Where did it all go wrong for Japan?

Eurosport - Tue, 06 Oct 11:13:00 2009

Japanese motor racing fans are wondering where it all went.

FORMULA 1 2007 Australian GP Takuma Sato Super Aguri - 0

Once, their nation was home to three Formula One teams, two grand prix tracks and several drivers - but there is little left to cheer for.

Japan's most successful F1 driver, Takuma Sato, has been out of the sport since his Super Aguri team folded in April last year; the country's sole starting driver, Kazuki Nakajima of Williams, has scored no points this season and may be looking for work next year.

The Honda team pulled out of the expensive sport at the end of last year, to be reborn as British-based Brawn GP, while the Toyota team survive, based in Germany, but have yet to win a grand prix despite pouring money into the sport since their debut in 2002.

The picture is equally depressing for home fans in the World Rally Championship, which lost Suzuki and former winners Subaru, and in motorcycling where Kawasaki now equip only one rider, Italian Marco Melandri, in the MotoGP.

Japanese fans still hope Sato, 32, might return to F1 and give the country a reason to cheer again.

"I like Takuma and want him to come back," said Miko Inaba, a fan from Tokyo who was at the Japanese Grand Prix in Suzuka at the weekend. "I really don't think much of Nakajima."

Sato never won a race but became a national hero when he made his points debut at his home track of Suzuka in 2002.

"When Sato was with Honda, he was more popular than (then team-mate Jenson) Button," said another fan, Yuji Endo. "For Japanese, we want to know if Sato is coming back."

Sato, who had one podium place when he finished third at the 2004 US Grand Prix, told Reuters his sudden exit had left unfinished business and he wanted to return as Japan needed an F1 hero.

"In the next few years, if they don't have a driver to cheer, it will be difficult," Sato said. "If there is a driver, it makes a huge difference."

He compared Japan without a successful national in the sport to Spain before the F1 success of Fernando Alonso with Renault.

"Before Alonso, everything was motorcycles. F1 was very small."

Nakajima, son of former racer Satoru and backed by the Williams team's current engine provider Toyota, is willing to fill the gap but, with a glut of drivers available and weak results this season, he may not get the chance.

"This year is obviously very frustrating because I'm doing a much better job in many aspects but somehow I haven't managed to get results," he told Reuters. "Results are important, especially for fans' attention."

Toyota's Italian driver Jarno Trulli gave the team their second successive runner-up spot at Suzuka but German Timo Glock did not start Sunday's race after injuring his leg in a qualifying crash.

Button is close to winning the championship with Brawn but was initially left without a car at the end of last year after the withdrawal of Honda, who had scored just 20 points in two seasons despite an estimated annual budget of more than $300 million.

Nakajima finished 15th on Sunday, keeping him without points this season after he earned nine in 2008.

He said national ardour for F1 might cool without a native in the sport, adding that harsh financial conditions for Japanese firms, traditionally backers of the sport, had led to changes in commitment.

Honda, Japan's second largest carmaker, still owns the Suzuka track but Toyota gave up its rights to host at Fuji International Speedway, citing costs. The track had been due to alternate with Suzuka each year.

"For the big car manufacturers the situation is really tough," Nakajima said.

Kamui Kobayashi has been competing in the GP2 support series this season for Toyota and is a practice F1 driver, but says his future is uncertain next year as companies keep a tight rein on budgets.

"I'm trying to be a race driver but now it's very difficult to say when even third drivers are changing," he said.

For some fans, nostalgia is the only comfort.

"I liked Takuma when he was with Honda but it doesn't seem likely he's going to come back," said Masayuki Kadowaki, a Toyota fan.

His 16-year-old daughter, wearing Ferrari colours, had no time for sentiment about Sato, however.

"He's done," she said simply.

Reuters

Comment 8 - 27 of 27

Sort comments by: Most recent
  1. Fia should consider awarding extra points to teams that­ have stayed within the rules or 'clean' for a­ certain time if like some people suggest that cheating­ is near standard in F1-That would please the big money­ teams to no end..not,and make it fairer for everyone.

    From wizzo, on Wed 7 Oct 12:06PM
  2. arshad, I admit Brazil slipped my mind. While not part­ of the "F1 (European) Triangle" I alluded to,­ it cannot really be classified as the same as Japan or­ Spain (Brazil has shown support for F1 with a passion­ of the big three Europeans even when they don't­ have a driver of note), nor can it be classifies like­ Belgium or the USA (because it does have someone to­ cheer for most of the time). They fit comfortably in­ the gap in between these latter two and the central­ three, and are the moon to the world that centres­ there, always there and always pulling at the tides of­ F1 without fail (and with full justification).

