Bunker Mentality

Man sues golf club for lowering handicap

How much is your handicap worth to you? For one golfer in Ireland, it's apparently worth €10m. In a bizarre story that, honestly, belongs in The Onion, 75-year-old golfer Thomas Talbot is suing his former club, Hermitage Golf Club, after the handicap secretary reduced his handicap by 7.7 shots between 1999 and 2004.

As the Irish Independent reported, Talbot claimed the handicap reduction took a personal toll on him over the last six years, as friends at his former club refused to play with him and labelled him a cheat.

The golf club claimed that based on GUI Rule 19, it had an obligation to lower his handicap if it felt it was too high relative to his ability on the course. But Talbot didn't see it that way, and so here we are ... talking about a guy suing his golf club for a lowered handicap. A LOWERED handicap.

"This case has been going on for the past six years. It has been hugely stressful. I didn't care so much about the handicap issue, it is more the principle of it.

"I'd turn up for a competition and there would be nobody to play with. I have learned the hard way that friends are a funny species - they're never there when you want them.["]

On one hand, I feel bad for Talbot because playing golf with friends is one of the best things on earth. But on the other hand, I want to know how he went five years without questioning his handicap. If this was such a big deal back then, why didn't he just talk to someone at the club and get things cleared up? That's the real question that needs to be answered.

Jonathan Wall, Yahoo! Sports

 

4 comments

  • LYNNE  •  Edinburgh, Scotland  •  3 months ago
    Should come to Powfoot golf club and cut some off the women!!! 49pts in a stableford and not having their full handicap.
  • Joao  •  Oeiras, Portugal  •  3 months ago
    Honestly, there's something missing here... So the gentleman complains that nobody was willing to play him suposedly because he had a too high handicap for his level of playing (communly know as "cheating"). Then the club lowers his handicap to make things fair and his friends may accept to play him again. Then he complains his club has lowered his handicap? Isn't this nonsense or am I missing something? The complaint of "no friends" and "lowered handicap" just don't fit! can you explain, please? This is nonsense...
  • ted  •  London, England  •  3 months ago
    When I was Handicap Secretary I needed protection from Golfers who wanted their handicap lowered! Although I have encountered players who 'avoided' qualifying games, to foster their pot hunting prospects, these I did my best to cut savagely, but they never sued.
  • A  •  Manchester, England  •  3 months ago
    If you think hes a cheat or has a false handicap,have a look at most americans handicaps

About Bunker Mentality

From the top of the golfing tree to the grubby roots of the game which bind us all together, Bunker Mentality will be there: It’ll tees up slices of news, and send them fizzing back down the neatly-trimmed fairway of opinion with more punch than a Tiger 2-iron stinger, more spin than a Mickelson wedge – and more bottle than John Daly.

POLL

Should players be penalised for slow play in golf?

Loading...
Poll Choice Options