Eurosport - Mon, 05 Jan 10:56:00 2009
Reaction from the FA Cup third round matches, including Southampton boss Jan Poortvliet slamming Manchester United's offside opening goal.
Southampton 0-3 Manchester United
Jan Poortvliet: "It (the first goal) was offside. The referee's assistant should see it because he is on the same line as the player. They told me (Paterson) went with two feet (for the sending off). It was one foot and it was on the ball. It changed the game because you are always having to come back. I think the penalty was cheap. The referee was in the best position. I think the referees in England are the best in the world. But our side, we never get decisions like that.
"It's a shame. I feel sorry for the boys because I think they worked hard. If only we could have created more opportunities."
Alex Ferguson: "We could have done it more comfortably but 3-0 is a satisfactory score.
"I think if the referee had booked him (Paterson) in the first minute it might have calmed him down a bit. It was exuberance more than than anything else. He was charging about a bit and tackling, all the things you expect from a young player and he was a bit over-enthusiastic maybe."
Mark Stimson: "I'm proud of the players first and foremost. I thought they did well out there today playing against a very strong Aston Villa side and gave a good account of themselves.
"On the result, I'm frustrated, we were close to maybe getting a draw and going back to Villa Park."
Martin O'Neill: "It was really tough. I came here last week and knew it would be tough. If the players didn't know it would be tough they did after 10 minutes. They are very strong. They played very well and good luck to them this season.
"It was a terrific goal by James, very well worked, a nice goal indeed."
Preston North End 0-2 Liverpool
Alan Irvine: "People said they were disappointed that Steven Gerrard was playing, and I suppose I was pleased initially to see Fernando Torres on the bench. But then again our lads have been excited ever since the draw, and that was because they wanted to play against Liverpool's big stars. It has been an education for them. For Sean St Ledger to be facing Torres was a great education for him.
Sammy Lee: "Steven is a top professional, he has had the full support of this club, and you see what he is after that performance. He is a great footballer, he produced a terrific performance. Things have been written about him, but we know that he is a terrific professional, a model professional and this club will put all our support behind Stevie Gerrard. But he is a great servant for this club, a great ambassador and we will continue to support him throughout, he's a terrific guy."
Manchester City 0-3 Nottingham Forest
Mark Hughes: ''I know exactly what is needed here. The work we do on a day-to-day basis makes players better. They have to be brave enough to perform in matches. Today some were guilty of not doing that. We know the areas of the squad we have to strengthen and we will try to do that. It is not going to happen in this window, or even two or three. We need more time.
'We are bitterly disappointed with the level of performance that we produced today. Nottingham Forest fully deserved to win. 'They showed more desire and energy in their play. They forced us into errors and took their chances.''
John Pemberton (temporary boss before Billy Davies takes charge on Monday): Billy spoke with the players this morning but he wanted to leave it today because it was such short notice. I just wanted the lads to give a good account of themselves and get them ready to play.
''Winning is fantastic but on Monday morning I will be back to my normal job, getting the reserve team ready for a game against Lincoln City away on Wednesday. Today was probably the highlight of my career. To win 3-0 against a Manchester City side stuffed with talent - and deserve it - was fabulous.''
Chelsea 1-1 Southend
Luiz Felipe Scolari: "It was not very good - but on the pitch, what can I say to my players? They had 15 chances to score a goal, and they didn't score. Carlo (Cudicini) didn't make a save. Our mistake was not scoring a second goal. We have to discuss the mistakes we made. This happens in football. I have these players, I believe in these players, and now we need to train."
Steve Tilson: "We were playing one of the top sides in this country and this is a fantastic day for the club, our supporters and everyone involved today. We rode our luck at times and you need that in games like this. Our goalkeeper has made some great saves and Chelsea could have been comfortably in front from the chances they created."
Hartlepool 2-0 Stoke
Chris Turner: "I couldn't have asked any more of the individuals. They were up against a very strong, powerful team, but they stuck at their task and were very concentrated. When that whistle went it was the best feeling I have ever felt even though as a player, I played and won at Wembley."
