Champions League - Top 10 ref controversies

Eurosport - Thu, 07 May 13:58:00 2009

Ok Chelsea fans, we hear you, Tom Henning Ovrebo was awful and you were robbed etc, etc....

FOOTBALL 2006 World Cup Graham Poll Josip Simunic - 0

But there is no need to engage in hyperbole and call it "the worst refereeing performance of all time". Not when there is so much competition for that honour.

Try these examples out for size.

Watford v Reading - Championship 2008 - Referee: Stuart Attwell

Reading's Stephen Hunt whipped in a corner but it hit Watford's John Eustace on the thigh and went two yards wide for another corner - or so every one of the 14,761 fans in the ground thought. Not assistant referee Nigel Bannister, who somehow managed to convince referee Stuart Attwell that the ball had gone into the back of the net. "Probably the worst decision I've ever witnessed in football," said benefactor Hunt. The Watford players and fans were a little less choice with their words.

Croatia v Australia - World Cup 2006 - Referee: Graham Poll

Graham Poll made an absolute howler when he booked Josip Simunic three times and failed to spot Harry Kewell offside for one of Australia's goals in this World Cup group game. The Socceroos drew 2-2 and qualified for the next round but Sepp Blatter later commented that "had Australia lost the game and gone out of the World Cup, they would have had grounds to request a replay".

Manchester United v Tottenham - Premier League 2005 - Referee: Mark Clattenburg

Roy Carroll made a hash of a long-range effort from Pedro Mendes near the end of this Premier League game but amazingly got away with it. The ball dropped at least a yard over the line before Carroll gained control, but referee Mark Clattenburg and his officials somehow missed this fact and the match finished 0-0.

Portugal v England - Euro 2004 - Referee: Urs Meier

Sol Campbell's last minute 'winner' against the tournament hosts was ruled out by Swiss referee Urs Meier due to a 'foul' by John Terry on the Portugal goalkeeper. England lost on penalties and Meier was forced into hiding after receiving 16,000 items of hate mail. 'Urs hole' and 'Swiss banker' were amongst the highlight headlines in the British tabloids the next day.

South Korea v Italy and South Korea v Spain - World Cup 2002 - Referee: Byron Moreno (Italy match) and Gamal Al-Ghandour (Spain match).

Guus Hiddink has not always been the victim of bad refereeing performances. His South Korea side made it to the semi-finals of the 2002 World Cup with more than a little help from officials. In the second round, Italy were left fuming at Ecuadorian Byron Moreno as they had a goal disallowed, a penalty shout turned down, and Francesco Totti sent off for diving. In the quarters, Spain had two goals chalked off by Egyptian referee Gamal Al-Ghandour before losing on penalties.

Middlesbrough v Chesterfield - FA Cup 1997 - Referee: David Elleray

Third-tier Chesterfield were 2-1 up against Middlesbrough in their FA Cup semi-final and looked set for an unlikely place in the final when Jonathan Howard crashed a goal in off the underside of the bar to seemingly make it 3-1. However, referee David Elleray said the ball hadn't crossed the line and Middlesbrough came back and won the match on a replay.

Argentina v England - World Cup 1986 - Referee: Ali Bin Nasser

'Hand of God' - need we say any more? If Tunisia referee Ali Bin Nasser is granted an obituary in any of the English papers then it will be because of this and this alone.

France v Germany - World Cup 1982 - Referee: Charles Corver

Dutch referee Charles Corver inexplicabley awarded a goalkick when German keeper Harald Schumacher smashed into French defender Patrick Battiston during their World Cup semi-final in Spain. Battiston was sent to hospital in a coma while Schumacher helped Germany win the match on penalties.

Coventry v Crystal Palace - Division One 1980 - Referee: Derek Webb

Crystal Palace's Clive Allen fired home a perfect free kick into the top corner against Coventry at Highfield Road. The ball cannoned off the stanchion and back into play. Referee Derek Webb thought it had hit the crossbar and waved play on. Palace protested but to no avail. They went on to lose 3-1.

Brazil v Sweden - World Cup 1978 - Referee: Clive Thomas

Welsh referee Clive Thomas picked a strange time to blow for full-time in this World Cup game. With the score 1-1, Brazil sent a corner into the box and just as Zico put his head on the ball for an apparent winner Thomas decided to blow for time.

What was the worst refereeing display you have ever seen? Leave your comments below.

