Gymnast unable to have natural birth sues coaches

Eurosport - Sat, 29 May 13:39:00 2010

Former gymnast Rebecca Owen is suing her ex-coaches for forcing her to train with an injury that has left her unable to have a baby naturally.

- 0

The 23-year-old, who won two Commonwealth Games silver medals for England in 2002, claims she was forced to train despite a back fracture, and says she has been in constant pain since quitting the sport seven years ago.

Owen picked up the injury when she was just 11 while doing a "whip salto" but returned to full training after six months rest.

Her coaches then added the whip salto back to her routine on her return despite it being related to her injury, and she was forced to carry out the move 10 to 15 times a day.

Owen's former coaches are Great Britain coach Colin Still and his wife Christine, who commentates for the BBC. 

"This has ruined my life," Owen told the Daily Mail.

"I always longed for lots of children but even if I manage to carry a baby - and doctors say it will be agonising as my back is so weak - I won't be able to give birth naturally. 

"And I don't know how I would look after a baby - bending and stretching are virtually impossible.

"Although I had been diagnosed with a fracture in my lower back my coaches insisted I trained.

"Despite the fact I was in agony and often in tears they kept pushing me to perform.

"People often comment on how Eastern European gymnasts are treated but it isn't very different here. Young children are pushed beyond their limits and are forced to perform under pressure and pain.

"Even going out with friends is miserable as I can't sit or stand in the same position for very long. I am constantly in agony and always taking strong painkillers."

Owen retired after being forced to pull out of the qualifiers for the 2004 Olympics in Athens.

The Stills have refused to comment on the story.

Eurosport

Comment 116 - 135 of 135

Sort comments by: Most recent | Most rated
  1. To follow on from my previous comment, which I have to,­ due to lack of space here, my final point is, that­ anyone who was responsible for Rebeccas injury and care­ and welfare, in any way, should definately compensate­ her for the future lifetime of care, support and­ assistance she is going to require and need.
    At 11­ years old she was a child. The responsibility for her­ safety and welfare falls squarely upon the shoulders of­ all the adults, clubs and organisations concerned.­
    Rebecca, I hope the powers that be ,find a way to help­ you have your own children and overcome the­ problems.
    However should this not be possible, then­ there are lots of children in the world who could use­ your love. See your future in a positive light and just­ another set of challenges to meet and overcome. The­ fact you have made it so far in your sport, tells me­ you have the courage and qualities required to survive­ this blow. And I thank you for speaking out and raising­ this issue, and bringing it and the dangers highlighted­ firmly into the public eye. Parents beware. Sometimes­ pursuit of excellence can ruin lives.

    From chl, on Wed 2 Jun 0:07
  2. well this just goes to show that parents should make­ themselves aware of the fact that life changing and­ sometimes life threatening injuries can and do occur in­ sport. This young lady was a child and in no way was­ she ever to blame for what has happened to her. She was­ simply following her parents , her coaches, and the­ Nations dream. As a Nation we encourage pursuit of­ sport, for fitness and general good health, not to­ mention to instill the pursuit of excellence and team­ building skills it teaches and which are useful tools­ and lessons to learn and use throughout life. however­ sport has changed of late. No longer is it the amateur­ status of its origins, but now Money and fame play the­ biggest part. Bothe parents and coaches think that this­ is the way to national glory and the major paychecks­ which ensue olympic or international success. this­ applies not only to the sportsperson but also the­ coaches and their clubs. However coaches act as­ substitue parents for these young althletes and as such­ should have their welfare as their prime concern.­ Rebeccas situation is not just one of not being able to­ give birth. this is a life long problem she has now, as­ she has a spinal injury which will never go away. You­ have to have a spinal injury to begin to know the level­ of daily pain this young lady probably endures whilst­ undertaking the simplest and most basic of activities,­ such as the bending and stretching she mentions. If you­ imagine the worst toothache you have ever had, and­ magnify it many, mnay, many, times you probably would­ not even come close to the amount of pain she feels as­ even the slightest of pressure is exerted on her spine.­ Standing and sitting can be excrutiating and then there­ is the creeping painful numbness which follows and­ which can only be likened to a really, really bad case­ of cramp. So Rebecca is going to need her strength of­ character she has developed through her dedicated­ training, just to get her through her daily life now.

    From chl, on Tue 1 Jun 23:56
  3. Jessica,how many times did you fracture your back?

    From kevin.tudor, on Mon 31 May 20:34
  4. vk, when you're 11 or 12 years old and an adult­ tells you to do something, you do it, especially when­ it's someone you've been led to trust by your­ parents. she was a child when this happened and­ didn't know any better, the adults involved should­ have been just that, adults. this sort of treatment is­ almost as bad as sexual abuse

    From James, on Mon 31 May 12:30
  5. There is nothing natural about having a natural birth!­ Nothing wrong with ceasarian section, it leaves an­ important part of your body intact and easier to sit!

    From CARLA, on Mon 31 May 11:46
  6. we have only had one side of the story, however,as an­ athletics coach i have had a few 11 and 12 year olds­ join my group only to find out from the parents that­ they want to try athletics because they have been­ injured whilst doing gymnastics. it is usually their­ knees that are damaged. when oh when will people take­ into account that growing children are still developing­ their bones and muscles. i coach hurdles, and always­ ask youngsters if it is they or their parents who want­ them to do it.....i think you would be surprised at­ some of the answers.

    From rod, on Mon 31 May 7:58
  7. Comment hidden due to its low rating. Show

    i am very sorry for her but coaches can tell you to do­ something. its your decision to actually perform it.­ She did it.

