Rate it!

29 votes

Earlier this week, Bjorn Borg said Andy Murray is a future world number one - despite being knocked out at the semi-final stage of Wimbledon by American Andy Roddick.

"He's going to be up there fighting with Nadal and Federer from now on," said the 11-times Grand Slam winner.

"One day I think he might be the number one player in the world."

When a legend of the game makes a statement like that, what can we do but open the debate up to you?

That's exactly what we did - and a quarter of you thought Borg was correct, while the other 74 per cent reckon he was talking out of the top of his headband.

The young Scot often draws extremes of opinion, and this was no exception, with plenty of people lining up to rubbish the notion that he could overtake Rafael Nadal and Roger Federer.

So heated was the debate, in fact, that dozens of comments disappeared from view on the board as contributors furiously clicked the 'thumbs down' button!

Among the shouting, however, many people made the valid point that Murray's style seems overly defensive at the moment.

One contributor, song_dp, went further than most in claiming that the Scot's glut of ranking points to defend this summer will see him drop out of the top five - despite the massive gulf of several thousand points that separates the top four from the rest.

Several of you were of the opinion that Murray could make it to the summit of the game.

"Andy has beaten all of the top 10 so why shouldn't he be a number one?" said voice of reason katy.hulme.

Nclsaverio agreed - after carefully pointing out that he or she is Italian, and therefore unbiased - but feels that Murray is yet to get the most out of his power and technique.

As ever, there were a few oddball suggetions - and this week they mainly revolved around Murray's personal grooming.

"Andy needs a real makeover in his appearance before anyone non-British can support him," insisted kayangmo.

"Federer looked like a grandmother before his curly-hair makeover and it has worked wonders for him ever since. This is not a joke."

If you say so, my friend. If you say so.

---------------------------------------------------------------------

We asked: Bjorn Borg believes Andy Murray could become world number one. Do you agree?

Yes - 26 per cent

No - 74 per cent

---------------------------------------------------------------------

Best of your comments:

katy.hume - Andy has beaten all of the top 10 players so why shouldn't he be number one sooner rather than later?

Nclsaverio - Andy could be number one by the end of 2010, but he must learn how to use his tennis potential. Roger will concentrate on Grand Slams, Nadal will continue to suffer and Andy is able to make points everywhere. He is one of the few who combines great technique with power and endurance; he has only to learn how to use them.

diegopacheco0988 - Murray has barely proven anything in best-of-five sets: he's a best-of-three specialist. That is largely related to his passive, boring, feeding style.

janell.lovell - If Murray wants to win a Grand Slam then he needs to be more aggressive in his play - period! Roddick beat him because Murray thought A-Rod was going to hand him the errors. Well, he didn't - hence him winning the match.

yossinetz - I used to be a faithful fan of Borg. I never missed his matches back in the 70s and the early 80s. However, I do not agree with his assessment. Murray is able to handle Federer, but in no way can he deal with Nadal. He hasn't got the strength in his "upper floor".

Mileta Cekovic - With Nadal off court, it is just that Borg needs another defensive player to support. I feel pity for Murray, but the number one will be either an offensive player, or a defensive player with extraordinary skills like Borg or Nadal - not Murray.

song_dp - Number one? I don't think so. With Federer and Nadal above him, and Djokovic, Roddick and Del Potro all playing good tennis, he'll drop out of the top five soon. After Cincinnati, which he somehow won last year, and the US Open, where he got to the final, he'll lose so many points that he might even be out of the top 10.

kayangmo - Andy Murray needs a real makeover in his appearance before anyone non-British can support him. Federer looked like a grandmother before his curly-hair makeover and it has worked wonders for him ever since. This is not a joke.

Aaa - If he continues to play well, and both Nadal and Federer lose vital points along the way, Murray could top the ATP ranking without winning a Grand Slam. It will be interesting to know how the media (especially the British press) will react to him then. Would they have the same (biased) attitude toward him that they have against Dinara Safina?

Eurosport