Carter: Melandri's massive risk

Eurosport - Tue, 20 Jan 15:38:00 2009

In the harsh weather conditions that plagued the 2000 MotoGP season, much time was spent in motorhomes chatting to riders about anything and everything.

2008 Ducati Marco Melandri - 0

Over that season, I learnt a lot about the mental make-up of many of them in the premier class. Not all of them, some of them just aren't open for a natter with anyone, no matter how deep the water is that's flooding across the pitlane.

Some of the top-flight fellas however, were pretty chatty blokes.

But one conversation stuck in my mind for an awful long time, and it has served to prompt a really valid question this week; can a rider really leave MotoGP and find a way back in?

I'll conveniently forget the blip that is Sete Gibernau; let's face it, his return is nothing short of miraculous and mostly put together on his former ability to really ruffle Valentino Rossi's feathers on the 990cc boomers a few years back.

But for the rest of the riding world, MotoGP must seem like a pretty closed club.

It was this very subject that lead to a fascinating conversation in the sodden paddock of the Mugello GP race that year.

I found myself in Loris Capirossi's motorhome and we were discussing all sorts of things, good and bad with GP, WSB and football.

After some time I asked Loris is he'd ever been tempted to go to WSB, as a taster. After all, I reasoned, Loris is something of a hard-edged racer who likes a bit of elbow-to-elbow contact and the WSB series is well-known for delivering that by the bucketload.

The former 125 and 250cc World Champion, who at the time was really in with a shout of taking the crown in the 500cc class, sat there for a while and thought about the idea of switching.

He slurped whatever energy drink he was slurping and then said: "While I can be fast enough to race in this championship I would not want to leave.

"I want to stay here for as long as I can and I will do as much as I can to do that. The moment you leave, the door shuts and you cannot come back."

I thought that was interesting stuff. Here was the man who'd taken the world crown on more than one occasion, riding for one of the highest-profile teams in the world and even he came across as being a bit scared about his spot on the GP grid.

So the news that former 250cc World Champion Marco Melandri, who has now been left very high and dry by the withdrawal of Kawasaki's factory effort from the MotoGP championship, has said that he would be happy to have a year away from MotoGP and return in 2010, is very puzzling indeed.

Is Marco THAT sure of his position in the greater scale of things? Is he privy to some information that none of us know about with regards to Kawasaki's future in a couple of season's time?

Here's his quote to Reuters about the situation: "It wouldn't be great but... to stop for a year would not be a huge problem. I'm waiting. I hope the date is not put back because it is better to know for sure that you won't be racing, rather than carrying on with uncertainty."

Now that sounds completely upside down to me. Certainly after taking on board what Loris said all those years ago I came away from the MotoGP paddock with a very different view to a rider's longevity than Marco has.

But you've got to admire his nerve. I guess though, at the end of the day, with grid numbers dropping as seriously as they are in MotoGP that previously shut door could soon be flung open to any and all who can get a bike round a circuit quickly enough.

Tony Carter / Eurosport

Comment 1 - 8 of 8

Sort comments by: Most recent
  1. perhaps melandri should take a leave out of capirossi's book and go back to 250's. loris was not doing too well on the old 500's , dropped back to 250's and came back stronger.

    From simonpbrooke, on Sat 31 Jan 6:26PM
  2. marco is not strong enough of late..but being in camp ducati could bring him back to his best,although he will have to keep the bike upright first and finish races.He`s a good rider but i think there are better up and comin riders....divioso on a factory honda wiil be one 2 watch but sorry guys rossi is still the man 2 beat,and stoner is still up there!cant wait till it kicks off

    From rossbrown303, on Sat 24 Jan 4:35PM
  3. bbradshaw909, You got that right. I clearly remember the incident. if you can’t win complain. that was Gibernau’s way but he did have a couple of good races.

    However Gibernau is too old for a comeback, the young lions will eat him for breakfast

    From barry.riddell, on Thu 22 Jan 3:42PM
  4. Marco is a winner and will be again. Sete was nothing and will be again. Sete is there only cause he is spanish and rich. How many races did he win on the Ducati? Oh None... Yeh Sete turned the bike into a winner... what ever!!

    From Travis L, on Wed 21 Jan 2:10PM
  5. Politics came in long ago. It's partly why Rossi moved to Yamaha, and Camel moved away from Yamaha, also why Moviestar pulled out, why Gouloise did the same. It's not just about riders, it's about relationships and at some point results. Gibernau's return isn't just down to pure friendship or his origin, it's also down to Stoner requesting he return to give feedback, as the prior development he did for the bike made it a winner, without him, it was fast, but largely a brut in anyone other than Stoner's hands...

    From EGK, on Wed 21 Jan 5:47AM
  6. The word "Ruffle" mean to annoy someone, and well, Giberneu, even when complaining did that. They often exchanged arguments, striaght eye to eye looks and sometimes even laughs. But, even from Rossi himself "I want him to be close so I can really fight someone that wants it as much as me". As for Melandri, it's a bould move, with rumours in Italy that Piaggio will race a new Aprilia motogp bike in 2010 and also Team Roberts have agreed to work, co-develop and build the Ilmor bikes for 2010 he could easily find a ride. Honda have also spoken about running 9 bikes next year as long as sponsors and suitable teams apply to their current working ideas. So, fingers crossed...

    From EGK, on Wed 21 Jan 5:42AM
  7. In this article the author says that Sete has been brought make in to motogp because of his ability to really ruffle Vale's feathers. What? I don't deny that Gibernau is a good rider, but if you remember back to Qatar, I think it was 04' maybe, Gibernau and his team filed some bulls**t complaint about Rossi's team cleaning their grid spot. Wether they did or not is not my point, in a press interview at Qatar, Rossi said that Gibernau would never win another gp. And since that day he has not. This year he gets another shot, but I'd say it's Rossi who done most of the ruffling. As for Marco, one of the best riders in recent times not to get a factory ride. The politics of GP.

    From bbradshaw909, on Wed 21 Jan 4:52AM
  8. Marco is a great rider and I think that had he been Spanish he could have had a seat on a factory Honda after a great year on the satellite bike. I was at Assen and watched him keep Rossi honest on the 990's, which he did on more than one occasion that season.

    From Holty, on Tue 20 Jan 7:59PM
Sort comments by: Most recent

Not already a Yahoo! user ? to get a free Yahoo! Account