Premier League - We rate the owners

Eurosport - Thu, 25 Sep 11:53:00 2008

Mike Ashley is vilified by Newcastle fans but is he the worst in the Premier League? And who is the best? We rate the owners.

FOOTBALL 2008 Premier League Newcastle United fans protest against owner Mike Ashley - 0

1. Roman Abramovich (Chelsea)

Source of wealth: Oil and industry

Estimated worth: £11.7 billion

The original foreign super-owner, Abramovich's cash is what made Chelsea such a force. He seems in it for the long haul and his only slip-up so far in the eyes of the fans was Jose Mourinho's departure and the purchase of Andriy Shevchenko

Wealth: 10/10

Cash splashabilty: 10/10

Fan support: 9/10

Sticking power: 8/10

Letting the manager do his thing: 6/10

Total Mark: 43/50

+++

2. Abu Dhabi United Group (Manchester City)

Source of wealth: Oil and finance

Estimated worth: £444 billion

Much like Nigel Tufnel's amp in Spinal Tap, City's wealth goes up to 11. Expect lots of ridiculous moves in the transfer market, but how much Mark Hughes will have to say about things though remains to be seen.

Wealth: 11/10

Cash splashabilty: 10/10

Fan support: 9/10

Sticking power: 6/10

Letting the manager do his thing: 6.5/10

Total Mark: 42.5/50

+++

3. Randy Lerner (Aston Villa)

Source of wealth: Banking

Estimated worth: £894 million

Lerner has spent astutely rather than with gay abandon and is seen as a positive forward thinker by Villa fans after the draconian Doug Ellis. A liked American owner? Say it isn't so!

Wealth: 8/10

Cash splashabilty: 8/10

Fan support: 9/10

Sticking power: 8/10

Letting the manager do his thing: 9/10

Total Mark: 42/50

+++

J4. Mohamed al-Fayed (Fulham)

Source of wealth: Retailing

Estimated worth: £555m

The Harrods owner has turned Fulham from a League One club to an established Premier League outfit. He celebrated his 10-year anniversary at the club last year underlining his commitment.

Wealth: 8/10

Cash splashabilty: 8/10

Fan support: 9/10

Sticking power: 8/10

Letting the manager do his thing: 8/10

Total Mark: 41/50

+++

J4: Steve Gibson (Middlesbrough)

Source of wealth: Global transportation

Estimated worth: £112 million

Loved by his fans and a manager's dream (who else would have kept Bryan Robson so long?), Gibson's fortune seems small change in modern times. But fans can also be sure that if he ever sells up it will be in the best interests of the club he loves.

Wealth: 4/10

Cash splashabilty: 8/10

Fan support: 10/10

Sticking power: 9/10

Letting the manager do his thing: 10/10

Total 41/50

+++

J4: Dave Whelan (Wigan Athletic)

Source of wealth: Sporting goods

Estimated worth: £200m

Much like Steve Gibson, Dave Whelan isn't the richest owner in the Premier League, but when Wigan fans compare the post-Whelan era to the pre-Whelan era, they can do nothing but love the man.

Wealth: 6/10

Cash splashabilty: 8/10

Fan support: 10/10

Sticking power: 9/10

Letting the manager do his thing: 8/10

Total Mark: 41/50

+++

7: Arsenal's non-quoted plc (Arsenal)

Source of wealth: Private shareholders

Estimated worth: Unknown

Neither owned by a sugar-daddy nor floated on the stock market, the Gunners are something of a unique case in the Premier League. A fantastic stadium has been built and Arsene Wenger has complete control, but it could get harder to compete.

Wealth: 7/10

Cash splashabilty: 7/10

Fan support: 8/10

Sticking power: 8/10

Letting the manager do his thing: 10/10

Total Mark: 40/50

+++

8: Malcolm Glazer (Manchester United)

Source of wealth: Various, most noticeably food processing

Estimated worth: £1.2 billion

The doom merchants were out in force when the Glazer family took over Manchester United in 2005, but the fears of many fans proved to be unfounded. Glazer has consistently given Alex Ferguson big bucks and has also seen his own wealth double in recent years.

