AFP afpji

Messi tops Ronaldo as world star - study

Tue 23 Jun, 08:58 PM


MADRID (AFP) - Cristiano Ronaldo may be the world's most expensive footballer, but Barcelona star Lionel Messi outshines him in terms of media value, at least according to a team of Spanish researchers.

The team from the University of Navarra said the Argentine had ousted the Portuguese striker as the player with the highest profile last season.

However, Ronaldo remains the most expensive player, with the researchers valuing him at 82 million euros, less than the world record 93 million Real Madrid paid Manchester United for him this month.

Messi was next at 80 million, followed by Liverpool's Spanish striker Fernando Torres at 67 million.

The study cited Barcelona's European Champions League victory, and Messi's goal in the final, for his leap to number one in the media rankings over last year's winner Ronaldo.

It forecast "an exciting media fight between these two brilliant players" next season.

In team rankings, it recorded a "technical tie" between Barcelona (86.2 points) and Manchester United (86.0 points).

But the manager with the most media pulling power was United's Alex Ferguson, ahead of Barca's Pep Guardiola.

 

Comment 1 - 19 of 19

Sort comments by: Most recent
  1. messi is now the world best player.

    From gloryadusaforo, on Mon 20 Jul 11:28AM
  2. With his big ego CR will find it difficult to live­ alongside LM in La Liga and that might affect his game.

    From cokrowinoto, on Thu 25 Jun 2:15AM
  3. enough with all the Bu.ll.shi.t about messi playing in­ premier league. find another excuse u fkin blind man­ utd fans. messi was the best this season and­ ronaldo's performances all over the year do not­ place him even in the top 5. the only thing epl has­ more is money muppets

    From Varnavas P, on Wed 24 Jun 2:26PM
  4. Definitely he'll be voted the best player FIFA of­ the year this December. Mark my words! Ronaldo will­ only be second to him, if not third.

    From random_access88, on Wed 24 Jun 1:05PM
  5. Agree with getachew44.For me I still support Man­ U..eitheir the team got a big name or not next­ season.Thanks to Ronaldo for the previous season...next­ season Ronaldo already put his name into the History of­ the Club,like Ruud,Becks..and any other name whom­ already feel the Grass of Old Trafford also the­ pleasure of "THEATRE OF DREAM".

    From Mohamad, on Wed 24 Jun 12:14PM
  6. Agree with getachew44.For me I still support Man­ U..eitheir the team got a big name or not next­ season.Thanks to Ronaldo for the previous season...next­ season Ronaldo already put his name into the History of­ the Club,like Ruud,Becks..and any other name whom­ already feel the Grass of Old Trafford also the­ pleasure of "THEATRE OF DREAM".

    From Mohamad, on Wed 24 Jun 11:48AM
  7. I would like to see Messi's so called world ranking­ after he has spent a year or two in the English­ Premiership. I think he will find it far too­ competitive for him. It is no surprise that he does not­ relish playing in England and the same goes for Kaka,­ Villa and the rest of the so called World's best.

    From BRIAN, on Wed 24 Jun 9:55AM
  8. Comment hidden due to its low rating. Show

    ronaldo will outshine messi in la liga just watch

    From Paul T, on Wed 24 Jun 9:15AM
  9. we should agree that ronaldo had a bad season if we saw­ the season before how he played. messi did an amaising­ job in barca as individual and as team player.

    From jeff_zall, on Wed 24 Jun 8:33AM
  10. Given that I know a thing or two about this­ institution, I would assume that the media data used by­ this reseach team is of Spanish media, NOT global­ media. If that's the case, which is very likely­ (since global media data would be very then to obtain)­ then its absolutely no surprise that Messi has a higher­ media ranking in SPAIN than Ronaldo. I could have told­ you that...and not waste the good Univ's time and­ money.

    From Mark V, on Wed 24 Jun 8:23AM
  11. c.shewan, agree with you. I'm not trying to­ discredit the whole University of Navarra as they are a­ fine institution which I actually know quite well. I­ also know quite well the passion that Catalans (common­ folk to dignitaries) have for their beloved FC­ Barcelona. With that, I just question the purpose and­ validity of this particular piece of research given­ both their proximity to FC Barcelona and Messi's­ obvious popularity in the region.

    From Mark V, on Wed 24 Jun 8:12AM
  12. Messi is a joy to watch and plays fantastic football,­ surely he is a way better than Ronaldo. Ronaldo is a­ very good footballer, but he does not deserve to be­ world's #1.

    From Dubek, on Wed 24 Jun 8:06AM
  13. Today, there is no real football star. Its all about­ marketing. When Ronaldo Rivaldo Zidane etc were best in­ the world, they were good both at club level and at­ national team level. Today there is no such player.­ Messi is good but very greedy because people make him­ believe he can win single handedly like Maradona used­ to. I would prefer Ronaldo in my team because he has­ more in his arsenal than Messi. Messi can get pass­ three defenders but it doesnt make sense if a fourth­ gets the ball away especially when ETo'o is begging­ for the ball. Ronaldinho at his best was more pleasure­ to watch than Messi.

    From Richie, on Wed 24 Jun 8:00AM
  14. University of Navarra is a very professional outfit­ with no political or footballing biases. It seems out­ of place to criticise their research when people have­ not taken time to understand the research or who did­ it.

    From c.shewan, on Wed 24 Jun 7:54AM
  15. University of Navarra's main campus is in­ Barcelona, which is probably were this research came­ from. Perhaps a little bias in the report??? Waste of­ time and effort. They should be doing better­ things...BTW, there is absolutely no question that­ Ronaldo has more marketing value than Messi.

    From Mark V, on Wed 24 Jun 7:21AM
  16. they should get back to reading books, idiots.

    From JACK, on Tue 23 Jun 10:23PM
  17. Comment hidden due to its low rating. Show

    Messi would be @#$% in a decent league like Premier­ England.

    From jason, on Tue 23 Jun 10:14PM
  18. Guess who won the CL Final?????

    From Top Dog, on Tue 23 Jun 10:11PM
  19. wtf football is not science to make reaserch
    ronaldo is­ the current golden ball and fifa prize­ winner
    ronaldinho and beckham are still in top 5 TV­ favour does that make them the best now?
    rediculous­ research!

    From getachew44, on Tue 23 Jun 9:25PM
Sort comments by: Most recent

Not already a Yahoo! user ? to get a free Yahoo! Account