Eurosport - Thu, 25 Jun 21:03:00 2009
WTA chief Larry Scott has said the tour can no longer turn a deaf ear to the grunting phenomenon that has swept women's tennis.
Instead of marvelling at the quality of the forehands and backhands, shriek-hunters have crammed courts to monitor the ear-splitting sounds from the likes of Maria Sharapova, Victoria Azarenka or new kid on the block Michelle Larcher de Brito.
"I've been used to hearing that controversy this fortnight over 20 years. The other 50 weeks of the year I would not say it has been a significant issue," Scott (pictured), who leaves his post at the end of this month after six months at the helm, said.
"(But) this year it has expanded beyond that. At Roland Garros, I agree, we started hearing about this and reading about it in a way we hadn't before outside Wimbledon. Based on that we have started a process of looking at it more carefully."
Larcher de Brito, a 16-year-old Portuguese teenager, created a commotion at Roland Garros with her howls.
It provided the perfect opportunity for British tabloid newspapers to think up noise metaphors about police sirens, aircraft taking off and bull elephants bellowing.
Scott said the tour wanted the focus to return to tennis so officials will be keeping a close eye on noise levels.
"There are rules in place. There are hindrance rules. Chair umpires are empowered to issue warnings, point penalties if there is a feeling that it's gamesmanship affecting play.
"But I don't think we're at that point of sort of changing the instructions to the chair umpires. It's just being monitored a little bit more closely right now.
"I haven't had players come to me in my six years as head of the WTA to say this is a competition issue. At least up till now, it has been more of an issue about the presentation of the sport, and it hasn't really been a competition issue."
Another thing that has caused confusion among fans is the ranking system. Since Belgian Justine Henin retired in May 2008, the top ranking has been occupied by five different players.
Of those, Serbia's Jelena Jankovic and current incumbent Dinara Safina have never won a grand slam and that has led many people to criticise the way the rankings are calculated.
They are based on number of matches won and therefore reward players who have been successful throughout the year rather than just those who have won the big tournaments like grand slams.
When US Open and Australian Open champion Serena Williams was usurped by Safina this year, the American claimed she was still the "real number one" no matter what the rankings said.
Although Williams has since backtracked somewhat, Safina has often had to defend her status as world number one.
"There have been several occasions where the sport has had number ones that hadn't won a grand slam at any time," said Scott. "I know that does stir a debate amongst fans because the world's focus is greatest around the grand slams.
"But the ranking system really is designed sort of around king or queen of the hill - who is the strongest, most consistent performer over the years. There are a lot of factors that go into the ranking system.
"While I know it does stir debate, the one place it doesn't stir a debate is in the locker room. The players believe in that ranking system. They believe the ranking is right.
"I have not had one player come up to me and say 'How can Dinara Safina be number one in the world?'" They believe in it. That is the ultimate test."
Comment 9 - 28 of 28
The shrieking, especially by the irritating snob Sharapova, MUST be outlawed.
thanks for ur opinions. i appriciate.
Ronsenglish
.. I 100% agree with you .... I still think that Olga miss the points ...Well said ..
Hit the nail right on the head there Rose. Well said.
Olga, your an armchair fan and critic try being court side, it can be very of-putting and definitely over the top, Fans count as much if not more than TV money, you hear players asking the umpire to do something about the excessive grunts and they get no backing. I think it's gamesmanship, it disguise the sound of the ball coming of the racket and should have a limit on it's volume.
Tim! U are Big Kahuna now? What a surprise! Great big hello to u!! I didn't recognize u sorry ))) hope u are doing good, cheers )
maisara_edwards )) we won't discuss here male or..sms, will we )) as for the umpires - mr. Scott's quote again: "There are rules in place. There are hindrance rules. Chair umpires are empowered to issue warnings, point penalties if there is a feeling that it's gamesmanship affecting play." They know how to do their not-bad-paid job i believe, and they can scream OUT!!! very loud - i heard it many times ) As for me - i remember Gonzo arguing with linesman as he did in RG - long, loud and gesturing for few minutes, then moving the track of the ball with his a*se )))) do u think its much better behaviour on court?))
Olga, you are right . Rafa grunts nothing compare to Gustavo Kuerten ............ I'm not Maris's fan but Nadal ardent fan .... but be it Rafa , Maria or Gustavo ..... That gruntling sounds sometime can be mistook as a linesmen call OUT !!!! I dont even like to hear RAFA's grunt it sounds like ..... sorry but sound like O.R.G.A.S.M............. :)Dont you think so ???
Well, obviously Mike D has a point. However, to stop watching tennis because of noise is stupid. If Sharapova and co. can't turn the noise down, we as TVspectators can ^^
@ Olga, noone complains about Nadal because he wins his matches grunting. And probably even more important: he has several other tics (which you also named) that distract the attention, as those other habits are unique.
And indeed, if grunting is a way of focussing for players, you can't possibly forbid it. How would they? Determine a maximum sound level? 90 dB or sth?
The idea is nice, as grunting can be annoying, but it's not possible...
Olga , I agree with you that grunting with some players comes with the territory . I don't really pay attention to it unless it gets too loud . In defense of SharÁpova , she is NOT the only player who grunts loudly .There are so many other players , men and women , who do the same thing . I think she is unfairly targeted though !!
Guys, what i think, is that we can find smth we dislike in almost every pro tennis player - somebody is grunting, somebody is preparing to serve for a long, somebody is checking smth in the a*se, somebody is pumping fist, somebody is crying...should i go on?? They are just humans - this is my point. They all have their own lack of something. They all are not perfect - visibly, hearebly or sensibly. Thats what matters. Lets accept them the way they are as soon as they try to do their best on court. Don't u agree? (english is bad again)
PS hello to all )
ok, maisara_edwards, please tell me why. May be cuz he can minimize it? And girls can not?
Olga, I disagree with you ......................... Maria grunts is like a siren . Annoying & irritating .She can grunt or shriek but I still beleive that she can minimize it ( bring down the volume ) ............................ Actually its not only women Tennis ..... If you are a real tennis fan Nadal grunts too ............... But no one complaints !!!!! Ask yourself why ??
How can Dinara Safina be number one in the world without ever winning a Grand Slam?
This ranking system is definitely wrong.
How can Dinara Safina be number one in the world without ever winning a Grand Slam?
This ranking system is definitely wrong.
How can Dinara Safina be number one in the world without ever winning a Grand Slam?
This ranking system is definitely wrong.
How can Dinara Safina be number one in the world without ever winning a Grand Slam?
This ranking system is definitely wrong.
How can Dinara Safina be number one in the world without ever winning a Grand Slam?
This ranking system is definitely wrong.
Hi Olga ! Long time no see . How are you ?
Mike D, let me disagree. If u don't like to watch them - don't watch; u don't like to hear them - don't watch either ) It's that simple. As for fans - if they are real fans - they will come and watch and hear. I am sure those three girls whos all noise is here about are not doing it on purpose - "I haven't had players come to me in my six years as head of the WTA to say this is a competition issue...", mr. Scott said. This is just the way they try to put all their power in the shot. This is not an issue to change the rules for. Reducing revenues - .... not for fans to decide i guess... Just my opinion and sorry for bad english. Enjoy Wimbledon)
Please login to post a comment
Not already a Yahoo! user ? Sign up to get a free Yahoo! Account