Wealth: 9/10

Cash splashabilty: 8/10

Fan support: 6/10

Sticking power: 7/10

Letting the manager do his thing: 9/10

Total Mark: 39/50

+++

9: Drumaville Consortium (Sunderland)

Source of wealth: Various, mainly property.

Estimated worth: Unknown

A collection of Irish businessmen fronted by Niall Quinn, the Drumaville Consortium have ploughed millions of pounds into Sunderland. A new share issue is trying to raise £50 million as the club looks for new investors.

Wealth: 7/10

Cash splashabilty: 8/10

Fan support: 8/10

Sticking power: 6/10

Letting the manager do his thing: 9/10

Total Mark: 38/50

+++

10: Alexandre Gaydamak (Portsmouth)

Source of wealth: Family business

Estimated worth: Unknown

Gaydamak doesn't have the wealth of a certain other Russian owner down at Stamford Bridge, but as long as players like Jermain Defoe and Peter Crouch keep coming into the club the fans will be happy.

Wealth: 7/10

Cash splashabilty: 8/10

Fan support: 7/10

Sticking power: 7/10

Letting the manager do his thing: 7/10

Total Mark: 36/50

+++

J11: The Walker Trust (Blackburn)

Source of wealth: Steel

Estimated worth: £300 million

The Walker Trust has bankrolled the club with around £100 million since Jack died in 2000. But it announced earlier this year that it would not be funding the club anymore and was looking to sell.

Wealth: 6/10

Cash splashabilty: 5/10

Fan support: 8/10

Sticking power: 5/10

Letting the manager do his thing: 8/10

Total Mark: 32/50

+++

J11: Paul Duffen (Hull City)

Source of wealth: Media and sales

Estimated worth: Unknown

Took over the club with a couple of property developers in 2007 and turned them into a Premier League side within a year. All nice and rosy so far but still very much in the honeymoon period.

Wealth: 6/10

Cash splashabilty: 6/10

Fan support: 7/10

Sticking power: 6/10

Letting the manager do his thing: 7/10

Total Mark: 32/50

+++

J11: Peter Coates (Stoke City)

Source of wealth: Catering and gambling.

Estimated worth: £200m

Coates is currently in his second spell at Stoke City and got to the Premier League due to sensible purchases rather than big spending. The fact that he is a local boy helps him earn fan trust. He is also close friends with manager Tony Pulis so don't expect a rash sacking.

Wealth: 5/10

Cash splashabilty: 5/10

Fan support: 7/10

Sticking power: 6/10

Letting the manager do his thing: 9/10

Total Mark: 32/50

+++

J11: Joe Lewis (Tottenham Hotspur)

Source of wealth: Currency markets

Estimated worth: £2.8 billion

One of the richest owners in football, most Tottenham fans couldn't pick Joe Lewis out of a line-up, with chairman Daniel Levy being the "face" of the club. Lewis is first and foremost a businessman, with Spurs being just one of over a 100 companies that he owns.

Wealth: 9/10

Cash splashabilty: 7/10

Fan support: 5/10

Sticking power: 6/10

Letting the manager do his thing: 5/10

Total Mark: 32/50

+++

15: Bjorgolfur Gudmundsson (West Ham)

Source of wealth: Various, but mainly banking.

Estimated worth: £500m

Gudmundsson was sentenced to 12 months in prison, suspended for 2 years, for book-keeping offences in the 90s. However, he re-made his fortune in Russia and what is most encouraging for Hammers fans is that he is a football man, and a former footballer himself.

Wealth: 7/10

Cash splashabilty: 7/10

Fan support: 6/10

Sticking power: 6/10

Letting the manager do his thing: 5/10

Total Mark: 31/50

+++

J16: Eddie Davies (Bolton)

Source of wealth: Kettle parts

Estimated worth: £60 million

There was some outcry when local kettle king Davies made the stake in the club he had held for five years a controlling one in 2003. However, since then the Trotters have become an established side who play the transfer market briskly.

Wealth: 3/10

Cash splashabilty: 5/10

Fan support: 6/10

Sticking power: 7/10

Letting the manager do his thing: 8/10

Total Mark: 29/50

+++

J16: Bill Kenwright (Everton)

Source of wealth: Theatre

Estimated worth: £30m

A boyhood Everton fan, Kenwright bought into the club at the turn of the century but has seen most of their Premier League rivals shoot past in the money stakes in recent seasons. Backed by his richer friend Robert Earl, worth more than £200m, Kenwright has always said he would love to sell to a sugar daddy.

