Your view: Ferrari rule the roost

Eurosport - Mon, 19 Jan 15:42:00 2009

Eurosport-Yahoo! readers have voted Ferrari as the greatest constructor in Formula One history, with McLaren easing home in second and Lotus the best of the rest.

FORMULA 1 2008 Ferrari Logo - 0

The Prancing Horse garnered half of the vote, with over 8,000 of you registering your opinion on the matter.

British squad McLaren was over 1,500 behind the grand Italian marque with 32 per cent, but comfortably ahead of their nearest rival Lotus (eight per cent).

Williams and Alfa Romeo had a decent showing with Tyrell and Brabham tied at one per cent - although the former nicked sixth spot by a few votes.

British Racing Motors were backed by less than 50 people and so finished with the grand total of zero per cent.

Which is the greatest constructor in Formula One history?

8,396 votes as of 12:30 UK time on Monday January 19

Results:

1. Ferrari: 50 %

2. McLaren: 32%

3. Lotus: 8%

4. Williams: 4%

5. Alfa Romeo: 3%

6. Tyrell: 1%

7. Brabham: 1%

8. BRM: 0%

What you said:

Alan P: I was always a Lotus fan. You have to admit that Colin Chapman's innovation and Jim Clark's driving were something to behold. But although I hate to admit it - particularly because of what we perceive as the 'unfair advantage' that they enjoy - I'm afraid it has to be Ferrari. They are the only team to be in there from day one.

bobtailgrove: Despite being rotten to the core, Ferrari. They are synonymous with the sport of F1 with a truly amazing history and pedigree; it's a shame about the corruption. Lotus got to be up there as well.

Napierrailton: Nobody really likes Ferrari, but they get the vote because they have been around longer and so would obviously have had more chance to win more often. Had Williams, Lotus and McLaren been around that long then they probably would have won more than Ferrari.

andy k: Short answer: blatantly Ferrari. Who else? Long answer: Lotus made the most interesting cars and won quite a lot in a short period; Williams for me defined the period I really got into the sport; but eight titles with eight different drivers? Says it all really.

claudebastide: This isn't even close. There is no other team with a record like Ferrari's. No other team can inspire so much passion. No other team makes F1 drivers drool at the thought of driving for them. But honours go to the great British car racing tradition as a whole.

Adrian W: McLaren don't exactly stimulate the senses do they? Coolly clinical, but they don't generate the passion that Ferrari, Williams and Lotus do.

Chitty Chitty Bang Bang: A very difficult one. For me it has to be Williams. To have such an impact in such a relatively short time must make them the greatest. Ferrari may be synonymous with F1, even to the point that some think they own it, but they have been in it for a long time and have had massive resources at their disposal.

justblowinoffsteam: Surely the question is who is the greatest constructor in F1? Not the team who has won the most or been around for the longest. If constructor is the key, then take a look at which of them has brought more into F1 than any other. That says to me the one who has been at the forefront of design and technology - innovation and engineering. Ferrari stand alone in the amount of time they have taken part, granted, but what did they do to improve F1 in terms of technology? It has to be Lotus or even Brabham and the fan car.

sdcharger717: As much as I love Tyrell (with Lotus a close second), from a historical standpoint, it will have to be Ferrari. Through most of the Sixties and Seventies, Cosworth was the standard engine (remember the garagistas?), but Ferrari stuck with their own even when they were considerably underpowered.

Oliver Tunnah: How can it be anybody but Williams? They are a true racing team.

MikeQ: It's interesting that most of the arguments for Ferrari are variations on 'we have lasted the longest'; the question was who is the greatest constructor, not the oldest! Ferrari have clearly been great contributors to F1, but it appears that most of their fans are unaware of any of their achievements.

teo: Ferrari is the greatest (in terms of) history, legendary standing and racing. Just thinking about that horse sends shivers down the spine. Then it would be Lotus (bring them back!) and Williams.

