Whatever the conclusion of the FIA World Motor Sport Council (WMSC) on the salacious ‘Singapore-gate’ scandal currently engulfing Formula 1, the two men arguably at its centre – Flavio Briatore and Pat Symonds – will find a way back into the top flight one day, reasons 13-time grand prix-winner David Coulthard.
On Wednesday, it was announced that Briatore and Symonds had sensationally left their respective positions of managing director and executive director of engineering at Renault F1 [see separate story – click here], with the former claiming he did so ‘to save the team’.
That has prompted fevered speculation inside the paddock that there must be some truth behind Nelsinho Piquet’s assertion that he was instructed by his two bosses to deliberately crash out of last year’s Singapore Grand Prix, thereby enabling team-mate Fernando Alonso to triumph in the sport’s inaugural night race – and likely also prevented Renault from pulling the plug on its F1 project at season’s end.
Whilst the WMSC is due to rule on the Enstone-based outfit’s fate on Monday (21 September) – with the potential ramifications should the team be found guilty of the charge of ‘race-fixing’ stretching as far as expulsion from the world championship altogether – both Briatore and Symonds are gone. Coulthard contends that they may not be absent for long.
“I think it’s been well-documented,” the Scot told Crash.net Radio of the latest controversy to rock the top flight. “Singapore last year was the catalyst; Nelson Piquet Jnr obviously left the team and then decided to share some information with the FIA. They did an enquiry, and the end of that enquiry is that before the hearing on Monday where Renault have to step forward and explain themselves, both Flavio Briatore and Pat Symonds have left the team.
“You have to presume that that’s because there are some grey areas or something that wasn’t discussed with Renault beforehand. We’ll find out in time. I think they will both have their opportunity to say something publicly on it if they want to, for sure the FIA will enlighten us as to what happened and there will be some information that comes out of the event on Monday. People don’t leave organisations unless there’s a reason – either they did act inappropriately or they just felt it was for the greater good.
“Pat I’m sure will end up somewhere else, because he’s got a very long and successful history in motorsport. Flavio I’m sure will have a finger in some pie in Formula 1 – he’s been a great entrepreneur and had a great deal of success, and he’s never claimed to be passionate about the sport individually. It was more about the business side, and if he’s made an error of judgement then obviously he’s taken the penalty for that, but I think we have to keep in perspective that these guys are all under a great deal of pressure – and sometimes that makes them make bad decisions.”
Other ‘victims’ of the fall-out look set to include Piquet – who Coulthard’s BBC F1 colleague Martin Brundle has described as being henceforth ‘unemployable’ [see separate story – click here] – and Renault itself, which has suffered considerable losses in terms of car sales since the onset of the global credit crunch last year and whose CEO is known not to be a particular motor racing aficionado. If the French manufacturer was ready to leave before, so goes the school of thought, then nothing will be able to convince it to stay now.
“I can’t possibly know,” the Twynholm native stated of Renault’s future. “I hope [they don’t leave], but we just need to be patient and see what happens. It would be very bad for the sport if Renault pulled out – they’ve been a great supporter of Formula 1 and motorsport and have used it to good effect for the promotion of their vehicles, but these are difficult times and, if they are on the edge, something like that could push them over. Time will tell whether [Piquet] pops up at another team or not. You can’t write the final chapter in the book; we just have to wait and see.”
Whilst the name of Prodrive chairman David Richards has cropped up regarding taking over at the helm of Renault F1 in at least the short term – “He’s been there before at Enstone, he knows the set-up, he’s obviously got leadership qualities and he’s well-equipped to handle it,” argues Coulthard – it has conversely been suggested that the disgraced Briatore and Symonds could both face criminal charges for having knowingly and wilfully endangered lives. ‘DC’ contends that the whole threat level of the situation has been somewhat over-exaggerated.
“I think it’s wrong to pull out the ‘it could have hurt someone’ card,” he underlined, “because by the very nature of motorsport, at any moment there could be a very bad accident that involves a driver, a marshal or a spectator. That is the fact, that is the reality, so you can’t look at one incident and say ‘well, that’s the one that tipped it over to being really dangerous’. It’s not that type of small incident that is the thing we need to watch out for; it’s the big crashes – the cars being launched and all the rest of it. It’s a valid point in that it is increasing the danger, but I think it’s overplayed in this circumstance.
“Crashing is pretty extreme, but I have had team orders in the past where I’ve been told to move over and allow another car to come through – and at the time that was part of the sport. If we go way back to Stirling Moss’ day, drivers would come in and give their car to their team-mate if necessary to allow them to finish the race. The essence of the sport is all about team play rather than the individual, but clearly there are sporting rules that are there to define and govern the sport and what we should be seeing is the best driver/team combination winning on any given day.
“Obviously it’s damaging for the sport to have any sorts of allegations of race-fixing and this sort of thing, but hopefully we’ll be able to move on from this and it’s good that the FIA have acted. Clearly anything that effectively fixes or changes the result is a form of cheating and should be punished. Scandals don’t enhance the reputation, that’s for sure, but they are factual events that have happened and the powers-that-be – the controllers of the FIA, the controllers of the commercial rights, the controllers of the teams – are collectively responsible for the image of the sport. If they’ve acted in a way which has damaged the image of the sport, then they have to respond to that.”
