account