Lions 2009 - Lions lauded despite Durban loss

Eurosport - Mon, 22 Jun 08:56:00 2009

The British and Irish Lions have received glowing reports in the Sunday papers despite losing to South Africa in the first Test.

2009 South Africa-British and Irish Lions Tommy Bowe JP Pietersen - 0

The press said the Lions' late fightback shook their hosts and left them relieved to have come away with a 26-21 win.

The Springboks produced a crushing forward display to cement their victory in the first of the three-match series at the Absa Stadium in Durban on Saturday.

"We saw epic power rugby, gorgeous rugby (most played by men in red), controversy, and amazing last-yard defending. We had an epic finale and at last, something to do rugby proud," said Stephen Jones in The Sunday Times.

"But the Lions would trade the whole lot in for the one thing this dramatic afternoon in Durban did not bring - a victory."

A late converted try for the Lions "would have sealed a comeback that would have rendered the return of Lazarus as something entirely predictable."

Former Lions fly-half Stuart Barnes, also writing in The Sunday Times said the tourists had to produce the game of their lives to level the series next Saturday.

"The good news is they have the ability and, more importantly, the bravery to push the world champions all the way," the Englishman said.

"The last 20 minutes proved the team have the mental courage, the skill and tempo to win; that if they start as they finished in Durban, they will prevail in Pretoria."

But Lawrence Dallaglio, the former England captain and ex-Lions forward, writing in The Sunday Times, said: ""The Lions didn't do what they set out to do.

"The Lions players will be feeling deperately frustrated. All they needed was parity in the forwards and they would have won.

"Their attacking game constantly found holes in the Springbok defence and everything we hoped for from the partnership of Jamie Roberts and Brian O'Driscoll came to pass. They were excellent."

Former Springboks coach Nick Mallett, writing in The Sunday Telegraph, said both sets of coaches contributed to their team's problems.

"The Springboks, besides looking at their defence, will also reconsider their growing habit of making lots of substitutions when they think games are won," he wrote.

"The Lions will have to rethink selection for next Saturday. They cannot make the same mistake of fielding Phil Vickery and Lee Mears in the front row."

The News of the World's Andy Dunn said the Lions were "Pummelled by the Springbok pack, shamed in the scrum, humiliated in the lineout.

However, "There is hope because of a fightback that showed spirit runs deep in this touring party," he added.

Patrick Collins, in The Mail on Sunday, said of the tourists' late flourish: "South Africa prevailed, and probably deserved to. Yet the Lions departed with heads high and jaws set in truculent defiance.

"Barely beaten in Durban, the men of 2009 may yet be on the brink of immortality."

But in The Observer, Paul Hayward said: "The essence of Lions rugby was on vibrant display, even if this result amounts to a missed opportunity to strike a result against the best team in the world before the circus moves to altitude on Saturday.

"To be brutal, the chances are that the northern hemisphere's representatives will lose 3-0, because the Springboks will not repeat their display of complacency when the Lions already seemed to be on the barbecue."

AFP

Comment 26 - 45 of 45

Sort comments by: Most recent
  1. I'm with 'LEE R' - much impassioned,­ irrational & mindless bias!

    Being in deepest S­ France I watch 'pay games' at an 'Irish­ Pub' full of wee green folk on holiday, thanks to­ Ryan! Each match has been marked by frenzy when an­ Irish player gets a touch, but zero interest for others­ - weird! (Just because of a 1st Grand Slam in 60­ years!?)

    They should remember that their team beat­ England 'by default' in '09 - England, like­ the Lions, ran out of time! - BUT -

    I'm not saying­ that English players acquitted themselves brilliantly­ in the Test, ANY MORE than the rest - Centres­ apart!

    The hard truth is that the Lions pack, no­ matter who is there, is really 'lightweight'­ (not necessarily in Kg) by comparison with the Boks at­ their best & most brutal.

    The Lions CANNOT win the­ series - they just don't have the firepower up­ front to gain the ascendancy & ball necessary to­ enable their backs (any picked, I reckon) to rip the­ bu...rs to bits as they showed they could do!

    Had they­ won this Test it would have been a travesty, brought­ about by the weird SA 'ease up' in the 2nd­ half. The totality of the inevitable defeat at­ half-time was so complete & depressing, I have­ seldom been more without hope when watching any rugby­ team I support in a big match - it WAS all­ over!

