Champions League - Top 10 ref controversies

Eurosport - Thu, 07 May 13:58:00 2009

Ok Chelsea fans, we hear you, Tom Henning Ovrebo was awful and you were robbed etc, etc....

FOOTBALL 2006 World Cup Graham Poll Josip Simunic - 0

But there is no need to engage in hyperbole and call it "the worst refereeing performance of all time". Not when there is so much competition for that honour.

Try these examples out for size.

Watford v Reading - Championship 2008 - Referee: Stuart Attwell

Reading's Stephen Hunt whipped in a corner but it hit Watford's John Eustace on the thigh and went two yards wide for another corner - or so every one of the 14,761 fans in the ground thought. Not assistant referee Nigel Bannister, who somehow managed to convince referee Stuart Attwell that the ball had gone into the back of the net. "Probably the worst decision I've ever witnessed in football," said benefactor Hunt. The Watford players and fans were a little less choice with their words.

Croatia v Australia - World Cup 2006 - Referee: Graham Poll

Graham Poll made an absolute howler when he booked Josip Simunic three times and failed to spot Harry Kewell offside for one of Australia's goals in this World Cup group game. The Socceroos drew 2-2 and qualified for the next round but Sepp Blatter later commented that "had Australia lost the game and gone out of the World Cup, they would have had grounds to request a replay".

Manchester United v Tottenham - Premier League 2005 - Referee: Mark Clattenburg

Roy Carroll made a hash of a long-range effort from Pedro Mendes near the end of this Premier League game but amazingly got away with it. The ball dropped at least a yard over the line before Carroll gained control, but referee Mark Clattenburg and his officials somehow missed this fact and the match finished 0-0.

Portugal v England - Euro 2004 - Referee: Urs Meier

Sol Campbell's last minute 'winner' against the tournament hosts was ruled out by Swiss referee Urs Meier due to a 'foul' by John Terry on the Portugal goalkeeper. England lost on penalties and Meier was forced into hiding after receiving 16,000 items of hate mail. 'Urs hole' and 'Swiss banker' were amongst the highlight headlines in the British tabloids the next day.

South Korea v Italy and South Korea v Spain - World Cup 2002 - Referee: Byron Moreno (Italy match) and Gamal Al-Ghandour (Spain match).

Guus Hiddink has not always been the victim of bad refereeing performances. His South Korea side made it to the semi-finals of the 2002 World Cup with more than a little help from officials. In the second round, Italy were left fuming at Ecuadorian Byron Moreno as they had a goal disallowed, a penalty shout turned down, and Francesco Totti sent off for diving. In the quarters, Spain had two goals chalked off by Egyptian referee Gamal Al-Ghandour before losing on penalties.

Middlesbrough v Chesterfield - FA Cup 1997 - Referee: David Elleray

Third-tier Chesterfield were 2-1 up against Middlesbrough in their FA Cup semi-final and looked set for an unlikely place in the final when Jonathan Howard crashed a goal in off the underside of the bar to seemingly make it 3-1. However, referee David Elleray said the ball hadn't crossed the line and Middlesbrough came back and won the match on a replay.

Argentina v England - World Cup 1986 - Referee: Ali Bin Nasser

'Hand of God' - need we say any more? If Tunisia referee Ali Bin Nasser is granted an obituary in any of the English papers then it will be because of this and this alone.

France v Germany - World Cup 1982 - Referee: Charles Corver

Dutch referee Charles Corver inexplicabley awarded a goalkick when German keeper Harald Schumacher smashed into French defender Patrick Battiston during their World Cup semi-final in Spain. Battiston was sent to hospital in a coma while Schumacher helped Germany win the match on penalties.

Coventry v Crystal Palace - Division One 1980 - Referee: Derek Webb

Crystal Palace's Clive Allen fired home a perfect free kick into the top corner against Coventry at Highfield Road. The ball cannoned off the stanchion and back into play. Referee Derek Webb thought it had hit the crossbar and waved play on. Palace protested but to no avail. They went on to lose 3-1.

Brazil v Sweden - World Cup 1978 - Referee: Clive Thomas

Welsh referee Clive Thomas picked a strange time to blow for full-time in this World Cup game. With the score 1-1, Brazil sent a corner into the box and just as Zico put his head on the ball for an apparent winner Thomas decided to blow for time.