Seán Fay / Eurosport

Comment 62 - 81 of 81

Sort comments by: Most recent
  1. im a chelsea fun but chelsea shud have scored more than­ 1 against barca coz 1 goal is not enough to win a game­ or seal the game if chelsea had scored in second half­ barca would had relax and not attack coz they willl­ think its over but i hope man u win im not sayin manu­ coz barca beat us well barca are a good team to be­ honest

    From Kevin, on Sun 10 May 2:51PM
  2. I am a Chelsea fan and as far as the game is concerned­ the strikers did not put in the effort and wrap up the­ game without worrying about the ref and his­ controversial decisions. Barca deserve to go to the­ final as they scored what they needed too and Chelsea­ knew that and ran that risk throughout the game. My one­ big comment though is that Chelsea and the players will­ get bans and fines and the ref will be put to needless­ worry because refs cant cope. Football is such a fast­ game now and if you want the best refs at these maches­ you need a bigger pool of refs and to get that they­ need help so lets have video evidence and take away the­ mistakes that blight our game.

    From anthony.pool1, on Sun 10 May 10:52AM
  3. MARK CLATTENBERG - MERSEYSIDE DERBY - 20th October­ 2007

    Look it up!

    From REUBEN, on Fri 8 May 3:11PM
  4. these howlers by refs are made sporadically. its not­ throughout the match. what mistakes ovrebo did was­ through the whole match. so that alone takes the cake­ for the worst referee ever. and how the hell did uefa­ even gave him a licence. granted the persecution he­ received from chelsea was emotional and shameful. but­ as a shrink, he DID brought hell upon himself. and why­ didnt his 2 assistants correct his mistakes? too shy? 1­ or 2 mistakes was forgivable. but mistakes after­ mistakes? in my opinion, he got paidoff by 3 parties:­ chelsea, barca, and platini.

    chelsea paid him: abidal­ got sent off.
    barca paid him more: all legit penalty­ claims waved away.
    platini paid and threatened him: be­ 'smart' abt your licence cos you are going to­ the world cup.

    ok these are just fictional. but i­ strongly suggest that uefa start sanctioning refs &­ officials for poor and appalling decisions. if teams­ are responsible for their conduct on & off the­ field, why refs and his assistants get away with it? no­ fines/bans.. in that way, they'll start consulting­ every officials if they're in doubt or have reasons­ to doubt.

    im no fan of either team. man utd all the­ way.. but for this match, i say

    football 0 officials­ 4.

    From Vertigo, on Fri 8 May 10:10AM
  5. drogba is the personification of foul play and should­ be punished. the chelski fans feel wronged, but so did­ the fans of the other teams in the prem who have been @­ the recieving end of the divers wrong decisions which­ are a blight on the english game. PUNISHMENT is long­ overdew.
    lfc should be in the final with man u if he­ would have been carded for his acting.

    From Gerry, on Fri 8 May 8:58AM
  6. drogba is the personification of foul play and should­ be punished. the chelski fans feel wronged, but so did­ the fans of the other teams in the prem who have been @­ the recieving end of the divers wrong decisions which­ are a blight on the english game. PUNISHMENT is long­ overdew.
    lfc should be in the final with man u if he­ would have been carded for his acting.

    From Gerry, on Fri 8 May 8:33AM
  7. i am a fans for both chelsea and barcelona,so which­ team go through i would be happy.
    however,i still have­ to say something bout the referee.maybe everyone is­ judging chelsea with their old record of diving,like­ drogba, malouda, anelka...yes they dived,so whats the­ point?
    is it means u should have discrimination on­ their team even when they palying good? giving penalty­ only after considering their record?
    what is this, this­ is not a mathematic question we answering here,this is­ sport,the referee should have act more better in this­ game.2 wrong never equal to a right!
    maybe 4 claim of­ penalty would be harsh,but at least there is 1 really­ shold have given.and giving out red card for abidal is­ another bad decision,which is too harsh.
    maybe u guys­ not supporting my thoughs here, but what i write here­ is based on this match referring,worst referee?nah if­ there is a rating , i would give him 3 out of 10.
    maybe­ the fifa given the referee too much power, as he acting­ like a god on the field,and some matches could really­ be ruined by them.and i think even he knows he wrong­ bout the decisions he made on the field, he still­ wouldnt appologise,have u ever seen ur boss say sorry­ to the workers? hahaha
    i am from malaysia,sorry bout my­ lousy english

    From wongkokleong1987, on Fri 8 May 7:59AM
  8. refree ovrebo surely must have taken millions of­ dollars to throw the game....worst refree ever!!!!