    From SixOneSix, on Wed 7 Oct 9:44AM
  3. A suggestion, Get rid of Ecclestone and replace him­ with a person, or group of investors who really have­ the welfare of F1 at heart. Then completely­ restructure the FIA and build a sport with races, at­ much lower cost to promote, at venues in the­ traditional F1 countries of Italy, Germany, Britain,­ France, Belgium, Monaco, and Spain. Then races in­ Australia, Japan, India, China, and Malaysia. Add to­ that races in Brazil, Mexico, and Argentina along with­ Canada and the United States. That is seventeen races­ at venues that should be able to support them. The­ races in Asia are going to be necessary because­ sponsorship is going to come, increasingly from those­ developing countries.

    Allow privateer teams to­ purchase chassis and engines from approved suppliers. ­ Require that F1 promote all races through the rights­ holder exclusively, at his/their cost. Require that­ the FIA fully staff the race meets with fully trained­ and experienced corner workers, emergency and medical­ personnel with a fully equipped emergency clinic, and­ professional race stewards beholden only to F1. The­ only connection with the venue is that they have a­ contract with the rights holder.

    Then maybe the sport­ can thrive, grow, and maybe represent the nations that­ participate in it.

    From larsonrc41, on Wed 7 Oct 5:13AM
  4. Let's examine another facet of why Japanese drivers­ haven't been successful in F1, and even GP@, F2,­ F3000, and F3 to cover most of the feeder series for­ the last 40 years or so. Almost always, in F1 the team­ was forced to use a driver selected by Toyota, or­ Honda, who were the engine suppliers or putative team­ owners. There is nothing slower, or more hard headed­ than a driver who knows he will still have his seat at­ the end of the day because he got the seat because he­ was Japanese and not due to any overwhelming exhibition­ of driving talent. It sounds provincial as all hell,­ but there it is.

    None of the young Japanese drivers­ are required to progress through the feeder series in­ order to prove their ability against the best yound­ drivers of Europe and those Aussie, American, and­ Canadian drivers who do race in Europe to work there­ way up. If the U.S. didn't have NASCAR, ALMS,­ Rolex Series, and IndyCar for young drivers to aspire­ to be successful in, then maybe they would be forces to­ be dealt with in competing for drives in F1. A yound­ american road racer can live at home and drive to all­ his race meets and if successful become very well off,­ so why live like a cretin to save enough money to get­ to the next race in a series where no one understands­ what you are saying and really doesn't give a damn­ whether you succeed or not. Why do it at all.

    I­ suspect that if Toyota, or Honda would subscribe to­ supporting a couple of young drivers, like the young­ Aussies and New Zeelanders used to have in the 50's­ and 60's. Support them with Japanese teams, teach­ them English, and bring them along with a support­ system, then maybe in 6 to 8 years there might actually­ be a Japanese driver competing for a championship.

    From larsonrc41, on Wed 7 Oct 4:56AM
  5. Japanese drivers dont' have the talent, background­ nor the will(courage) to win in F1. And sons of former­ champions are never as good as the father.

    From massimo, on Wed 7 Oct 4:02AM
  6. If I may, I will like to say that Formula 1 is not that­ big in America because is hard to follow for the time­ difference.
    I do live in the East cost ( Washington DC­ area) and on Sundays, I have to be up at 8 in the­ morning!!!!! :( to catch it on the laptop.
    If is hard­ to follow, is hard to get to know drivers, brands,­ circuits, hard to become a fan....
    I am from­ Argentina, from the time when Carlos Reutemann used to­ race and became a fan then !

    From M Ferreira, on Tue 6 Oct 11:09PM
  7. Great comment 616.
    I'd just like to add that in­ Spain before Alonso , the Spanish GP didn't even­ begin to fill. They couldn't give the tickets­ away!
    They were so desperate for a Spanish F1 driver­ that the TV commentators "adopted"­ Heinz-Harold Frenzen as an honorary Spaniard! (He has a­ Spanish mother). Gené and De la Rosa, for differing­ reasons, were disappointments (despite the fact I rate­ DLR).
    Once Alonso began to do well in Renault F1 fever­ attracted the futboleros on their days off and suddenly­ F1 was outselling Moto GP!
    Once Alonso bombs, which I­ feel he will as he's had two lucky escapes now, F1­ will be forgotten in a country with two (of the worst)­ GPs.

    From Count Louis Zborowski, on Tue 6 Oct 9:29PM
  8. Japan seems to produce top-flight motorcycle racers­ (Noriyuki Haga, Nori Abe, Tetsuya Harada et al), but it­ is strange the nation has never produced a race-winning­ F1 driver. I thought Taku Sato would be the one, but­ his machinery was never quite up to it, there was a­ youngster in the 90's, Tora (Tiger)Tanake, but he­ didn't stay in the top flight long enough. I for­ one would love to see a Japanese pilot on the top step­ of the podium and fighting for the Championship. I­ agree with Neil M, Taku Sato was above Grosjean, Piquet­ and co. in ability and experience, so why no seat? His­ one-time team-mate Ant Davidson is no slouch either.