Tony Pulis: "It was disappointing. I didn't think there was much in the game in the first half - if anything, I thought we were the better team. Then when they got their goal, from that point onwards, I thought Hartlepool were the better team and deserved to win."
Forest Green 3-4 Derby County
Jim Harvey: "We were 3-2 up again in the second half and I thought that might be enough but it was not to be. To take the lead three times against Derby was magnificent for a club our size and I think the people here had terrific entertainment. But on reflection, we had it within our grasp to win it - we had believed we could do that for the whole game."
Chris Hutchings: "We were very lucky to go in level at 2-2 at half-time. We kept going at it right to the death - I suppose it was a classic cup tie with lots of goals and tackles and a sending off for our penalty. It was a good, honest cup tie and I'm glad we stayed strong to win it."
Macclesfield Town 0-1 Everton
Keith Alexander: "They are a good team and we made life difficult for them. Everton had the majority of the play but we had the better chances. On another day at least one of them would have gone in and Nat Brown needed to put that one away. That has been the story of our season. We have been playing good football but conceding sloppy goals and that has happened again. I have seen penalties like that given but not often against Premier League teams. But I don't want to moan."
Steve Round: "His[goalkeeper Tim Howard] form has been excellent. I have been very impressed with him. Credit to Tim. He had little to do all game but kept his concentration and made a great save at the end. Macclesfield were hanging in there and took us to the wire. They almost nicked an equaliser at the end."
Arsene Wenger: "I give credit to my team for doing the job seriously, and also to Plymouth who had a great game as well. I was surprised how well they were organised and how strong they were in every challenge. They did not die physically and were always dangerous on set plays. The gap between the Championship and the Premiership has been reduced and looking at the FA Cup results today, you could see that."
Paul Sturrock: "I am very pleased with the team's overall performance, but gutted to have given away those two goals just after half-time when I had warned the players what to expect. That really kicked us in the teeth, but we dug deep to get out a goal and if someone had told me that just seven minutes from the end we would be chasing the game against Arsenal, a world-class team, I would have bitten their hand off. The fans were fantastic, and I am glad we got a goal for them to celebrate, and hopefully they will go home appreciating the boys gave all they had."
Hull City 0-0 Newcastle United
Phil Brown: "You can go on about goalline technology but it is inconclusive and impossible for the linesman to give that. Shay [Given] does look like he has stepped over the line to save the ball. Damien Duff has done fantastically at the back post to get a touch, certainly if he doesn't Michael Turner scores."
Chris Hughton: "We have got used to that type of performance from him [Given]. He is a top quality goalkeeper and a top quality individual - but we wouldn't expect anything different from him. Their players are always going to see it going over the line and ours could see it for what is was, hit the crossbar, went into Shay Given's hands and certainly not over the line."
Comment 29 - 48 of 48
same old man utd all ways cheating sir alex myass 4 the chop liverpool 4 ever
I wish gaynaldo gets fuuucked by sever injury puts him on a wheel cheer
Having watched the game at St Mary,s I would like to comment on the "Got the Ball, not the shin foul". Previous comments on the subject are quite right, Patterson went in with his studs showing - that is an illegal challenge and should be punished with a straight Red. With regards to the first goal as the ball was put in a Southampton player pushed the Manu player towards the goal - that should have been a penalty! If you ask me the Southampton manager should be ashamed of the way his team played, especially with all the fouls that they dished out - it seems to me that they were intent on fouling as many players as possible.
Yes, I agree, the refereeing did leave a bit to be desired, but how many of you so called "experts" in the Laws of the Game could referee a kindergarten 5 a side match?
It wasn't so long back that the blue half of Manchester was crowing about getting one of the best young managers around. Hughes was not at fault for Man C's inability to beat Forest. That is down to the 11 'players' who pulled on the shirt. On paper the team Hughes put out should have easily beaten Forest. I'd say the fact that Foerst easily beat City says far more about the attitude and pride of the City players than anything about Hughes.