    Sheridan (if fit) & Shaw may introduce a bit­ more brute force & savagery to things (NOT­ O'Callaghan - great player for 6 Nations but not­ what's needed here!) - but - the scrums will NOT be­ remedied, I fear, & that's where it will go to­ hell - probably lineouts too - NOT the thrower's­ fault - in Matfield, the Boks have the best (for the­ past 20 years, at least, as a lineout winner, even­ better - a good deal better - than Martin Johnson or­ Willie John, I reckon!)

    Finally, there is NO ONE to­ replicate the devastation wreaked by (wee) Neil Back,­ Hill & Dallaglio (or F Slattery) in th

    From Anthony S, on Mon 22 Jun 5:58PM
  2. Lee R - superb comment wish everyone would think like­ that. June / July 2009 WE are The LIONS end of story.

    From Joe B, on Mon 22 Jun 3:48PM
  3. It wasn't all Vickerys fault, there wasn't much­ grunt behind him in second row from Jones. Mears was­ too small and didn't give him enough support, also­ Mtawarira didn't srumage square he came in at an­ angle and was able to screw Vickery and Mears. When­ Jones came on he had O'Callaghan and Rees to­ support him so his job was easier.............Thats the­ first time I've ever defended Vickery and I'm a­ Paddy

    From John, on Mon 22 Jun 11:35AM
  4. The english players where found out.Vickery was a­ joke,uho moyne has to be replace by like fitzgerald,rob­ carney has to start,jones must be replaced by o­ gara..the english left everybody down once more

    From sugruejames55, on Mon 22 Jun 10:54AM
  5. The Lions are simply not good enough. Croft, Moyne,­ Vickery, Jones, Mears and Byrne were all out of sorts­ and need to be replace. Wyn Jones is too light weight­ and the Lions need an enforcer at second row -­ O'Callaghan! Phillips dithers too much at the break­ down and needs to speed up his delivery to the out­ half.

    We won't win but at least six of the team­ must be changed for next week.

    From John, on Mon 22 Jun 10:34AM
  6. Post #23, For your information Ryan Jones spent 2 days­ with the squad before being sent back home due to­ concussion he recieved in the USA game. Please keep up.

    From David, on Mon 22 Jun 10:16AM
  7. Paul O'Connell's pick and drives deliver­ excellent quick ball for the scrumhalves. He never gets­ turned over and rips the ball from the opposition quite­ often, and he's excellent in the lineouts (with­ decent throwing/lifting). How anyone can still question­ his place is beyond me.

    With a couple of Changes in­ the front row and Hines in beside POC for test 2 and­ the boks will have to work an awful lot harder!
    With­ Rees throwing in and Jones doing a better job lifting­ we won all our lineouts. The scrums turned in our­ favour immiediately, before the Beast and Smit were­ taken off remember, the bulk of Hines will only help­ this and he'll help more around the fringes which­ also improved greatly after the­ substitutions.

    O'Gara should get his shot now with­ Jones on the bench. Hook will only delay the ball from­ getting to O'Driscoll and Roberts. He has a go­ himself far to often, which is too dangerous against­ the Boks who are experts at turning ball over.­ O'Gara will have the ball flung out wide long­ before they get to him.

    Fitzgerald in for Monye and­ Kearney to start at full back. If Byrne is injured­ I'd have Earls on the bench as cover.

    I think the­ Lions players will be licking their lips thinking about­ the next test. If they start the next one like they­ finished the last one the boks are in for a torrid­ time!
    C'MON THE LION!!!!!

    From ptothej, on Mon 22 Jun 8:59AM
  8. lol-lost control of me computer!!! The lions simply­ won't fair any better next week cause we can't­ compete with the fit forwards on available. POC­ should'nt be picked regarless of the fact that­ he's the captain. He aint got over the gain line­ once to my recollection in any of his games. A wet­ pitch in Ireland is different gravy to the hard fast­ tracks of SA. Next week will be worse than this week­ due to altitude and the boks are more match hardened.­ Its a shame cause we've got the back to really push­ them
    Just my thought before i get savaged!!!!

