6 Nations - Sloppy England win Six Nations opener

Eurosport - Sun, 08 Feb 17:54:00 2009

England beat Italy 36-11 in the opening game of the Six Nations but it was a flattering win as they failed to show the improvement Martin Johnson had demanded following their November drubbings.

Harry Ellis - England - 0

England, beaten by Australia, South Africa and New Zealand in the autumn international season, were never in danger from the moment fly-half Andy Goode marked his return to international rugby with a try after two minutes.

They led 22-6 at halftime thanks to further scores by scrum-half Harry Ellis (pictured) and centre Riki Flutey. A second for Ellis and a late score in the corner by wing Mark Cueto made it 15 out of 15 wins for England against Italy.

However, England played barely any constructive rugby against a disorganised and injury-ravaged Italian side, had James Haskell and replacement Shane Geraghty yellow-carded, and will need to find a rapid improvement for next week's game against defending champions Wales.

"It's always the same first game back," man-of-the-match Ellis said. "It was a bit stuttery at times and we need to improve in every single area."

Goode marked his first appearance since 2006 by running on to Fabio Ongaro's over-thrown lineout throw and moments later chipping through to score his first international try in his 10th appearance.

Cueto, in his first game since the 2007 World Cup final, set up the second with a penetrating deep kick and thumping follow-up tackle. Haskell showed good skill at the turnover to set up Ellis, promoted to the side this week after an injury to Danny Care, to score.

Mauro Bergamasco endured a torrid time as emergency scrum-half and launched a wild pass above the head of Gonzalo Garcia which the centre could not hold. Goode was on hand to hack ahead and Flutey, who struggled to live up to his billing in his debut series in November, scored his first England try.

Italy suffered another setback when they lost fly-half Andrea Marcato to injury after half an hour, although his replacement Luke McLean landed two penalties to put his team on the board.

Goode, normally a highly reliable kicker, missed three of his six first-half attempts.

Coach Nick Mallett eventually admitted defeat with his scrum-half experiment at halftime and brought on Giulio Toniolatti, who had only 15 minutes of international rugby to his name.

Italy looked more composed for the change, while England lost their way, and the crowd had to wait until the 55th minute for their next decent attack, and the fourth try, when Ellis ran in from 40 metres after a break by Flutey.

It was a rare moment to savour as England, as they did in their home defeats by the three Tri-Nations teams in the autumn, lost their shape and discipline in a second half almost devoid of any flowing rugby and punctuated by errors and an aimless and inexplicable kicking game.

Italy took heart and grew in confidence and they got their reward in the 72nd minute when winger Mirco Bergamasco scored in the right corner.

Reuters

Comment 70 - 89 of 89

Sort comments by: Most recent
  1. hey steeveengland , did u know that guy ANDY MANN , he­ is scottish , guess what he is doing to all these

    From nathan, on Sun 8 Feb 7:31PM
  2. Hey why is there a strong rivalry between england and­ scotland ?? Its like dog and a cat fight !!!

    From nathan, on Sun 8 Feb 7:17PM
  3. Hey, I'm an open minded girl from US, I'm­­ interested in exotic things, photography, dating and­­ sports...I have my photos on --- Tallhub Co m ---, I­­ love tall guys!
    Do you love traveling and have some­­ experience? Just find me out.

    From reialen09, on Sun 8 Feb 6:44PM
  4. England were again clueless.

    How many more times do we­ need to see Noon ambling round the pitch. He is a­ DISGRACE!
    Tait should be playing.
    Meares is a waste of­ time too, put in Hartley.

    From Matthew G, on Sun 8 Feb 6:05PM
  5. The flower of scotland... is a weed.

    From steveengland1234, on Sun 8 Feb 5:30PM
  6. And the flying scotsman is finally silenced. Oh dear,

    From sadie s, on Sun 8 Feb 5:21PM
  7. ENGLAND= masters. scotland=@#$%

    From steveengland1234, on Sun 8 Feb 4:20PM
  8. England are the rulers of the world. scotland are ruled­ by the world; end of story. Bow down to England­ scotland, you speak ENGLISH language, and rent the @#$%­ part of the country that we dont want! HA HA

    From steveengland1234, on Sun 8 Feb 4:18PM
  9. Q: Whats the difference between England and scotland?­ A: England owns scotland, scotland are a complete bunch­ of @#$%, that take drugs and screw their own family,­ and end up on jeremy Kyle because there nan is pregnant­ to her own grandson! Sad Sad jealous nobodys

    From steveengland1234, on Sun 8 Feb 4:12PM
  10. at the end of the day lets all face facts both italy­ and england made mistakes in team selection and on the­ field of play they now have 4 games each to correct the­ issues with italy this may be harder as they have a­ smaller pool of players to pick from
    whereas england­ should on paper have selection problems through good­ competition for all positions.
    but if you don't get­ rid of the old pals act the problems will persist and­ fresh blood does'nt have a chance.
    ps.i am a­ scotsman and try and put an objective view on all teams­ including my own as i'm just as worried about our­ performance as anybody!