United also faced lower league opposition and played with a weakend side the difference was that the players wanted to play for the shirt. Yes United got lucky with the offside goal, but the tackle on Vidic could quite easily have broken his leg.
neil w, YOU ARE RIGHT, THE SAINTS MANAGER SHOULD HAVE GONE TO SPEC SAVERS ! OR BETTER STILL GET BACK TO HOLLAND.
Suzanne B, Can't you find some housework to do pet!!!!
the saints manager deserves to be in trouble for trying to defend that foul on vidic
***** MISSION ACOMPLISHED ****** MARK HUGHES COME HOME NOW ******* ONCE A RED ALWAYS A RED ****** Oh yeh !! City have lots n lots of Money ... he he !! so they go for Craig Bellamy !!!!! ... me not understand.... andy parfitt manchester
We need football heroes in Wales and Sparky is one of them. Sacking him will just make it worse as he has no say at all in who the mega rich boys will want to bring in. I am sure the Robinho steal was a surprise to him. It must be extremely difficult managing a group of bigheads who all want to be in the starting line up and it is not going to improve after this month as it will be hard to keep up with the comings and goings. Mid table for City at best but give him a chance for God's sake. He is a good strong manager
THE SAINTS MANAGER IS A TOTAL FOOL IF HE DONT KNOW THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN A BALL AND A SHIN ,, YOUR TEAM WAS BEATEN AND MANU , I THINK DID NOT WORK UP A SWEAT , THE BOY WHO WAS SENT OFF WAS RUNNING ROUND LIKE A HEADLESS CHICKEN , IT WAS ONLY TIME BEFORE HE WAS GOING TO DO AN IDIOT MISTAKE , ALSO IT DID NOT CHANGE THE GAME , MANU COULD HAVE COME OUT OF WARM UP MOLD AND SAINTS WOULD HAVE NOT BEEN WITH THEM AS IT PROVED THROUGHOUT THE GAME ,,, A VERY POOR SIDE BUT GOOD KEEPER ONLY .LOOKS LIKE A BIG FIGHT TO AVOID RELEGATION FOR SAINTS ,,,,
the saints manager cant tell the difference between a football and a shin, he must be @#$%-eyed. 1st goal was offside, penalty was harsh but if you put your arm up you got to expect it, but if vidic had done that to patterson you would be screaming for his head.
Inside info from Man City staff is that - 'all transfers will be halted temporarily whilst the board decide what to do with Hughes.' Thank God!!!
bring back sven or get jose before city go down a league
Hughes just GO AWAY man!
First move for City is to get a new manager!
The day we bring in cameras to do the decision making will totally ruin football, players and managers will want every decision from corners to throw ins, offsides, fouls etc. It will not work, end of.
Mark Hughes has been found out for what he is not a good manager no what a mean
Hi Ashley B with the mustach as bigger than your brain! who wrote :- stop dreaming, it was never over the line. No amount of wingeing is going to make it so...
The result wasnt a goal your right there but it does not alter the truth which isn't important to you or the football league, or Given.
Cannot argue about the result because the Ref decides that one but there can only be one truth even though it doesn't mean anything in soccer or your ideals.
I aint winging or dreaming... I do not support either teams involved.. but true results in soccer are long overdue.. every other sport has sorted it out with technology, there would be no wrong decisions then.
Ali - M, stop dreaming, it was never over the line. No amount of wingeing is going to make it so...
HUGHES is apretty good manager, but when you take over a club that is owned by filthy rich............you gotta say WHO is deciding on BUYING!!!
JOSE had the same trouble at CHELSEA but found a way round it until it got too much!!!
fancy having a red icon as your manager !!!!!! man you strike again from the inside .... ;-))))))))))))
Please login to post a comment
Not already a Yahoo! user ? Sign up to get a free Yahoo! Account