    From Simon W, on Mon 22 Jun 12:20AM
  9. Is it time to have no Englishmen in the Lions team. An­ all welsh front row is needed. Hines or Wyn Jones in­ the second row with P. O'Connell. (Could have S.­ SHaw on the bench toa dd a bit of grunt in the last­ twenty minutes). Croft did score two tries but was­ anonymous for most of the game. The second try Croft­ was nowhere near where the hard work was being done by­ the rest of the forwards. Martyn Williams could of done­ the same thing. \Williams even won lineout ball­ which croft failed to do. Monye should of scored two­ tries. Is that why England would not have picked him­ this year before the other wingers became injured?
    It­ would be a sad reflection of the English game. The only­ change I would make would be for a good out half.­ Cipriani could really make the space for the LIons­ backs.
    From Keith W. SUn. 22 June 2009

    From kwalker737, on Mon 22 Jun 12:19AM
  10. The lions were simply no match in the contact/collision­ with the boks, Vickery is a good prop(and i'm welsh­ saying that!!!) you could clearly see the SA prop­ pushing across instead of straight, mears aint big­ enough to support Vickery making him look terrible.­ Adam Jones looked better cause he had Rees(bigger)­ alongside most of the time he was on the pitch. T

    From Simon W, on Mon 22 Jun 12:15AM
  11. why do all these message boards end up at the same­ point time after time after time.....?!?!?! What is it­ that makes discussion of a sport we all profess to love­ end up in petty pathetic name calling and trading of­ ridiculous insults about our respective home­ countries?!?!? Am sick and tired of reading that c@%p.­ I am Welsh and am a huge fan of the whole­ history,ethos,of the lions, embodying everything that­ is good about bringing the best players from four­ countries together and pitting them against the best­ teams in the world. I watched the game on saturday with­ goosebumps( thats the little bumps on the skin, not the­ nickname of one of my mates!).Being honest i think­ South Africa just about deserved the win.To the­ impartial fan it must have been fantastic to watch, as­ for me it aged me 10 years!! The Springboks were­ immense in areas and had weaknesses in others, stangely­ enough the Lions were immense in areas and had­ weaknesses in others.Both coaching teams made tactical­ blunders, Mix it all up in massive couldron of fervent­ supporters and wait to see whats dished up. the answer­ was that it had everything, a concoction of sublime­ play, dismal play,misplaced overconfidence, guts and­ tenacity etc... Dont know about anybody else but i am­ looking forward to the 2nd test even more than the­ first having seen the potential for an amazing­ encounter. Will not pretend that i dont want the lions­ to win, but if they dont the springboks will have­ proven to be the better team and should be applauded­ for that. So lets all just enjoy it as fans and have a­ bit of friendly banter, it is a game after all.

    From Lee R, on Mon 22 Jun 12:08AM
  12. Comment hidden due to its low rating. Show

    Roberts is a slightly bigger version of Tindall,­ without any skill he has to be replaced by a fleeting­ player like Flutey, how the hell do players with­ nothing but grunt to offer, suddenly become GOOD just­ because they are not a pommie, very puzzling.

    From s27prs, on Sun 21 Jun 10:37PM
  13. well done the boks, must admit, some of the comments­ about the BEAST, yeah he had a field day with vickery,­ but when the hairbear (Adam Jones) came on he was more­ like a @#$% cat, oh yeah Smit the only time you saw him­ was scoring the first try and going off,no change from­ Gethin Jenkins,typical boks fans we didnt see at any­ time SA looking like scoring from the backs, all SA­ have is heave Ho again.. we bigger we stronger
    V. good­ set of forwards, the wingers on about lack of play time­ for the boks, substitutions,lions been together 6 weeks­ never played with each other, only goes to show that­ as usual EXCUSES come out when things go wrong!! every­ time the Lions backs had the ball they made ground and­ threatend the line.. not so the glorius SA, rolling­ mall try..(Yawn Yawn) rule change cant bring it­ down...miss throw from Lions @#$% mears and try number­ one stoppable..altitude and a dodgy ref orderd for the­ next test match, oh no what are we to do.... try thats­ it lets all have a good game and stop kicking the poor­ ball to death, amd play rugby in the way it was ment to­ be played open and entertaining not just the bish bash­ game of big men, but speed of thought and gile and team­ work.. creates trys.. written at altitude on top of­ sand dune in blackpool.. oh to be in SA !!