    From jc297, on Sun 8 Feb 2:24PM
  11. England where fortunate that Mallet played Bergamasco­ at scrum half otherwise it could have been a different­ story.

    From gethin, on Sun 8 Feb 2:03PM
  12. i cant believe everyone has slammed the performance­ yesterday with a very weakend squad no pocession and­ little fluency we scored 5 tries and jumped on every­ mistake they made italy arent the whipping boys of 5­ years ago they go places to win there scrum is strong­ there line out is normally good they hit hard and slown­ the ball and game down to suit there own players and­ now fitness isnt an issue there i think they will shock­ a few teams. my only issue is the fact that we spent 20­ of the 80 mins with 14 players disapline is a key in­ the modern game peneltys mean points and if players­ consitantly offend maybe the bad out weighs the good

    From paul s, on Sun 8 Feb 1:23PM
  13. It will be interesting to see how the jocks do against­ the taffs later today though.

    From BigBill, on Sun 8 Feb 12:29PM
  14. English Rugby is play at much too slow a pace and­ Johnsones selectios reflects the 5 years he spent away­ from front line action where he is picking players from­ memory of the good old days why on earth else would­ Gould have played. Just look at the difference in pace­ of the Irish / France game. When will some tell the­ group of fowards who like to clutter the mid field that­ being dynamic is not about standing there and trying to­ brake the game line from a standing start but about­ entering the rucks and maul and driving over and though­ the ball. I'm starting to believe this current crop­ of players are sucoming to the footballers memtality of­ all glamour and no results

    From Julie, on Sun 8 Feb 11:01AM
  15. Got to feel sorry for Bergamasco, Toniolatti played­ well, Mallett made big mistake there.
    What's­ England up to? what's the point of loading the­ midfield with forwards so there not at the breakdown­ resulting in slow ball supplied to slow forwards making­ no ground.
    Playing most of the game this way, They must­ have spent a lot of time doing this on the training­ ground.
    What are the coaches up to?

    From Salamander, on Sun 8 Feb 10:59AM
  16. I found a hot place..... it's called the­ Reeperbahn.

    From Oasis, on Sun 8 Feb 10:45AM
  17. Dennis England wasnt the only team making mistakes.­ What the TV didnt show you, is the amount of Italian­ players taking swings at then English OFF THE BALL. but­ nothing was done about it. Everyone is way too busy­ trying to make England look bad, OK it wasnt the best­ game. OK mistakes were made but at the end of the day­ we played a better game and WON. END OF STORY. We have­ 4 more games in which to prove all the negative England­ haters wrong

    From sadie s, on Sun 8 Feb 10:43AM
  18. +There is some ignorant rubbish posted on this page­ today, for goodness sake, comment on the game and then­ go away. Don't get into these childish, insult­ swopping exchanges like the football morons! England­ won because of an amazingly crass, naive decision by­ MALLET to play a back row forward at the pivotal­ position of scrum half, which led to the England tries.­ I am still stupified by the amount of juvenile, 3rd­ team level penalties given away by England players in­ their own half. These are international, professional­ players, what is actually going through their stupid­ heads when they do these things. Gerharty - what was­ that all about? Blatantly taking out a player in the­ air when you have been on the field 2 minutes? When he­ did come back on he did nothing.

    From Leoden47, on Sun 8 Feb 10:35AM
  19. You should try watching any England game in a scottish­ pub. I doesn't matter who we play, the place is­ alway full of croations, argentinians, french,­ italianss but all with scottish accents

    From debbieh76, on Sun 8 Feb 10:29AM
  20. Are you Scottish, or rubbish? same thing, I guess, the­ scots have been the whipping boys of British rugby for­ as long as I can remember, some things never change, ­ Ned Kelly

    From jcastledineruiz, on Sun 8 Feb 10:26AM
Sort comments by: Most recent

Not already a Yahoo! user ? to get a free Yahoo! Account