Wealth: 2/10

Cash splashabilty: 6/10

Fan support: 6/10

Sticking power: 5/10

Letting the manager do his thing: 10/10

Total Mark: 29/50

+++

18: Tom Hicks and George Gillett (Liverpool)

Source of Income: Various

Estimated: worth £1.4 billion

Loathed by Liverpool fans, the American duo are extremely wealthy but have much of their money tied up in other ventures. This means that the club are struggling to build a new stadium and not spending like the Kop think they should be.

Wealth: 8/10

Cash splashabilty: 5/10

Fan support: 2/10

Sticking power: 4/10

Letting the manager do his thing: 4/10

Total Mark: 23/50

+++

19: Mike Ashley (Newcastle United)

Source of wealth: Sporting goods

Estimated worth: £1.4 billion

Ashley has reportedly invested over £250m in Newcastle United and all he has got for his troubles is hate mail and death threats. He won't be around for much longer and can anyone blame him?

Wealth: 8/10

Cash splashabilty: 6/10

Fan support: 1/10

Sticking power: 2/10

Letting the manager do his thing: 3/10

Total Mark: 20/50

+++

20: Jeremy Peace (West Brom)

Source of wealth: Stock trading

Estimated worth: £35m

Not the most popular chairman with everybody, Peace, who trained as an accountant, has always preached sensible financial practices, which of course, very rarely goes down well with fans. Peace would likely sell the club if he got a decent price for his shares.

Wealth: 2/10

Cash splashabilty: 4/10

Fan support: 4/10

Sticking power: 3/10

Letting the manager do his thing: 5/10

Total Mark: 18/50

Eurosport

Comment 10 - 29 of 29

Sort comments by: Most recent
  1. Kevin Keegan. Only a Newcastle United supporter could­ believe that he wasn't going to do the club any­ harm. I feel really sorry for Newcastle but you have­ got what you deserve for poaching and then sacking Big­ Sam.

    If Big Sam was still at the helm then you would­ have been guaranteed premiership football for years to­ come. As it is thanks to King Kevin, it's good luck­ in the championship. And then the Johnson's Paint­ Trophy when you will finally be able to re-live those­ glory days when you are reunited with Leeds.

    As for­ blaming Dennis Wise. sure he's useless but he is­ not the one that walked out is he. If King Kevin truly­ loved the club then he would have acted like a man and­ stuck around and done the job he was paid to do. Yes,­ even if he didn't get all the players he wanted...­ And even if he did have to work with Dennis Chopper­ Wise.

    From tri_mur, on Fri 26 Sep 6:33AM
  2. An excellent article! MSN eat your heart out. Think i­ will be lifting some of this when i preach my weekly­ drivel to my numbers on my own radio show this weeeek­ (thats Stoke-on-Trent Polytechnic Radio by the way -­ thanks for your support, mum, dad, aunty and unkle).­

    But you gotta laugh aintcha? A Nigerian consortium­ looking to buy Newcastle? Don't we all get them­ emails at least twice a month? No dout they want Mike­ Ashley to invest in some stocks and shares, left by­ some executed dictator to his mistress, via his second­ cousin twice removed. I suppose they want Dennis the­ Menace to get a taxi to Nairobi and then jump bail with­ a suitcase after having kicked the taxi & driver to­ death?

    and Joe Lewis at Spurs? 100 Companies?­ Jesus.

    As For Man City, well anyone who has 444­ billion in the bank and invests in a club like that is­ obviously two supporters short of a Kippax. 444­ Billion? What is the point? With that amount of dosh,­ the Arabs can play a real life ver$ion of Championship­ Manager and drive their 8 or so wives each positively­ bezerk. Bet Man City don't win fuckall this season­ anyway. Allah be praised.

    Final word on me own club­ the beloved, (and since 1990) deluded LFC. Our owners­ have got it sussed, football these days, especially in­ the Carling Cup is often a close shave. When i heard­ Gillette had bought the Kop I rang me mate who runs a­ burger stall, went out and invested in one thousand­ pounds worth of shares in MACH 3 razors. I am still car­ booting 'em but i hope to become a millionaire­ myself one day. As the saying goes - you gotta spend­ money to make money...