What was the worst refereeing display you have ever seen? Leave your comments below.

Seán Fay / Eurosport

Comment 22 - 41 of 81

Sort comments by: Most recent
  1. i dnt support chelsea beither do i like them but its­ not the refs fault in my eyes its that french t wat­ platini who hates all english. this is a conspiracy no­ doubt in my mind he wuda done anything to stop another­ all english final so probably tapped up the ref.

    From R, on Thu 7 May 4:48PM
  2. We just need to wait a few years for the old farts like­ Blatter to die/retire and technology will fix all this­ @#$%. Games may take a bit longer to playout but at­ least decisions will be proper and people will stop­ blaming human error that will always be a factor in the­ game.

    From G, on Thu 7 May 4:39PM
  3. The difference is that in all these cases it was one ­ mistake. This guy yesterday demonstrated a series of­ serious mitakes . All the incidences happened when he­ was in a short distance from the offence. HE IS A JOKE

    From DIMITRIS, on Thu 7 May 4:33PM
  4. # 37, before calling anybody idiot, you must learn to­ write, or at least find simpler words that your mind­ can handle. Whatever the 4th referee is for, it is not­ his job to overrule the linesmen AND the referee. The­ video replay was not, has not been adopted neither by­ FIFA nor by UEFA, yet it was used de facto to review­ Zidane's conduct. Had not he been sent off, it­ would have been a disgrace for whom? The Italians? The­ Spanish? As for the name calling, it always happens:­ when someone is short on arguments, he or she start­ calling names or using expletives. It makes him/her­ feel better while compensating for their inadequacy at­ the brain level.

    From Carl D, on Thu 7 May 4:29PM
  5. in the 78/79 season READINGS first goal of the season­ at home to rochdale was a shot that went into the side­ netting!
    went on to win the game and get promotion at­ end of season!

    From waffle, on Thu 7 May 4:03PM
  6. Carl D, you are an absolute i.d.i.o.t, without any­ doubts. Do you know anything about football? 4th man is­ there to coadiuvate the refree on particular topics.­ Zinedine Zidane had to be sent off; if he had not been­ sent off the pitch, that would have been a HUGE­ football disgrace! On the other, you must surely be a­ liver damaged french or a Domenech parent, which, trust­ me, is far from being a compliment.

    From fafa, on Thu 7 May 4:02PM
  7. If you want bad ref incidents how about this one­ Stockingford White Lion V Arley and the ref didn't­ turn up so there manager reffed. After about ten­ minutes he called over one of our players and said­ "i'm booking you whats your name?" our­ player said, "i aint telling you" and the ref­ said "i know what it is anyway it's­ c***." wrote it down and waved the imaginary card.­ Seven quid that cost us!

    From rafaforpope, on Thu 7 May 3:59PM
  8. Oh and with the players on your team, who lie on the­ floor clutching their face, grimacing after minimal­ contact trying to get opposition players booked... I­ wouldn't accuse any other team of diving.
    Every­ team in this world has divers, yet you're insistent­ on being a pot calling a kettle black.

    From i am a teacup, on Thu 7 May 3:55PM
  9. Tim are you stupid?
    If your hand is raised above your­ head, or placed away from your body.... and in the act­ of the ball making contact with it, it stops a goal­ bound strike or prevents a goalscoring opportunity, it­ is an offence.

    -Hence the Pique incident is­ STONEWALL...
    -The Eto'o incident is debatable as­ no-one can tell if it was on target.
    -The Abidal tackle­ on Drogba was stonewall as well, and Abidal­ should've been sent off then and there... but­ Drogba's reputation played against him.
    -The Alves­ tackle on Malouda is also a clear penalty, if he­ stopped play for the incident which left Malouda on the­ ground. The only excuse he has is if the initial foul­ was outside the box, in which case the freekick was­ STILL given in an incorrect position.
    -The others are­ not even debatable penalties.

    From i am a teacup, on Thu 7 May 3:53PM
  10. Referee are killing football. Referee anywhere whether­ europe, america,asia or africa, something need to be­ done before something tragic happen before solution are­ found. Let us have technology in football. We have it­ in rugby, baseball racing, lawn tennis, why is football­ different. Clubs must come together to force governing­ bodies to introduce technology.