It is easy to forget, finally, that against the backdrop of so much going on off-track, there remains a title fight on the circuit too, with four grands prix of the 2009 season now remaining. Whilst Red Bull magnate Dietrich Mateschitz has written off his team’s chances of denying Brawn GP glory in the wake of the energy drinks-backed operation’s Monza disaster last time out, Coulthard is adamant that nothing is over yet – even if he acknowledges that it is Jenson Button in pole position to make it back-to-back title triumphs come Abu Dhabi in just over a month’s time.
“There are 40 points available and they’re 20-odd points behind, so the fight is still on,” urged the 38-year-old, who ended his competitive career with RBR last year and has stayed on at the Milton Keynes-based squad as a consultant and occasional test driver. “It’s not over. Kimi Raikkonen came back and won the championship from that far away two years ago, so we have to keep working, keep pushing and then see what the championship brings.
“The most likely person for the championship, though, is of course Jenson Button. He had a lean period, but that’s inevitable in such a competitive championship, and he’s led the championship from the first race. He’s got a 14-point lead now and his wing-man is his team-mate, so he’ll more than likely be the world champion.”





Comment 1 - 10 of 10
Maybe Flavio could find a position as a tyre stacker with the 'Yorkshire Values', 'Notts County F1' or 'Megavalve F1' teams :-)
Pat Symonds has much to offer a team if in a less high profile capacity than hitherto, however we know Flavio is primarily a playboy wheeler dealer of the Muggly Egglestone variety who will probably have to give up his ownership of QPR since he is obviously not a 'fit and proper' person to hold such a responsibility.
I just hope Flavio does not end up replacing Mugly as F1 dictator if he does F1 will be well and truely doomed.
David displaying the quality of judgement and understanding of sound, decent, sporting, let alone socially responsible and humanitarian principles that made him always the also ran he was throughout his driving career; seems like this status will now continue in his post driving journalistic/pundit career.
Yet he was one of the top names in his time; isn't that just about as clear a statement of the decline of the sport of F1 as one can get.
Coulthard: Briatore and Symonds will be back, say David. Suck, SUCK and More SUCK. Are you hoping for a drive David?
While the blood thirsty hordes clammor for the scalps of, let's see, alphabetical order, Alonso, Briatore, Alonswo, Briatore, ad infinitum; reality must in fact take place and sensible decisions made. To date, there is nothing that has been made public that directly links Briatore except for the hearsay evidence of a kid who in a fit of pique has made unproven allegations.
The fact that both Briatore and Symonds resigned, essentially for the good of the team and the company does not in any way prove their guilt, if any. That must be proven from the facts unless there is a confession, which I do not see happening any time soon.
It is not only very interesting, but also very important that Piquet has made no public allegation that Alonso was involved in any way.
There are a whole boatload of people who have made great leaps of faith, or the lack thereof, by making rash charges against everyone involved.
If the past is any measure, those involved will be fined, suspended for a year or two, then, on good behaviour, reinstated into the F1 family. I cannot remember anyone who has been banned for life and have it hold. There are just too few people with the special talents and brains to get to the level of team principal or Director of engineering. Most of their minds are wired differently from most of the rest of us. How long did it take for the FIA to begin modifying the penalties imposed for Stepneygate? Six months or less? While it could be said that Ron Dennis left because of the penalties imposed, the facts are that he had been planning to leave for several years. He carried on for a decent period of time then left. Facts are, he is still a force within McLaren.
coultard has taken leave of his senses
C'mon Coulthard...dont you have any decent thing to say,dont say anything!!!!
Its terrible if it happens...dont you think???
It means you prefer a no rules championship..perhaps to benefit Mr. Kite?! Another words,LH!
Coultard seems to be an apoologist for behaviour that any reasonable person should find beyond acceptance. Moving over to allow a team mate past is not dangerous crashing ALWAYS is because even in a relatively same area debris can spread onto the racing line. Drivers accept the inherent danger of driving at 100% but I don`t think any driver would be happy to have an accident on debris that was caused by a deliberate crash (having said that neither Schumacher or Piquet were properly punished for thier suicide attempts in the past.)
Formula 1, like most professional sports, is corrupted by the vast amounts of money involved, and moves further and further away from anything that can be described as `sporting`.
Futchi -- I agree that it would be wrong to see the dirty apples back in and Renault out, but Renault does bear the responsibility of the actions of the team (they hired the scumbags in the first place). Briatore and Symonds should be banned for life from participating in any manner (even advisory) in any FIA sanctioned event.
.
Having (probably) asked for Briatore's and Symond's resignations when the details came to light, Renault's penalty should be mitigated, but still serious and more of a sting than McLaren's fine. At least Renault has co-operated and not attempted a cover-up like McLaren did, but this is much more serious than stealing data -- lives were endangered needlessly. Yes, I know the drivers know and accept the risk of crashes -- when they are truly accidents or racing incidents, then this is acceptable. When they are manufactured for personal gain, this is beyond the pale.
:)
It would be a shame if Renault leave and Briatore/Symonds come back.
Renault are almost certainly innocent of any direct dealing here - their staff did the dirty and should be punished.
Both should be heavily fined and banned for life from any involvement or attendence at F1 events. They should also face criminal penalties for endangering lives and corruption.
But Renault itself should be treated leniently - loss of points and return of any prize money over the past two seasons.......
There must be dozens of good people working there and it's unfair to penalise everyone for the foul behaviour of their bosses.
Please login to post a comment
Not already a Yahoo! user ? Sign up to get a free Yahoo! Account