    @#$% is that the time? gotta go­ and prepare my insignificant internet podcast. Bye.

    From evanskopite, on Fri 26 Sep 1:01AM
  3. The owners are all t0ssers

    From Harry, on Thu 25 Sep 11:40PM
  4. Surely the question should be "Are Newcastle fans­ the Leagues worst supporters?"

    From DDD, on Thu 25 Sep 11:18PM
  5. mike ashleys big mistake was dennis the dwaf wise what­ does he know about newcastle u could write on the back­ of a stamp get shot of him and beg king kev to come­ back

    From stephen, on Thu 25 Sep 11:11PM
  6. mike ashley is said to be doing what is best for­ newcastle united.if he is selling the club then he wll­ have no need for wise and company.so let them go get­ kegen back in place and lets all move on.im sure this­ will settle it all down,and get the players playing­ again

    From james.brown1820, on Thu 25 Sep 10:37PM
  7. "Abramovich is really the best owner a club could­ have". thats funny.

    From shoo, on Thu 25 Sep 10:25PM
  8. before anything else,its football,it is a buisness.only­ in the respect that its a franchise,that aside,its­ something that cnt be fu*ked around with,if you dont­ know football you have no buisness getting involved­ ,fans are loyal when they have something to­ support,when you rip the soul from a club,and bring in­ people who have no buisness being there your gonna have­ probles,denis wise played for chelsea,that aside,what­ credentials gives him the right to be director of­ football at one of the best supported clubs in­ england?some rich @#$% with ideas above his station­ thats what.for all the mucking about that the liverpool­ owners do,they let benitez pick his own team and buy­ his own players,thats a start,newcastle is a ship with­ now no captian.and no real direction ,there taking on­ water,and theres no one to bail them out it seems,but a­ group of nigerians who maybe are looking for an­ aquisition to add to there financial portfolio.god help­ us all

    From !, on Thu 25 Sep 9:43PM
  9. Personally I thought there was too many foreign players­ in our football league ruining everything. This article­ goes to show how many foreign investors are ruining our­ once beautiful game. My opinion is kick them all out­ and lets see some home grown talent and keep the­ british paying footballing publics money in this­ country for a change. Why is our national team so poor­ because our own boys have no opportunities and we seem­ to think foreign is best. Total rubbish.

    From prk886, on Thu 25 Sep 9:43PM
  10. who in there right mind besides a group of nigerians­ who possibly dont realise that newcatle are in the­ shizz,are going to want to throw money at a blackhole­ that is newcastle.no matter how much money you have the­ club swallows it up and still under achieves,long since­ are the times of lol,tino asprilla,the rubber legged­ oddity who graced your team in the champions league win­ over Juventus,now your struggling for your very­ identity,if i were a billionaire,id look to buy a club­ lower down in the championship,and bring it up then­ compete.newcastle is a thirsty horse that keeps on­ drinking,i really feel for the fans,they support­ through thick n thin,not like united.who dissapeard to­ set up a new club cos someone came in to buy­ there's,The prawn sandwich munching fans bemoan­ everyone else,count your blessings you have­ stability,for now!!!!

    From !, on Thu 25 Sep 9:38PM
  11. fkj
    calm down, its just an article, dont take it to­ heart! I found it funny when man city wealth was 11/10!­ brilliant! keep it up boys!

    From Kenny L, on Thu 25 Sep 9:06PM
  12. Interesting artical....
    man,man city are loaded....!
    it­ should be fun to see what they do with it.
    only a­ possitive for the EPL as it makes it even more­ competitive.
    theres always a feeling that some clubs­ will never win anything,
    no matter how much they­ spend,i.e. NUFC.
    but saying that, I don't think­ NUFC has ever been the biggest spenders in a single­ season ?

