Armchair Pundit

QPR lucky to get Hughes

Mark Hughes at Fulham

In appointing Mark Hughes as their new manager, QPR have given themselves a major boost in their battle against relegation.

Neil Warnock may count himself unlucky to be sacked, with his club still outside the bottom three the season after a spectacular promotion campaign.

As Warnock pointed out, Tony Fernandes's takeover of the club, on August 18, did not give the manager enough time to bring in new players, while many of his preferred targets had already gone elsewhere.

Warnock said on Tuesday: "Will a new manager make a difference? Not as much as new players will.

"If you haven't got the players you can't win games, that's another fact of life in football management.

"I just wish I had the chance to bring in the ones I wanted, both in the summer, and this month."

New managers often possess a strange ability to loosen the chairman's purse strings, and reports suggest Hughes could get as much as £30 million to spend this month.

If the previous gaffer had that money to spend - who knows?

So while Warnock has the right to feel somewhat aggrieved, this is ultimately not an issue of fairness. It is a simple upgrade in the dugout.

It's not about whether Warnock 'deserved' the sack as much as whether Hughes can do better.

I think he can.

In its final weeks, the Warnock era appeared in some danger of spiralling out of control.

Not just in the miserable run of nine games without a win, but in the manager's demeanour.

Never slow to take up arms against officialdom, Warnock cut an increasingly angry figure as results went against QPR.

His rage following Joey Barton's red card was well-documented, and included a claim that referees favour bigger clubs (odd, given Barton was sent off against Norwich).

Days earlier, he ripped into referee Lee Probert after the draw against Swansea, claiming he had perpetrated "an injustice".

Now, managers criticising referees is nothing new, and even the best bosses do it. But they normally do it with a specific goal in mind - making sure the next decision goes their way.

Problem is, Warnock's rants were so splenetic, so bitter in their condemnation of referees and the FA's appeal process, that far from coaxing some more favourable treatment, they merely risked alienating the authorities.

QPR chairman Tony Fernandes may also have considered the potentially damaging effect all this rage might have on a club trying to raise its global profile.

Flavio Briatore's idea of selling Rangers as an exclusive 'boutique' club was clearly preposterous no matter how many times Naomi Campbell turned up. I mean, have you ever been to White City?

However, the Italian was right that the club needs to broaden its appeal overseas, and coming across as a gang of irate bruisers probably won't cut it.

To paraphrase the late, lamented Garry Cook, Shaun Derry doesn't roll off the tongue in Beijing.

So a change is probably for the best, though Hughes does not come without his own question marks.

He seems desperate to tell everyone just how ambitious he is. But in the summer that ambition led him to quit Fulham with no alternative lined up, and resulted in six months of unemployment before joining a lower-ranked club than the one he left.

So if Hughes does keep QPR up, there is no guarantee that his ambition will not take him elsewhere if a bigger club comes calling - or even if they don't.

One thing not in question is Hughes's ability to deliver results.

Only once in six full seasons of management has his side finished outside the top half - his first year at Blackburn.

Manchester City have progressed since Hughes was sacked in December 2009, but that may have something to do with the oodles of cash lavished on transfers as much as Roberto Mancini's managerial acumen.

In any case, it was a run of draws that did for Hughes at City; not ideal for ambitious -that word again - owners but hardly an indication of a useless manager.

Hopefully he will have learned a lesson from his ill-advised departure from Craven Cottage - that a manager looking for the next big move is more likely to get it if he already has a job.

And Hughes's appointment must come as something of a relief to his representative Kia Joorabchian, whose two highest profile clients in Britain have been at something of a loose end.

In Carlos Tevez, he has a footballer in his prime not playing football, and in Hughes a manager in his prime not managing.

By the end of the month, both men should be back doing what they do best.

Hughes is too talented a manager to spend his days pruning the roses. QPR are lucky to have him.

