Rate it!

144 votes

You probably know this already, but Player of the Week Shay Given is an absolutely brilliant goalkeeper.

HOW IT WORKS

We tot up the marks out of 10 awarded in five national newspapers - The Sun, The Mirror, The Mail, The Times and The Guardian - to create a total out of 50. The top player in each position will be rewarded with a spot in the team of the week, while the worst scorers will be named and shamed in our Flops XI.

TEAM OF THE WEEK

If Given were English, we would all be saying he was the best goalkeeper in the world. The Irishman's heroics this season have defied belief, and he started his Manchester City career with a whopping 44 points to take Player of the Week honours by a mile. A good win for Sunderland sees three of their number earn selection, while Everton's two-goal debutant Jo leads the forward line. The Big Four have nobody in this team, but four players in the flops XI below.

GK: Shay Given (Manchester City) - 44

RB: Phil Bardsley (Sunderland)- 34

CB: Michael Turner (Hull City) - 38

CB: Danny Collins (Sunderland) - 38

LB: Leighton Baines (Everton) - 35

RM: James Milner (Aston Villa) - 40

CM: Luka Modric (Tottenham Hotspur) - 40

CM: Gareth Barry (Aston Villa) - 38

LM: Andy Reid (Sunderland) - 38

FW: Jo (Everton) - 42

FW: Marc-Antoine Fortune (West Bromwich Albion) - 39

FLOPS OF THE WEEK

Liverpool have made history as the first team to win a match but provide three players to the Flops of the Week. Reina is unlucky, as marginally the worst of a decent batch of goalkeeping performances, but Ryan Babel and David Ngog are duly slated after their stinkers at Portsmouth. Thank heaven for Fernando Torres... The worst individual performer was West Brom's Abdoulaye Meite, whose only competition came from team-mate Leon Barnett.

GK: Jose Reina (Liverpool) - 27

RB: Andy O'Brien (Bolton Wanderers) - 24

CB: Abdoulaye Meite (West Bromwich Albion) - 15

CB: Leon Barnett (West Bromwich Albion) - 18

LB: Stephen Warnock (Blackburn Rovers) - 25

RM: Emmanuel Eboue (Arsenal) - 19

CM: Kim Do-Heon (West Bromwich Albion) - 22

CM: Keith Andrews (Blackburn Rovers) - 23

LM: Ryan Babel (Liverpool) - 21

FW: David Ngog (Liverpool) - 20

FW: Ariza Makukula (Bolton Wanderers) - 21

TEAM OF THE SEASON (minimum 13 starts)

Given's heroics see him overtake Frank Lampard as the player with the highest average in the division this season. It has been nip and tuck between Gareth Barry and Xabi Alonso all season, but the Villa man has just nudged in front by the smallest possible margin.

GK: Shay Given (Manchester City) - 34.96 average

RB: Glen Johnson (Portsmouth) - 32.06

CB: Michael Turner (Hull) - 33.64

CB: Martin Laursen (Aston Villa) - 33.84

LB: Patrice Evra (Manchester United) - 32.63

RM: Antonio Valencia (Wigan Athletic) - 33.64

CM: Gareth Barry (Aston Villa) - 34.72

CM: Frank Lampard (Chelsea) - 34.92

LM: Ashley Young (Aston Villa) - 33.72

FW: Wayne Rooney (Manchester United) - 34.00

FW: Craig Bellamy (Manchester City) - 33.75

FLOPS OF THE SEASON (minimum 13 starts)

Julien Faubert's move to Real Madrid means he is out of the picture, while Pascal Chimbonda and Darren Bent could soon become ineligible as both have made the minimum 13 starts. The hopeless Keith Andrews has taken Zoltan Gera out of central midfield with a scything, mis-timed tackle.

GK: Heurelho Gomes (Tottenham Hotspur) - 29.66

RB: Pascal Chimbonda (Tottenham Hotspur) - 28.77

CB: Andre Ooijer (Blackburn Rovers) - 28.47

CB: Fabricio Coloccini (Newcastle United) - 28.47

LB: Jose Enrique (Newcastle United) - 26.06

RM: David Bentley (Tottenham Hotspur) - 28.95

CM: Keith Andrews (Blackburn Rovers) - 28.18

CM: Amdy Faye (Stoke City) - 27.35

LM: Chris Brunt (West Bromwich Albion) - 27.81

FW: Roman Pavlyuchenko (Tottenham Hotspur) - 26.98

FW: Darren Bent (Tottenham Hotspur) - 27.75

Alex Chick / Eurosport