    From vk, on Mon 31 May 5:46
  8. Comment hidden due to its low rating. Show

    Of course we feel sorry for her suffering but we have­ parents with thalidomide defects and wheelchair bound­ people who have children and find ways to cope and­ unfortunately there is no natural right to bear­ children so have a little thought for those who cannot­ have children at all.

    From saffron_scotland, on Mon 31 May 3:59
  9. Comment hidden due to its low rating. Show

    Ah bless, so no thanks to the coaches for pushing her­ hard enough to win a commonwealth medal? Is that not­ worth the pain?

    From martincane2005, on Mon 31 May 3:19
  10. surely if she sues the trainers she must then sue the­ parents on being negligent and complicit in her­ training regime. it sickens me that as a nation we can­ no longer blame ourselves for anything. falling was a­ hazard of not looking where you placed your feet whilst­ walking. you have only one person to blame and that is­ yourself. the word accident means just that, if the­ council had too fill in every loose, cracked or unlevel­ paving slab. if this is too be done you would require­ several hundred staff roping off areas deemed­ "dangerous" and awaiting repair and rates 3­ or 4 times higher too cover it. the only people too­ blame are the parents who wanted the "second hand­ fame and fortune"

    From dotcom, on Mon 31 May 2:43
  11. unbelievable

    From joe.d.f.harris, on Mon 31 May 2:33
  12. I think the parents and the doctors have much more­ guilt than the coaches. At the end of the day she was­ not their daughter, but just another talented child,­ that could bring herself and them more glory. And that­ is probably why also the parents did not say­ stop....just wanted their daughter to achieve as much­ as possible, and probably not being aware of the long­ term consequences...? What about the doctors? Did not­ they knew that she should not continue with the sport­ at that level, or did they knew, did they worn the­ parents, but were not listen to? There are many, many­ questions.

    Some people here say, that she herself­ should say NO. But what an eleven-year old girl, whith­ olympic expectations knows about life? What does she­ care about at that age about being a mother? Many of us­ do not know about life even at 20 or 30....

    I believe­ she should NOT sue! Be humble, and accept your destiny.­ At the end of the day, you CAN conceive a child­ naturally, and may be there exist different ways that­ will help you even to carry it....if you do not try,­ you would not know. The C section is nothing pleasant,­ and every mother try to give birth naturally, but there­ ARE methods that can help....just do research, give it­ a try!

    There are so many people who have to undergo­ much more intrusive operations and procedures to have­ their own child....AND there are so many children­ without any parents at all.....there are possibilites­ and solutions, just some people are to self-centred and­ arrogant.....running after life.

    This case is just­ another illustration of many things that are wrong in­ this so called "civilized" society.......

    From Flauta, on Mon 31 May 2:19
  13. I'm a little baffled. Presumably both her and her­ parents had no idea at the time that these exercises­ would later have such serious repercussions, so the­ suggestion that she or her parents could have said no­ is a little harsh. Whereas I deplore the blame culture­ we see to live in these days, in this case I think she­ has a good case.

    From DAVID, on Mon 31 May 2:09
  14. i think forcing a child 2 do a 'whip salto'­ with servere back pain after it gave her that injury,­ at the age 11, is a modern form of child abuse , if the­ child at 11 couldn't say no 2 it , then the parents­ should of stepped up and then withdrawn the child­ either after back surgery or withdrawn her completely .

    From Mrs, on Mon 31 May 1:50
  15. iF she was in that much pain, why did she carry on, and­ yes were where the parants.there is such a word as NO.

    From lyn, on Mon 31 May 1:46
  16. she was 11 years old, a child, children can find it­ very hard to say no, especially in that kind of pushy­ environment.

    From Jennifer Anne, on Mon 31 May 1:27
  17. I am stunned by this story.Where were the parents­ ,Sorry I , know soaking up the glory now of course­ they want to reap the benefits of money.Its strange how­ money compensates for a child..I am unable to have­ children who can i sue..My parents ,God..I seek your­ advice.No i am not cynical but is the in England or­ America.

    From beau, on Mon 31 May 1:04
  18. Comment hidden due to its low rating. Show

    i fractured my back while at work, in an accident and i­ couldnt sue anybody. i live in constant pain too. i­ should get compensation because my employer was at­ fault. Although i feel sorry for her as i know what she­ is going through, i think she needs to take a step back­ and look at her parents, doctors and herself. I­ understand that the business is pushy but we invented a­ word 'NO' if she refused to do the routine her­ coach couldnt do anything about it.

    From Jessica, on Mon 31 May 1:00
  19. Comment hidden due to its low rating. Show

    i fractured my back while at work, in an accident and i­ couldnt sue anybody. i live in constant pain too. i­ should get compensation because my employer was at­ fault. Although i feel sorry for her as i know what she­ is going through, i think she needs to take a step back­ and look at her parents, doctors and herself. I­ understand that the business is pushy but we invented a­ word 'NO' if she refused to do the routine her­ coach couldnt do anything about it.

    From Jessica, on Mon 31 May 1:00
  20. Comment hidden due to its low rating. Show

    i fractured my back while at work, in an accident and i­ couldnt sue anybody. i live in constant pain too. i­ should get compensation because my employer was at­ fault. Although i feel sorry for her as i know what she­ is going through, i think she needs to take a step back­ and look at her parents, doctors and herself. I­ understand that the business is pushy but we invented a­ word 'NO' if she refused to do the routine her­ coach couldnt do anything about it.

    From Jessica, on Mon 31 May 1:00
Sort comments by: Most recent | Most rated

Not already a Yahoo! user ? to get a free Yahoo! Account