Twitter - @alexchick81

 
  • A Yahoo! User  •  London, England  •  4 months ago
    Luck? The man was unemployed anyway and is costing them a reputed £3 million a year in wages! How the hell is that lucky?
  • Kenneth  •  4 months ago
    It's the old story, the old manager has been asking for money, possibly for years, to improve the team, this has not been forthcoming and results have suffered. Sack the manager and suddenly the missing money is there for the taking (30 million so the rumours have it). Judicious buying by the new manager should begin to show improvements in the results, new manager now looks like he has single handedly turned the club round. Owner looks like a genious. The 30 million is conveniently taken out of the equation!

    The current exception to this rule is Martin O'Neil. However, exceptions do prove the rules.
  • john  •  Dublin, Ireland  •  4 months ago
    Great to see that World renowned football club QPR have employed a fantastic manager in Mark Hughes and he avoided ended up in the doldrums wih one of those minnows Barcelona Real Madrid Milan AC and Inter Bayern Munich Arsenal Liverpool etc who were all competing for his services in such a cut troath way. I bet they are all regreting their lack of incisive decisions (interest) now. Who the hell are you trying to fool Chick?? Hughes is just another run of the mill second rate bottom to mid table manager, if he survives a season at QPR he,ll have done well. He had his chance at Man City, he had the cash , look at HIS signings! proof enough he cant hack it no matter how much he might think hes a great tactician and leader of men(ok egotistical footballers)... GET A GRIP MAN! and write a decent commonsense article for once, at this rate you wont get a "proper" job at one of those highly respectable redtops like the Sun Star and Mirror as a teaboy!
  • norman  •  Manchester, England  •  4 months ago
    You really have not got a clue about football or what makes a good manager, get a new job.
  • Lee  •  Tonbridge, England  •  4 months ago
    Hughes and Fernandes deserve each other, Hughes couldn't manage a p*** up in a brewery, and Fernandes couldn't run a bath. Feel sorry for the long time QPR fans who have to put up with it.
  • martin  •  London, England  •  4 months ago
    hughes is a loser who has an inflated ego hes done #$%$ all ias a manager he made an arse of himself at man city was #$%$ at blackburn bored the arse off fans at fulham and he will nowt at qpr i dont really like warnock but i dont think he was given a fair crack of the whip
  • TERRY  •  London, England  •  4 months ago
    mabe time will show the welshman is as smart as his suits but I wouldnt bet a penny farthing on it.
  • Badspelling  •  London, England  •  4 months ago
    Alex Chick must not know anything about football, because if he did he would not write so many #$%$ articles.
    • A Yahoo! User 4 months ago
      It's a good article. No trace of sarcasm whatsoever...
  • Badspelling  •  London, England  •  4 months ago
    Alex Chick what do you know about football, from what i have read of your articles i take it you know nothing, because if you did you wouldnt write such #$%$
  • dj softy  •  London, England  •  4 months ago
    lmao u telling me they replaced warnock with hughes lol madness they will pay for that in the long run trust he #$%$ thank god he didnt come to villa
  • Joseph  •  Freetown, Sierra Leone  •  4 months ago
    Mark Hughes is a talented manager. Let us hope he gets some luck with QPR!
  • PatSyCola -  •  Brighton, England  •  4 months ago
    Mark Hughes will do just fine. I had the biggest bet of my life on QPR (thanks neil) to win the Championship last year, 14-1 and all the way down to odds on, backed them time after time. I just wish I could get another mug bookie to lay me, and who thinks they will go down , any takers ? Rangers will finish comfortably clear in the top 12 , not bad for new boys in first season. Im off to the Canaries for some winter Sun , thanks to laddies ,paddy, and fred on the local high street
    • Gavin Whigham 4 months ago
      Hey good luck nice to read someones creaming the bookies & if u have any good tips to share message me !!!
  • Faizal  •  Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia  •  4 months ago
    30M??? what Hughes should do? i think he will stay long...
    first, he should buy some star players that have something to give.. wayne bridge is available..also alex from chelsea.. an an attacker like pavluchenko from spurs..
  • Ian  •  4 months ago
    Best of luck to Sparky and QPR ... let's just hope Tony Fernandes isn't from the Abramovich mould of club ownership. A Liverpool fan.
  • reggaebeach  •  Sheffield, England  •  4 months ago
    that's another million or two in the bank for mark,who of course won't make any difference to the escape chances of qpr.they are relegated,hughes will do a bit of hand wringing then pick up his compo cheque and bugger off back to the valleys and wait for the next club to want to sign him....it's a great life as the grim reaper of football clubs,and before anyone gets out their dollies chucked out the pram look at his track record,it speaks volumes.
  • Peace  •  Bristol, England  •  4 months ago
    one man off the dole another one back on it.
  • ZORRO  •  Glasgow, Scotland  •  4 months ago
    WHAT BAD LUCK RANGERS.LOOKS LIKE THE JELLYPISH AINT GOING !!!!!!!!!!!
  • BillS  •  Ilford, England  •  4 months ago
    Mark Hughes has achieved nothing in his managerial career apart from qualifying for europe on the basis of fair play. If he is to be judged at QPR it should be on the same terms as Warnock - same players, no money and then lets se if his tactics and motivation work any better. But if the board decided to do things differently then they need shooting for their poor treatment of Warnock. Funny how Hughes has not managed to be in the running for other top jobs since he left Fulham.....
  • Al  •  4 months ago
    First I was thinking that oh cool, Hughes is coming, although it feels wrong that Warnock was sacked. But after hearing that Joorabchian manages Hughes, I almost vomited in disgust..
    • Steve 4 months ago
      Blimey - wouldn't want to be sat next to you on a bus
  • Jam  •  Boston, United States  •  4 months ago
    If Hughes is "too talented a manager" then why has he been sacked from all his other clubs?
    • Teal 4 months ago
      He wasn't sacked by Fulham.
    • blueboy22 4 months ago
      wasnt sacked by Fulham,Man Citys owners wanted a more high profile Manger