    From CHINNA KARUPPU, on Fri 8 May 7:45AM
  9. Drogba should be suspended for next years champions­ league.

    Terry
    Lampard
    Alex
    Cech
    Ballack

    should­ also be punished but not suspended for all of next­ years champs league .
    maybe a 3 match ban .

    From James, on Fri 8 May 7:31AM
  10. barcelona is are the teanm in the WORLD...

    From MESSI, on Fri 8 May 2:20AM
  11. ballack,
    drogba,
    terry,
    alex ,
    is a disgrace,i­ can't believe it

    From Tony, on Fri 8 May 12:31AM
  12. ballack,
    drogba,
    terry,
    alex ,
    is a disgrace,i­ can't believe it

    From Tony, on Fri 8 May 12:31AM
  13. england vs t & t england under pressure cant­ score until david crouch grabs hair to rise above much­ shorter defender to score england eventually won 2-0

    From anwicis, on Fri 8 May 12:00AM
  14. what about all the cr@p ref decisions C. Ronaldo always­ seems to conjure up. stupid bumfu*k

    From fabregasfan09, on Thu 7 May 10:25PM
  15. One i remember was the Italy - scotland qualifier at­ hampden for euro 2008. 1-1 was the score, if scotland­ scored, they would go through, but italy had­ possession. then a shot was taken and recoiled away­ after a save, alan hutton collected the ball but was­ charged and rugby tackled by one of the italian­ players. Hutton was sent straight to the ground and­ everyone thought freekick to scotland. But... the ref­ and linesman both thought it was a foul the other way.­ they gave a freekick to italy right in the middle of­ the space between the corner flag (right) and penalty­ box. it was then crossed in a lead to a goal...­ scotland out due to a spanish referee's very poor­ judgement...

    From dodger, on Thu 7 May 10:16PM
  16. Comment hidden due to its low rating. Show

    How about the goal allowed for England to win the world­ cup while clearly the ball did not come close to the­ line? I still feel sorry for the dutch :-)

    From Half A Brain, on Thu 7 May 10:04PM
  17. look people if you were refs you'd see how hard it­ is so give them a brake we're all human and plus­ youyu make more mistakes in a game as a player than a­ ref does in that game so stop giving the refs abuse or­ else you'll lose them and lose the game what i­ think nobody wants

    From gally.gallagher, on Thu 7 May 9:54PM
  18. The graham poll 3 yellows the true story:

    On his cards­ he has 1 side per team so he put the number of the­ player down on one side then accidentaly put it on the­ other as well. The 4th offical had noticed the mistake­ (so it is 1/2 his fault) but thought as poll is so­ senior he must be right and I must have made the­ mistake

    The offside:
    The linesman should of kept his­ flag up and buzzed Poll as soon as Kewell touched the­ ball or after the goal went in

    From gally.gallagher, on Thu 7 May 9:50PM
  19. there was a game in argentina where the ball went out­ play and ball boy put it into the back of the net and­ it was allowed - classic

    there was also the sol­ campbell goal disallowed in france 98 for­ nothing

    collina performance in everton vs villareal­ where if everton had won it would of been 5 english­ teams in champions league more anti english from thatt­ t@ blatter.

    From joe_edgar2000, on Thu 7 May 9:32PM
  20. I am 65 years old, In all these years I have seen­ many..many..football games
    many mistakes by the­ Refs,and unjustice decissions by many of them. But­ nothing
    has matched the ignorance of the Ref. In the­ finals of the World Cup in England
    in 1966. Was it­ ignorance, or a favor to the English Team...??? If We­ consider
    that the Ref. was Scotish. Sorry....But it has­ hapenned many years ago, and yet
    now and them, many­ fans still talk about the "DESASTROUS" Ref.­ against Portugal.
    It was ..Pure and simple...One more­ player on the English Team , with a lot of
    power to­ make the wrong decissions, allways in favor of England.­ Eusebio alone
    was enough to beat de hell of the Inglish­ Team, but the Ref. was there to stop it.
    So...You win­ some and loose some. That is the way it's go.

    From Pepe C, on Thu 7 May 9:30PM
Sort comments by: Most recent

Not already a Yahoo! user ? to get a free Yahoo! Account