Is time up for Tendulkar?

Sun, 29 Jan 10:39:00 2012

The very thought of Sachin Tendulkar and his contemporaries being shown the exit door would have been dismissed a year ago, but the majority of the Indian cricket fans are now convinced that the 'golden generation' should make way for new blood.

Sachin Tendulkar - 0

After a decade-and-a-half of blind worship, fans believe their demigods have been rendered immobile by feet of clay and are ready to thank them for the memories and move on.

The last time Tendulkar featured in a newspaper poll was when readers were asked who should be the first sportsperson to receive India's highest civilian award, a Bharat Ratna.

As India succumbed to their second straight overseas whitewash in Australia, the Hindustan Times newspaper carried a poll this weekend in which more than 36 percent opined the 38-year-old 'Little Master' should hang up his bat.

Quite a significant percentage, considering the man in question has virtually been the sacred cow of Indian cricket since his first Test century in 1990.

The results were even worse for the two stalwarts Tendulkar sits sandwiched between in the batting order.

More than 58 per cent favoured 39-year-old Rahul Dravid's immediate departure while 82.6 per cent would prefer not to see VVS Laxman (38) in India colours again.

"Age is conspiring against them," former Test player Ravi Shastri wrote in a column that appeared in Sunday's Times of India newspaper.

"A bad series or two at the start of your career is almost a given. A series or two at the end is a catastrophe. Everyone is in an unforgiving mood."

From India's perspective, the Australia tour was a disaster, where anything that could go possibly wrong invariably did.

The biggest letdown was the vaunted batting order where Tendulkar, Dravid and Laxman - who have more than 37,500 Test runs between them - made a collective contribution of 636 runs in the four-Test series.

Dravid, who alone had scored 619 in the drawn 2003-04 series, managed just 194 runs at an average of fewer than 25 per innings.

His legendary defence, that earned him the moniker of "The Wall", was breached seven times in eight innings, including by a Peter Siddle no-ball in Melbourne.

Some other hard-earned reputations were also sullied.

Laxman was a pale imitation of the batsman who has been Australia's nemesis for so long and scratched around for his 155 runs from eight innings to finish with an embarrassing sub-20 average.

Only Tendulkar averaged 35-plus in the series and regularly middled the ball, but his desperate bid for a 100th international century seems to have become a millstone around the neck of cricket's most prolific batsman.

Almost inevitably, India hurtled from one defeat to another and many believe the humiliation could have been easily averted had the selectors shrugged off their timidity and took a long-term view of things.

"I can understand the fans being in awe of big names. But sometimes the selectors and officials are also too much in awe of the big names and that's why not able to take tough decisions," former Test player Sanjay Manjrekar told CNN-IBN channel.

His views were echoed by former Australia captain Ian Chappell, who recommended a thorough review of Indian cricket.

"The star system is well and truly ingrained in the Indian team and things won't improve, certainly not on the overseas Test match front, until this is changed," Chappell wrote in a column that appeared in Sunday's Hindustan Times.

"India is currently a side full of individually bright stars and it needs to become a group of cricketers who perform as a team. It doesn't help when a number of those individually bright stars are playing for their own survival.

"... the star players have held sway for too long and surely eight successive losses, some of them total capitulation, is confirmation that the system is not working," Chappell added.

To make it work again, the Indian cricket board has no other choice but to confront the transitional crisis they have been avoiding for too long and their task has been made easier by the fact they finally have the country's fans on the same page.

Reuters

Comment 1 - 10 of 10

Sort comments by: Most recent | Most rated
  1. I fail to see why India should drop Tendulkar now. He­ has a better average in this shambolic 4-0 defeat in­ Auss that the other top 4 batters in this series. ­ Its not all about keeping the most favourite son of­ India, its about keeping the best players who can still­ make a valuable contribution to their country. I say­ , let Tendulkar play at least till end of 2012. I am­ sure the man himself will ultimately decide what is­ best for him!

    From P, on Tue 31 Jan 0:03
  2. The only solution the Indian Board has to everything is­ arrogantly refuse to have UDRS. And use their money to­ dominate other boards!

    From pradeep, on Mon 30 Jan 12:34
  3. well said harris lol

    From Ali A, on Mon 30 Jan 12:11
  4. KAREN

    Would it even better against England? ;-)

    No­ man is bigger than the team unless you're Sachin­ Tendulkar and India is your team.

    The man should go -­ let the team rebuild without him.

    From BEN, on Mon 30 Jan 8:01
  5. India is not scheduled to play overseas for next two­ years, I'm sure they'll get a tour here and­ there but atleast next two series will be in­ India.

    Just like how they let Gavaskar make records in­ India (at the end of his career), they are gonna do the­ same for Dravid and Tendulkar!

    India is obssessed with­ personal records and not actually witht he glory of the­ team!

    From Harris, on Mon 30 Jan 7:39
  6. Just simply to say India cricket team learn from­ Pakistani team to how to play abroad try to play out­ side off India

    From Mohammad, on Mon 30 Jan 5:40
  7. As a cricket fan, I would love Sachin to get that 100th­ 100, and I would love it even more if I watched it­ happen live.

    From KAREN, on Mon 30 Jan 4:45
  8. India will play at home for the next two years, so let­ the older players make their records on dead flat­ wickets and get it out of their system. Then once­ they have scored their hundreds, let them gracefully­ say goodbye to the fans and make room for new blood.

    From Anon, on Mon 30 Jan 1:58
  9. i thing it is a big embarasment for india i myself have­ been shocked by the hammering they have received, ­ when i look at the batting line up of india you know­ you got your hands full but i think only when century­ in 4 tests is not acceptable. laxman should go­ tendulkar has been scoring but needs to get his hundred­ and hand his boots up. dravid is still going strong­ but his time is very near sewag he is a one day player.­ doni also not scoring and why on earth have they left­ out sharma he is a class batsmen. like england who­ cant play in the sub continent india cant play too­ outside of sub continent conditions.
    i think that south­ africa and australia have got better back up and all­ round players to fit in than any other team at the­ moment.
    i support pakistan and even though they won­ they still have a very weak batting line up and not­ enough quality players are coming through.

    From Nabbil, on Sun 29 Jan 20:21
  10. so will england and india make whole sale changes, did­ australia make whole sale changes after the ashes­ defeat. no they did not and neither will india and­ england. dravid in england was very good scoring 3­ centuries. tendulkar is scoring but the millstone is­ becoming heavy. recently in india laxman has batted­ well grinding out scores to win and save test matches­ one being against the aussies in india. these three­ greats will know themselves when it is time to go.­ sehwag ghambir donni have not done so good have they,­ kohli one century and looks the part, yes rohit sharma­ should be given a chance. england have looked good­ against the quicks but against top class spin they have­ faltered. pieterson has lost his spark, morgan to me is­ not a five day test cricketer. if bressnan had been fit­ they would have dropped morgan for panesar and out of­ this defeat this may be the making of an all round­ side. with prior moving to six and bressnan broad and­ swann are all very capable batters.

    From STEVEN, on Sun 29 Jan 19:50
Sort comments by: Most recent | Most rated

Not already a Yahoo! user ? to get a free Yahoo! Account