About Armchair Pundit

Alex Chick spent the World Cup pontificating from the comfort of his own front room, and will continue rambling about football from the dark recesses of the Eurosport office. Not so much Armchair Pundit as Swivel Chair Pundit. He has been Deputy Managing Editor at Eurosport-Yahoo! since 2007, although it took him until last week to work out how to use the photocopier.

  • Hodgson hamstrung by foreign influx

    Hodgson hamstrung by foreign influx

    Well, we know what Harry Redknapp would have said had he been appointed England manager and been in charge for tomorrow's friendly against Norway: 'We're down to the bare bones.' And Harry would have been right. As rude awakenings go, … Continue reading → More »

    Jim White - Fri, May 25, 2012 13:01 BST
  • Hodgson lowers England expectations

    Hodgson lowers England expectations

    "You don't have to use short passes. Not if you want to use your big man up front." It could be a line ripped straight from the script of 'Mike Bassett: England Manager', that affectionate yet searingly honest deconstruction of … Continue reading → More »

    Early Doors - Fri, May 25, 2012 09:10 BST
  • Over and out for Pep

    Over and out for Pep

    It's a good time to be a Real Madrid fan. Jose Mourinho has signed an extension which will contract him to the Bernabeu until 2016. Sir Alex Ferguson might think about moving on by then.  Having displaced Barca as Spanish … Continue reading → More »

    Andy Mitten - Thu, May 24, 2012 17:46 BST
  • Coaching or TV? Neville must choose

    Coaching or TV? Neville must choose

    Gary Neville's appointment to Roy Hodgson's England coaching staff surprised me, because I'm not sure he can combine the job with his punditry for Sky. If he is working as a link between the squad and the manager, he needs … Continue reading → More »

    Paul Parker - Thu, May 24, 2012 13:02 BST
  • Barton gazes into the abyss

    Barton gazes into the abyss

    Twelve Nietzsche quotes for Joey Barton to ponder during his suspension: 'If there is something to pardon in everything, there is also something to condemn.' 'Talking much about oneself can also be a means to conceal oneself.' 'And if you … Continue reading → More »

    Early Doors - Thu, May 24, 2012 09:01 BST
POLL

Should Roberto Di Matteo be given the Chelsea job full-time?

Loading...
Poll Choice Options