Transfers - Your view: City a top four club?

Eurosport - Wed, 24 Jun 10:03:00 2009

Roque Santa Cruz is confident Manchester City are showing enough ambition to break into the top four, but do you agree?

FOOTBALL 2008-2009 Premier League Blackburn Roque Santa Cruz - 0

The Paraguayan has joined Gareth Barry in signing for the Eastlands outfit, and with Carlos Tevez reportedly close to becoming a City player, the future appears to be bright for Mark Hughes's side.

But does the club have what it takes to finally break the Big Four? If so, when? Can City's mega-rich owners expect an instant return on their investments, or will they have to be patient?

Hughes certainly has the financial clout to compete with any club in the world, but is that enough?

It remains to be seen how these new recruits gel and with the likes of Robinho and Elano still at the club, might there be further problems in the dressing room next season?

What do you think? Have your say below or on the message board forums via the link underneath the photo.

This is what you've been saying already:

Ben: "Man City are now steeped in class in every department¬ from best goalie in the world to best forwards, you¬ have to have all that class in the team to win a¬ premiership title."

yip: "I think they are looking good now. Looks like they will¬ sign Tevez then once they buy a centre-back they are¬ sorted."

Isaac: "(Santa Cruz is) another disappointed signing. Will end up just like¬ Bellamy. What a waste of money. Strengthen the¬ defence, that's where City are really weak."

Eurosport

Comment 76 - 95 of 95

Sort comments by: Most recent
  1. Chelsea were the last team to buy the league and they­ brought in a lot of players new players over 2 seasons.­ Cech, Carvalho, Bridge, ferriera, geremi, Johnson,­ Makele, duff, Cole, Drogba and Robben. They even got­ rid of some under permformers after the first season­ such as mutu, crespo and veron. Compare that to Robinho­ SWP, Barry, Santa Cruz and Bellamy and Tevez. Some­ great players but wheres the defence?

    From juddaz1982, on Wed 24 Jun 10:51PM
  2. City have to deliver now for the 1 st time in years!­ Beating Man United in their cup final is not good­ enough.lets see how long it is before they turn on­ Hughes.

    From TERRY K, on Wed 24 Jun 7:01PM
  3. man city wont break in the top 4 yet as long they got­ mark hughes in charge.

    From ANTHONY H, on Wed 24 Jun 3:27PM
  4. WHAT A LOAD OF JELOUSE @#$% YOU ARE

    CTID

    From RAYMOND P, on Wed 24 Jun 3:14PM
  5. Comment hidden due to its low rating. Show

    They could have the best players in the World but would­ never be top 4 with the muppet in charge

    From BRIAN, on Wed 24 Jun 2:41PM
  6. No. We are a top10 team atm...but it is mightily­ encouraging to see that the squad has been­ strengthened, with more to come i hope.
    The only thing­ that keeps the Top4 in place is the amount spent on the­ squad over several seasons. When City continue to lure­ top quality players over a few seasons, then the­ chances of breaking into the Top4 will come. We can­ outspend almost every club bearing in mind that United­ have recieved about 200mil in the last months (50 mil­ for CL, 50mil TV rights, 35mil for the league, 60 mil­ for Cron...and the list goes on).
    Liverpool and Arsenal­ can't keep up with the spending power of City and­ will eventually be overtaken. Its only a matter of­ time.

    From Andy, on Wed 24 Jun 1:49PM
  7. Comment hidden due to its low rating. Show

    Man City are just all talk
    and dr_vongise1 riikard has­ signed for galatasary not long ago
    City fans should­ just get real and face the fact that they won't­ break into the top 4
    and Utd fans should face the fact­ that the league is coming home to anfeild this season­ because man u players are eether too old, or not old­ enough to win the EPL
    It's laughable that Utd fans­ think they are goin to dominate the EPL for years,­ Liverpool and Chelsea will share the next 5-6 titles

    From Maggie, on Wed 24 Jun 12:32PM
  8. Man City should Get a Good Manager (Rikaard)will do,or­ @#$% Advocat

    From dr_vongise1, on Wed 24 Jun 12:06PM
  9. Comment hidden due to its low rating. Show

    city fans getting carried away again,we will not finish­ in the top 6 as usual

    From S, on Wed 24 Jun 10:54AM
  10. Could be, but only if they acquire a 'top four'­ manager!

    From mambles, on Wed 24 Jun 10:46AM
  11. rexy comment 77 wake up...u still dreaming.

    From Monkey L, on Wed 24 Jun 10:37AM
  12. if city keep building the way they are tho, and they­ keep hughes then breaking into top 4, breaking into a­ title race is only a matter of time.