    From dapfash, on Thu 7 May 3:46PM
  11. I would add to that list the sending off of Zinedine­ Zidane in the final of the last World Cup. The referee­ did not see the incident nor was it reported by the­ linesmen. Someone who was not even in the game reported­ it and they checked(?????) the video. Who was that­ fourth "referee?" A certain Medina Cantalejo,­ who had awarded a penalty to Italy so they could­ advance. Anyone remembers why Juventus was relegated to­ a lower league? Barcelona has great players, but you­ see too many decisions in their favor. Football at that­ level has become like a ballet: everyone is in position­ and take a certain step a certain time, making a great­ show, but not what we would like to see. I trust­ neither the Italians nor the Spaniards at great matches­ time. They have perfected the art of Crooking.

    From Carl D, on Thu 7 May 3:39PM
  12. oh and tim you p rick! if you can show me 1 video of­ any of the players you mentioned going down without any­ contact I'll give you 100 quid. I could show you­ plenty videos of ronaldo and gerrard going down without­ the any kind of contact, thats what a dive is.

    god Id­ luv to punch you on the face

    From yip, on Thu 7 May 3:35PM
  13. oh and tim you p rick! if you can show me 1 video of­ any of the players you mentioned going down without any­ contact I'll give you 100 quid. I could show you­ plenty videos of ronaldo and gerrard going down without­ the any kind of contact, thats what a dive is.

    god Id­ luv to punch you on the face

    From yip, on Thu 7 May 3:35PM
  14. tim you are an actuall disgrace. you are just lying on­ purpose. you shouldnt be allowed to use a computer.­ fair enough people have opinions and utd n liverpool­ fans will say rubbish cause its chelsea but you are the­ worst person I have ever came across. I feel sorry for­ anyone that knows you, although I guess you have no­ friends.

    lot of bad decisions in spurs utd games aint­ there

    From yip, on Thu 7 May 3:33PM
  15. refereeing Tom Henning Ovrebo Should go to hill and­ kills itself is not a good refereeing and UAF shoud­ stop using him...

    From m2love50, on Thu 7 May 3:30PM
  16. Drogba is to England what Pepe is to Spain: Disgraceful­ testimonies that affect the way children see this­ sport. Poor Henning. ˇBallack has the most atrocious­ bad breath! Poor Hiddink. His bad memory fails to­ remind him of a couple of legitimate goals scored be­ Spain in 2004 Korea-Japan World Cup that were called­ null and void by a referee, classifying his pupils in­ the same fashion we saw yesterday. You sow in 2004-you­ reap in 2009. Bye Bye Baby. Man U is number one by a­ longshot.

    From blanquillo, on Thu 7 May 3:29PM
  17. Three Card Poll was hilarious, but nothing more.

    Hand­ of God is total stupidity, and Maradona should be­ banned from football because of that.

    Schumacher's­ "effort" was the worst I've ever seen....­ how the hell he CLATTERED into Battiston and ESCAPED­ with it?

    But the worst one of all....? The­ Reading-Watford match. Guess the assistant referee was­ in dreamland!

    (P.S: The "ghost goal" in­ Liverpool-Chelsea CL semifinal also deserves a mention­ in there, but I think it's excluded because it was­ never determined the ball crossed the line - still, I­ believe it didn't....)

    From lalala, on Thu 7 May 3:25PM
  18. homerBeckham what are you talking about... it is in the­ list shown in this article... actually the photo is­ that referee showing the Croatian player the third­ yellow

    From inka_d, on Thu 7 May 3:24PM
  19. I think graham poll should be on top of the list­ because he booked the same player 3 times without­ giving him a red card during world cup 2006.......I­ think those who work at yahoo sports must be all stupid­ english who are related to sir oswald mosley..the­ founder of graet britain fascist.

    From homerBeckham, on Thu 7 May 3:24PM
  20. Of course eurosport will claim to have blocked my ip­ for speaking the truth.The Cameroon-England match of­ 90' was a total disgrace to football and sports in­ general.

    From Eel, on Thu 7 May 3:19PM
Sort comments by: Most recent

Not already a Yahoo! user ? to get a free Yahoo! Account