Jonathan Symcox / Eurosport

Comment 49 - 68 of 68

Sort comments by: Most recent
  1. will be looking forward to it hurry-up

    From stivsf1, on Tue 20 Jan 6:31PM
  2. Ah well at least we ended on a civil note Stivsi, bedtime in the subcontinent. Going home in a few days so then I'll be able to annoy you all night again. :-)

    From Mike, on Tue 20 Jan 6:03PM
  3. Mike the manufacturers are called so because they manufacture the complete car.
    What you call constructors they normally only make the chassis they used to be called garages-tee by ENZO FERRARI. Most of them made a name for them selves and certainly showed the way forward this also goes for the independent engine suppliers. The problem was is and always will be money, do you remember the so called poor men’s Porsche?

    From stivsf1, on Tue 20 Jan 5:35PM
  4. Hey stivsi,
    Its not my distinction, I didn't make it up.
    Seeing as Cosworth make engines not cars, I guess they are engine builders.
    As you say they all take part in the WCC, hence my question about the distinction between the two, and its relevance. Keep up.

    From Mike, on Tue 20 Jan 5:04PM
  5. Mike do you consider COSWORTH as a manufacturer or an engine supplier?
    BMW-MERCEDES-TOYOTA-RENAULT-HONDA and FERRARI are called manufacturers.
    The others are known as constructors some as engine suppliers.
    They all take part in the WDC and the WCC.

    From stivsf1, on Tue 20 Jan 4:50PM
  6. Yes Clispy, somewhat ironic that the team that won it isn't actually a constructor, do they still distinguish between the two? I suspect not.

    From Mike, on Tue 20 Jan 2:45PM
  7. Mike. Don't worry about Shaun. He's so thick it's unbelievable!

    From crispyduck, on Tue 20 Jan 1:32PM
  8. Just a bit of fun to pass the time between seasons guys !!!

    From m.e.jenner, on Tue 20 Jan 11:06AM
  9. repeatalarm50 I sometimes wonder that myself.

    From wizzo, on Tue 20 Jan 10:21AM
  10. Shaun, if you make your own engine then you classed as a Manufacturer if you don't your a Constructor. So you work it out.

    From Mike, on Tue 20 Jan 10:17AM
  11. All of them are constructors, Shaun. A constructor doesn't need to manufacture their own components in order to be a constructor.

    From Count Louis Zborowski, on Tue 20 Jan 10:07AM
  12. THOUGHT IT WAS SUPPOSED TO BE FOR CONSTRECTOR how many of the above make or made there own engines those that dont should not be in it so how can mclaren be above lotus

    From U R SOLES, on Tue 20 Jan 9:02AM
  13. Ferrari certainly have the crown for the top 'manipulators' in F1 I think it would be fair to say that, as Lotus are no longer around in F1 their fan base is too small, but they were the true innovators in the sport, and EVERYONE copied them, ALL the cars we see today are an evolution of LOTUS engineering...

    From achilles, on Tue 20 Jan 7:35AM
  14. @45justblowinoffsteam

    28.3 No change of car is permitted after the start of the race.
    A change of car will be deemed to have taken place once a driver is seated in his new car and such change may only take place in the team's designated garage area.

    From MGA, on Tue 20 Jan 12:56AM
  15. Is this a Dating agency?

    This is a F1 motor racing comment forum!

    From repeatalarm50, on Tue 20 Jan 12:46AM
  16. Good night, sleep tight don't let the bugs bite

    From , on Tue 20 Jan 12:00AM
  17. Ditto, 'parting is such sweet sorrow...' Another day nearer March 29th !!!

    From m.e.jenner, on Mon 19 Jan 11:59PM
  18. He he !! Just trying to be nice. Which reminds me. Time for me to go home and kiss my own special lady. Good night everyone !

    From Forza Ferrari, on Mon 19 Jan 11:57PM
  19. You old smoothie Forza !!

    From m.e.jenner, on Mon 19 Jan 11:52PM
  20. every woman is beautiful
    when she holds the hand of the man she is in love with

    From , on Mon 19 Jan 11:42PM
Sort comments by: Most recent

Not already a Yahoo! user ? to get a free Yahoo! Account