    From Adam B, on Thu 25 Sep 8:46PM
  13. I'm a Newcastle fan. I think Mike Ashley has bailed­ the club out a hell of a lot. his mistake was perhaps­ to bring in Dennis 'un' Wise, and then Keegan­ in a knee jerk. Let's be honest Keegan left­ Newcastle in a bit of a storm originally - there was no­ reserve team then - he had splashed the cash of Hall­ and Shepherd but to no avail. Yes we played great­ football - but Keegan, relative to the time, had as­ much as Jose at Chelsea was given - don't believe­ me? remember in 96 he bought BArton, Ginola, Shay­ Given, and Les Ferdinand in one close season alone - a­ year later he got Shearer for 15 million. He won­ nothing. The reason that the likes of Wenger, Fergie,­ Scolari get the last word on players is that they­ deliver. Wenger in particular buys cheap and sells for­ more - he's never had a Newcastle United­ budget.
    Newcastle fans are very ungrateful for an owner­ that did try and balance the books - maybe he made two­ mistakes - Wise and Keegan. The fans - if that's­ what they are should turn up and support their club -­ especially if they want a proper investor - who's­ gonna invest without fans?

    From LoheswaranA, on Thu 25 Sep 4:18PM
  14. Football is turning into Cancer and spreading fast

    From LEE C, on Thu 25 Sep 2:36PM
  15. Best Chairman is Butcher of Kirton United, he's­ invested more than £50 over the 200 years he has­ managed and ran the club. (He's still running it­ today).

    From Views from Suffolk, on Thu 25 Sep 2:18PM
  16. Hmmmm. Very surprised. That many points for WBA? Absurd­ - Far, far too many. Masquerading as Premier League­ outfit/football club. Mike Norgrove , Exmouth -­ life-long Wolves fan.

    From Michael, on Thu 25 Sep 12:49PM
  17. Oh well said Mr Hawkins! Fjk seems to have forgotten­ all the abuse the Glazer family suffered when they­ first assumed control. 76000 glory hunters may inhabit­ Old Trafford but that surely pales into insignificance­ compared to the 50000 idiots who go to St James Park to­ see a team which hasnt won a major trophy since the­ late 1960's. Steve Gibson is the head kiddy amongst­ all this for me. Quietly going about his business and­ providing a small club in Yorkshire with dreams beyond­ all those imagined when Ayresome Park was closed down

    From The Trout, on Thu 25 Sep 12:12PM
  18. Manure,(sorry,man utd),fans were so besotted with the­ Yank trailer-park owners that they promptly­ upped-sticks and formed their own club.
    The Glazers­ have faced constant abuse,death-threats and a concerted­ "love united,hate glazer" campaign.
    The 6 out­ of ten mark reflects the popularity of the owners,not­ the 70 odd thousand southern sheep who would travel up­ to watch the shirts being washed and who get off the­ Euston train at Piccadilly asking for directions to Old­ Trafford.
    I would say that the assessment was more than­ generous.
    Nice set of "fans" who print­ stickers bearing the message "three strokes and­ you're out" when Malcolm Glazer suffered a­ heart attack.
    And people wonder why they are­ universally disliked?

    From steve, on Thu 25 Sep 11:56AM
  19. Not sure how Eursport arrived at their marks out of­ ten; i can't comment for other clubs but the­ results for The Glazer family and Man Utd are way off­ the mark! I'm referring to the following...
    1) Fan­ support: 6/10 - 76,000 full house every game at Old­ Trafford equates to 100%
    2) Sticking power: 7/10 - Took­ over in 2005 and are still there in the background and­ going no where equates to another 100%
    3) Letting the­ manager do his thing: 9/10 - I have not heard of one­ single incident where they have undermined any decision­ made by Sir Alex equates to another 100%
    The fact that­ they have doubled their wealth is a clear indication of­ the ship under good control and heading in the right­ direction. I think the guys at Eurosport need to go­ back to the drawing board and re-evaluate their­ findings

    From Fjk, on Thu 25 Sep 9:40AM
  20. Not that much wrong with Ashley. He bailed them out­ financially, sacked Big Sam when they wanted, brought­ back Keegan. The flaw in his plan was that he listened­ to the thick jocks that inhabit Newcastle. He should­ never have brought Keegan back, it was always going to­ end in tears. Now he is being hounded out of the club­ and it will be sold to Nigeria. Fortunately they have­ loads of money because I keep getting e-mails from­ there offering me £1 million. Be careful what you wish­ for!

    From jonandjuliearden, on Thu 25 Sep 9:39AM
Sort comments by: Most recent

Not already a Yahoo! user ? to get a free Yahoo! Account