Eurosport - Sun, 25 Jul 18:03:00 2010
Fernando Alonso led a controversial one-two for Ferrari in the German Grand Prix at Hockenheim with the Scuderia fined for seeming to instruct Felipe Massa to let him past.
Massa leapt from third to first at the start of the race, with Alonso slotting in behind him as poleman Sebastian Vettel - who finished on the podium - fell back to third.
The Brazilian was de facto leader until Alonso moved past on lap 49 of 67, soon after Ferrari had asked engineer Rob Smedley to tell him: "Fernando is faster than you. Can you confirm you understood that message?"
The next message from Smedley was: "Well done. Good lad. Now try and keep with him. I'm sorry."
Ferrari were fined $100,000 over the incident and could face further FIA sanctions having been referred to that body's world motorsport council, which can impose unlimited penalties.
It is Ferrari's first one-two since the opening race of the season in Bahrain and they showed the greater pace throughout.
Vettel was also quick and closed the gap on Massa in the final laps, but did not get close enough to launch an attack.
The German's Red Bull team-mate Webber struggled to match him and was passed by Lewis Hamilton early on to drop to fifth ahead of Jenson Button in the other McLaren.
The opening pitstops saw Button lead briefly, and the reigning champion exhibited strong pace on the wearing super-soft tyres to oust Webber from fifth after he had eventually come in.
That was the finishing order behind the front three, Hamilton all alone by the end to claim a comfortable 12 points with Button picking up 10 and Webber eight in the fight for the title.
It keeps the 2008 champion top with 157 points from Button (143), Vettel and Webber (both 136). Alonso's victory moves him on to 123.
Ferrari were convinced that Alonso had the greater pace despite both their drivers setting fastest laps throughout the race, as did Vettel. Before Alonso took the lead, he had uttered "this is ridiculous" over the radio in response to Massa shutting the door on an overtaking move.
Until Massa dropped off him following the changeover, they had been within three seconds of one another throughout - and this while passing a multitude of backmarkers.
Robert Kubica of Renault was seventh ahead of Mercedes duo Nico Rosberg and Michael Schumacher, who enjoyed a late battle for position. Amazingly all were lapped by the front three drivers.
Vitaly Petrov, also of Renault, completed the points positions.
Things did not go so well for Toro Rosso and Force India.
The former's drivers made contact with one another on the opening lap, smashing off Sebastien Buemi's rear wing and forcing him to retire while Jaime Alguersuari had to slice through the backmarkers for a 15th-place finish having damaged the front of his car.
Force India inexplicably put the wrong tyres on each car and they had to be swapped over in the early laps. Tonio Liuzzi came in twice in that period and finished 16th ahead of team-mate Adrian Sutil.
The Saubers and both Williams filled places 11 to 14 while Timo Glock won the 'new teams' race for Virgin, taking 18th after Jarno Trulli was forced out of the race.
Bruno Senna was the only other finisher as his temporary Hispania colleague Sakon Yamamoto, Trulli's Lotus team-mate Heikki Kovalainen and Virgin's Lucas di Grassi all retired at various stages of the race.
Comment 949 - 968 of 968
'I would ask Martin Whitmarsh about the ballant team orders in Hockenheim 2008, when Heikki Kovalainen let Lewis Hamilton pass in the hairpin.
That is the youtube video code, enjoy.'
but at least they tried to make it look convincing, this time Ferrari were taking the p1ss
Well Well Bernie Ecclestone, your F1 roadshow spirals into chaos and farce yet again, and the people hurt are the true fans, not the corporate fat cats you court with your publicity machine, its good if the true fans go isn't it Bernie ....more space for the fatties.....turn this rubbish into a sport again please. the days of proper racing F1 cars with the likes of mansell and senna are gone forever, health and safety, cheating and manipulation. races are won in the board room, I for one will turn over to motoGP now and quit F1 forever. shambles and a crime. @#$% Turpin still is among us and he is short and merciless indeed, the FIA are still Bernies Puppetts. and the Puppet Master still orchistrates the asylum ....
I'm an American and I've loved F1 since the 1970's so don't say that we have no interest in F1; a lot of us do. As for this idea of team orders, it sucks, no matter who does it. I liked the fact that Massa was diplomatic in the post-race interview, but we all know what he really felt: sick over having to give a win to his teammate. When Massa joined the team, he wanted to be to Ferrari the kind of driver/winner Schuey was, but that hasn't panned out. If anything, I hope he learned something for the next race: stay focused, maintain a fast pace and keep Alonso from catching up.
I would ask Martin Whitmarsh about the ballant team orders in Hockenheim 2008, when Heikki Kovalainen let Lewis Hamilton pass in the hairpin.
That is the youtube video code, enjoy.
Ferrari should have their Manufacturers points deducted, Alonso and Massa reversed.
But more to the point we want to see RACING! not cars just going fast, drag racing has that, not tactics, not cutting corners, RACING. We want drivers pitting their skills and courage on the track, they should be punished for going off the Black bit either by damaging their car or tyres or making them turn back to return to the track! and change tracks to provide overtaking opportunities.
Alonso has always been a cheat just look at his past record to see that, deduct the points from him and give the race to Massa..