    From ian960, on Sun 21 Jun 7:34PM
  14. Since when did subs become the b players? Or are the­ boks subs just so bad thats what you call them? I seem­ to remember the lions brining on o'callahan, jones,­ kearney,rees, same amount as you lot or 1 less maybe­ cant remember. Its irrelevant to say we played your b­ squad, actually just discriminating your own squad:L­ and when the lions pick the right pack next week(ie­ rees, jones, and hines to deal with Botha) you will­ need to use your subs as you couldnt cope when we heald­ the ball and ran you lot ragged! Then you will have to­ put on your 'b' players where as we will have­ quality subs to make an impact, face it we outplayed­ your A team, we just made some wrong starting picks,­ whereas de villiers has probably knowen pretty much his­ best 22 for months. Hope that smile is wiped off your­ smarmy south african face next week!! COME ON LIONS,­ TIME TO ROAR!! Roberts and O'driscoll have you­ @#$%ting yourselfs!! as de villiers is cr*p and that­ sub fourie is it? was no btter!!

    From bmuirboy, on Sun 21 Jun 7:02PM
  15. Comment hidden due to its low rating. Show

    WRT to Scotland and Wales and England - they all lost­ against the Boks! The almost, and should have's are­ irrelevant! They all lost in the own backyard! Rugby is­ played over 80 minutes and not 30! Especially when the­ other team is so far ahead and coasting, the coach­ idiotically decides to bring on substitutes which­ clearly disrupted the side. Why did that raved about­ Lions side not perform well against the­ A-team?Mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm!

    From michaelsmith470, on Sun 21 Jun 6:43PM
  16. Comment hidden due to its low rating. Show

    In 1997, the Lions scored 3 tries and the Boks 9! Guess­ who one the series? If it had been the other way­ around, we would have 12 yrs of bleating over the ref!­ The best of 4 Countries failed to beat a small sad­ little country! It is a simple game - the team with the­ most points wins! This concept appears to be too­ difficult for most Lions supporters to grasp!

    From michaelsmith470, on Sun 21 Jun 6:30PM
  17. Replying to lassiestevens, even I (as a bok supporter)­ agree that Jamie Roberts and B O'Driscoll played­ exceptionally well on Saturday, destroying the SA­ midfeld. But to say Jean de Villiers is a weak link is­ not quite fair, yes maybe Adi Jacobs is, but de­ Villiers made a try saving tackle on Monye. In my view­ it should be Jean de Villiers at 12 and Jaque Fourie at­ 13 with Wynand Olivier on the bench, Adi Jacobs is­ simply not good enough all-round. Lets hope Peter de­ Villiers doesn't make a pigs ear out of it in­ Pretoria!

    From avianadventures, on Sun 21 Jun 6:01PM
  18. fact of the matter is the lions crossed the boks try­ line SIX times - shd really have beaten them by 10­ points - fair play to the boks forwards tho especially­ at the scrum - was reminsiscent of the Lions of 74­ which murdered all South African scrums- hopefully two­ good tests to come

    From dhgigg, on Sun 21 Jun 4:55PM
  19. As a BOK supporter living in the UK ,the newspaper­ articles today praising the Lions
    are a little bit­ blinkered in the Lions favour. The Springboks had not­ played a competitive match since november 2008, the­ Lions have played 6 in recent weeks, come off it who­ pays these sports reporters.AND GUESS WHAT WHO WON THAT­ IS THE BOTTOM LINE IN

    From GRAHAME C, on Sun 21 Jun 3:57PM
  20. Notice how none of us are abusing the Bokkes, calling­ them names or displaying a childish immature­ behavaiour. Remember its only a game will you, no­ wonder the rest of the World didn`t want to be involved­ with you for so long with that kind of attitude, no­ doubt still upset that your ancestors aren`t allowed to­ run the country like they used to. Take it out on the­ blogs here, real brave in hiding.
    WELL DONE BOYS­ GREAT GAME TO WATCH IT HAD IT ALL , EXCEPT THE­ FAIRYTAIL ENDING, GET THE SELECTION RIGHT AND WE WILL­ DISTROY THE SUPERIOR RACE.

    From trufftastic, on Sun 21 Jun 3:51PM
Sort comments by: Most recent

Not already a Yahoo! user ? to get a free Yahoo! Account