    From kirstyrixom, on Wed 24 Jun 10:19AM
  13. lots of people think utd will slip this year, its a­ laugh really but we will see, losing ronaldo is a big­ loss, no hiding but we have more than just ronaldo.. I­ honestly think utd will come into this season fighting,­ no complacencey this year becasue everyone thinks we­ are down.... chelsea are ageing but i think they still­ have skill and liverpool may still lose key players but­ they are still the top 3 teams for me... arsenal for me­ are the weak link, they still may lose players as well­ and if they lose even one midfielder they are in­ trouble... and then city who I think will be with­ arsenal for most of the year.. city will have the squad­ but may need time to mesh, arsenal are meshed but dont­ have the squad, so forth spot will be a 2 horse­ race.... but then again ya never know do ya.

    From kirstyrixom, on Wed 24 Jun 10:17AM
  14. rocky is an injury awaiting to happen the only answer­ is hughes out, john

    From ROGERSON, on Wed 24 Jun 4:35AM
  15. Comment hidden due to its low rating. Show

    Osas, Well i dont think Man City can break into that­ big four spot next season. Aston Villa tried it last­ season but it doesnt work, so i dont think man city can­ do either.

    From osto, on Wed 24 Jun 1:28AM
  16. man city have the money, the manager and they might­ have the players but money needs to be spent wisely,­ the manager who has never managed a big club or big­ players needs to up his game and the players need to­ gel.

    I dont think that is going to happen. They are­ trying to be the next chelsea which is way of as­ chelsea had a decent team to start of with and were in­ the champions league. I think results arent gona go man­ citys way and mark hughes is gona get sacked the­ players arent gona gel and city will finnish at best­ 7th.

    as a player i would rather go to any other team­ than go to man city because people will be expecting­ too much from you at man city.

    cruz is a good player­ but his not gona get 20 goals, as for robinho he is­ good but players got see what he can do and will deal­ with easy. teves would be crazy to join man city rather­ than chelsea were he will be very explosive.

    From blue, on Tue 23 Jun 10:22PM
  17. No, no offence, but i do not think that Mark Hughes has­ the capability to take city to the top. They have so­ much money going on players that aren't worth it.­ Spend it on a wage for a decent manager! (Harry­ Redknapp would do best)

    From Rory C, on Tue 23 Jun 10:14PM
  18. I'd like to see Man C do well. I have a feeling­ though that it's a bit soon for them yet. We shall­ see!

    COYS.

    From lee, on Tue 23 Jun 10:03PM
  19. Get real, you stupid ManUtd fans... Forget about the­ EPL... You have no chance next season.
    You're not­ only losing CRon and Tevez but also Giggs and Scholes­ coz they are just way too old and slow...
    You also have­ an 80y.o. keeper in Van Der Sar...
    Then of course­ Neville is no longer useful while Hargreaves and Brown­ are injured 4ever...
    And who's going to be your­ backup striker? that Macheda guy again?

    As of right­ now, your line-up looks like this:
    VDS
    Da Silva, Vidic,­ Rio, Evra
    Nani, Carrick, Fletcher, Anderson
    Rooney,­ Berbatov
    Bench: Giggs, Scholes, O'Shea, Park,­ Neville

    You know what? Your midfield simply sucks and­ doesn't scare anyone.

    Check this out:
    Liverpool:­ Gerrard, Alonso, Mascherano, Riera, Kuyt,­ Benayoun
    Chelsea: Lampard, Essien, Obi, Ballack,­ Malouda, J.Cole
    Arsenal: Fabregas, Nasri, Walcott,­ Diaby, Denilson, Rosicky
    ManCity: Ireland, SWP, Barry,­ Elano, De Jong, Kompany, Petrov

    NOW...
    IF SAF can buy­ BOTH Ribery and Benzema.
    AND IF both gel quickly.
    AND­ IF Berbatov becomes a lot better.
    AND IF this Brazilian­ Douglas guy is the really the next Ronaldinho.
    AND IF­ Nani and Tosic grow up.
    AND IF Hargreaves comes back­ strong and everyone else stays healthy.
    AND IF you are­ lucky something happens to the other teams through­ injuries or transfers,

    THEN maybe you have a chance to­ win EPL again.

    Otherwise, concentrate on maintaining­ your top 4 position because as of right now it seems­ you are at best a 3rd-4th place team, and ManCity is­ already strong enough to challenge. Mind you that you­ can keep on talking about that 80mil but the truth is­ even at this point, ManCity still has definitely WAY­ MORE than 80mil to spend.

    From Rexy, on Tue 23 Jun 8:58PM
  20. they're not a top four club yet but they could be­ in a few years. first, to attract the highest quality­ players they need to win something, and since city­ aren't even in europe the coming season, that will­ take some time IMO. the top 4 will not change next­ season.

    From the_smiths_rule, on Tue 23 Jun 8:55PM
Sort comments by: Most recent

Not already a Yahoo! user ? to get a free Yahoo! Account