This is precisely why Americans have no interest in Formula 1. They don't care if the technology is Stone Age, but whatever the boys are racing, they expect them to be RACING.
THEY NEVER STOP DOING THIS THEY DONE IT 7 YEARS GO AGIAN AND AGIAN THEY JUST WANT WIN ANYHOW LIKE THEY FINE NOT ONLY F1 ALSO IN FOOTBALL SAME THING KEEP DOING ............I WAS THERE FAN AND 7 YEARS GO s.m and R.B INCIDENT I LOST FAITH ON THEM..................PLEASE DONT LET DO THIS AGIAN SPORT HAS TO CLEAN AND PURE....................
numeru no soy italiano o ingles the problem with fi1 is the manipulative side of it an unfortunately alonso is at his worst here, about singapore im sotrry but nobody sells me that dud.
I hate the cheat Hamilton.
Nuberu Alonso is not an egoist as translated from spanish, alonso is the embodiment of all that is wrong with a sport in dire need of reform, he has been embroiled in every event that has tarnished formula one over the past couple of years, including singapore, problems with his co-drivers, and now this. Rather describe him for what he is, a cynical individual who grew up in protected environments where the value of the sponsorship is deemed to be more important than the sport itself.
i hate the cheat alonso
As the rules currently stand, the issuing of 'team orders' to manipulate a race result is illegal. What really galls me is that the Team Principal - Stefano Domenicali, passed the buck by instructing Rob Smedley - Massa's race engineer, to inform Massa to allow Fernando Alonso to overtake him, and thereby trying to distance himself from it. This kind of instruction should only be communicated by the Team Principal.
The drivers build a close working relationship with their race engineer and put complete faith in that person to fight their corner. Is it any wonder that Felipe Massa and Rob Smedley were fed up.
Well said Thomas in below comment.And as Coultard mentioned yesterday this stupid rule that was brought in years ago is unworkable.Also all the teams will have codes for getting their no. 1 driver to the front over their 2nd driver.Anyone who thinks different is extremely naive.
It seems emotions are still running high. The solution to team orders is simple. It should only be allowed in exceptional circumstances when for instance it is mathematically impossible for the front running driver to win the championship. He can then choose (voluntarily) to give way to the driver behind only if the rear driver is still in the championship race (mathematically that is). What happened yesterday was unacceptable, lets not kid ourselves, but we have to remember that this is a team sport.
Article 39.1 of the sporting regulations, which states that "team orders which interfere with a race result are prohibited", and Article 151 (c) of the International Sporting Code, which outlaws "any fraudulent conduct or any act prejudicial to the interests of any competition or to the interests of motor sport generally".
Surely anyone who watched the race and listened to the radio transmissions between Smedly and Massa can be under no illusion that what went on was in breach of both these rules...On the day the words said and actions done were blatantly clear what had happened....TEAM ORDERS but by the time this shameful event gets to the Sport councl meeting in september the massive properganda machine of Ferrari will have walked all over Massa and Smedly putting so much pressure on them that the true events and meanings of what happened will be lost
Article 39.1 of the sporting regulations, which states that "team orders which interfere with a race result are prohibited", and Article 151 (c) of the International Sporting Code, which outlaws "any fraudulent conduct or any act prejudicial to the interests of any competition or to the interests of motor sport generally".
Surely anyone who watched the race and listened to the radio transmissions between Smedly and Massa can be under no illusion that what went on was in breach of both these rules...On the day the words said and actions done were blatantly clear what had happened....TEAM ORDERS but by the time this shameful event gets to the Sport councl meeting in september the massive properganda machine of Ferrari will have walked all over Massa and Smedly putting so much pressure on them that the true events and meanings of what happened will be lost
A proposal: we kidnap Alonso, bring him to London and hang him with we all wearing medieval customs (maybe after three days in London bridge drinking only tea, eating porridge and listenning to an endless dvd of Lady Di's wedding). We feel very good because he is very bad and he's from Spain, we invite the royalty, of course british, and at the end we pass around a hat to collect some alms for Button, just in case he's short of gas next races. Monty Pyton could organize the whole thing.
Wherever there is controversy in F1, the Unscrupulous Senor Alonso is sure to be found lurking in the centre. He is a Desparado Swindler, who creates Acrimony and Disharmony where-ever he goes. He is destructive, disingenuous, as well has dishonourable – all the characteristics required to be a Ferrari No.1 Driver.
.
PAST EVIDENCE – the record speaks for itself:
.
(1) McLaren = “Spygate” : he tried to Blackmail his own team
.
(2) Renault = “Crashgate”: He Gained his ONLY win last year, through his Team Mate Crashing in Singapore
.
(3) Ferrari = “Cheatgate”: Robbing his team mate of his win, through Team Orders when he DEMANDED that the Team do something regarding Massa
.
ALL the above were MAJOR & EXTREME attempts of MASS MANIPULATION!
He had the audacity to claim that Hamilton’s Drive-Through was a race manipulation, when he paid the price. When Webber did the same thing earlier in the season, going on to win his race, nothing was said!
ellie - it's nice to see someone commenting without taking it all too seriously - love what you wrote about Benidorm/Benalmádena...... ;)
Please login to post a comment
Not already a Yahoo! user ? Sign up to get a free Yahoo! Account