    From Only Human After All, on Tue 6 Oct 7:33PM
  9. SixOneSix, excellent comment no.17. You perfectly­ summed up how fickle the fans can be in some countries.­ There are empty stands in Spain when Alonso isn't­ in the top five while I remember the Brits roaring­ their hearts out when Hamilton passed Alonso for 15th­ this year. Britain, Italy, Germany, Belgium and Canada­ are passionate about F1 but don't know about­ America. I'll also add Brazil into the mix for­ having one of the most passionate fans but maybe that­ is because they have had a potential race winning­ Brazilian racing throughout the years

    From arshad_iceman2, on Tue 6 Oct 6:51PM
  10. You could say a stagnant Rising sun...

    From wizzo, on Tue 6 Oct 6:48PM
  11. 93 starts, 1 podium and Sato is considered the best­ ever Japanese driver in F1? 93 races and he's just­ getting to grips with the car?

    From DingoAteYourBaby, on Tue 6 Oct 6:46PM
  12. Bishop, I refrained from including America as an­ example because F1 has had much more of a following­ there historically than it has in say Spain. My gripe­ is the pandering to fickle nations with no long term­ interest in the sport.

    In Spain, ticket sales to the­ two GPs have fallen in 2009 and 2008 compared to 2007­ and 2006. And what is the big difference in those­ years? Fernando Alonso is no longer a reigning Wolrd­ Champion with a car competitive enough to make him a­ race winner. The F1 hype in Spain is tantamount to­ glory hunting and is very much dependent upon the­ success of their kinsman. Watch ticket sales jump­ again next year if Ferrari start the season with a­ winning car, and watch them continue to stagnate if­ their new charge strands Alonso towards the back of the­ grid.

    And the same short term fickle support can be­ seen in 2009 in Turkey for example. Not the best, but­ definately one of the better tracks on the F1 calendar,­ and yet the grandstands were virtually empty.

    Now­ compare that to the "heartland" of F1 -­ Britain, Germany & Italy. The three countries­ around which the sport is arguably based. In Britain­ you still saw support for a lacklustre Lewis Hamilton,­ and how many other fans through away the idea of­ national pride to support Ferrari? In Germany they may­ have had Vettel to cheer about this year, but they­ still didn't struggle with crowds in 2007 &­ 2008 with no German challenger for the title because­ the fans love the sport. And in Italy Ferrari fans­ make Monza a pilgrimage - even when Ferrari aren't­ winning.

    And then there are 3 host countries that have­ no real national identity in the sport but always seem­ to draw large crowds - Belgium, Canada and America. ­ Why? Because the fans there are of the same cut as the­ 3 places above - they are F1 fans first (whether they­ realise it or not).

    From SixOneSix, on Tue 6 Oct 6:32PM
  13. Wizzo. simple answer; NO! It's that sort of sport.

    From the real adrian, on Tue 6 Oct 6:24PM
  14. Adrian,is there ANYONE who has not been playing with­ the rules.

    From wizzo, on Tue 6 Oct 5:54PM
  15. Wizzo, Toyota were caught cheating big time in the WRC­ & had to sit out a year so they are not whiter than­ white. Also I believe Honda F1 were caught­ "bending the rules" over using fuel as­ ballast.

    From the real adrian, on Tue 6 Oct 5:26PM
  16. Sato could do a solid journeyman's job - no more.

    From markrose260, on Tue 6 Oct 3:44PM
  17. @SixOneSix, you make a good point. F1 is fairly popular­ in the US, even without an American F1 team or drivers.­ Few will wax poetically about the heady days of Mario­ Andretti or Phil Hill in this modern era of F1.­ Americans have a completely different problem: too much­ of everything. Too many different series to follow,­ both motorsports and other sports. Will overall­ American interest improve when USF1 comes around?­ Doubtful, but I look forward to it anyways. Will USF1­ find decent enough American drivers? Hard to say. We­ have good drivers here, but few grow up dreaming about­ F1, like they do in the EU. That's a different­ mindset that hasn't always gone well when we cross­ the Pond. Our effort probably won't meet your­ standard, SixOneSix. But it's no less worthy to­ cheer about it.

    From Bishop, on Tue 6 Oct 3:30PM
  18. Maybe they are the only ones who have not been­ 'cheating'.

    From wizzo, on Tue 6 Oct 3:06PM
  19. Japanese drivers have never succeed in F1, they have­ had the sponsors but not the results, but Japan has had­ no stand out driver. Honda has been the only shining­ light for Japanese F1 motoersport, but sadly the Honda­ F1 team failed mainly due to it's driver line ups­ over the years. Toyota should have remained in­ sportscars and had success in that type of motorsport­ before making the switch to F1. Mazda are the only­ Japanese constructor to win Le Mans back in 1991.­ Toyota and Honda should have focused on supplying­ engines only to teams in F1, and not become the team­ itself.

    From formula1police, on Tue 6 Oct 2:48PM
  20. There's alot of realy good drivers in Japan but­ they have no wish to be treated like a second class­ person by the round eye Europeans of F1 !

    From RON, on Tue 6 Oct 2:40PM
Sort comments by: Most recent

Not already a Yahoo! user ? to get a free Yahoo! Account