Cow Corner

Is Broad England’s genuine all-rounder?

There are few roles more important and yet elusive then a genuine world class all-rounder.

England have always been more transfixed with the role than most other sides, heralding the status of Ian Botham and Andrew Flintoff beyond all measure.

Since Flintoff hung up his size 14 boots after the 2009 Ashes, the nation has awaited the next instalment of the all-rounder phenomenon with bated breath. It is an obsession which consumes even the most pragmatic of cricket followers.

Stuart Broad's bowling has improved dramatically since he ditched the ill-advised role of England enforcer and back-of-a-length pounder and sought to emulate Glenn McGrath's penchant for hitting the off stump 'corridor of uncertainty'.

Broad has since enjoyed a stunning spell of form, ransacking India on home soil before producing an unwaveringly consistent set of performances with the ball in the UAE.

The 24-year-old boasts a bowling average of 15.50 over the last six months, taking 32 wickets with a potent strike rate of 40.3 - the stats of a truly world-beating fast bowler.

While the comparisons with McGrath may be unfair and slightly tedious, Broad's metronomic line and length and ability to pepper a nagging area outside the batsman's off stump make the similarities with the great Australia paceman hard to ignore.

With time very much on his side, Broad - under the erudite stewardship of Victorian David Saker - can continue to blossom and hone his skills while ensuring that he does not waver from the fuller length that he has employed over the last six months to such success.

Along with Steven Finn, Broad has been a beneficiary of England's refined strength and conditioning boot camps; the results have been very telling and have seen both bowlers hit 90mph+ with encouraging regularity.

Having established himself as a world class paceman, the onus has been firmly on Broad to demonstrate his ability with the bat.

Over the last 12 months, Broad averages 40.25 with a strike rate of 90.44 with two of his significant half-centuries having been ended abruptly after being left stranded by the tail.

After Tim Bresnan left the tour of the Middle East with his ongoing shoulder problem, the pressure has been cranked up on Broad to carry England's lower order amid a string of disappointing displays from several frontline batsmen.

Stuart Broad wrestled back a great deal of the momentum for the tourists with his 58 off 62 balls before he was left stranded by the tail, and it said something of the esteem he is held in by the opposition that Pakistan gladly and openly gave him cheap singles with Ian Bell at the other end.

Perhaps the crucial feature of Broad's game which fits neatly in line with that of other big-name all-rounders is his ability to take the game away from his opponents with a touch of the unexpected and the sublime.

England's number eight plundered seven sparkling boundaries, including a belligerent six, in what was a measured, yet destructive cameo to provide the tourists' first innings with a timely fresh impetus.

The frontline batsmen played with a great deal of apprehension and a distinct lack of fluency; Broad demonstrated that it was possible to play with freedom and conviction in unfamiliar conditions.

After stumps, Broad spoke about his intention to "take the game to Pakistan with aggressive, positive batting" and he executed this approach with distinction.

England established a crucial 70-run lead from the first innings, and Broad's contribution - not for the first time - could prove to be the most significant in the context of the match.

With Monty Panesar, Graeme Swann and Jimmy Anderson all unable to provide Broad with an accomplice, the Notts man was left stranded at the crease; there is no telling how his innings would have developed with additional support.

England look set to stick rigidly to the balance of their side with six batsmen and four bowlers but, regardless of where Broad finds himself in the order, he represents a significant threat to any side with his wide range of strokes and powerful ball-striking.

Unfavourable comparisons can always be made with those in the pantheon of great all-rounders, but Broad is currently excelling in a successful England side and fulfilling his role in every respect.

++++

STAT OF THE DAY: Since January 2011, England's tail add on average 50 runs per wicket - considerably more than any other side in Test cricket. Again, lower-order runs proved crucial to the tourists posting a significant first-innings lead.

TWEET OF THE DAY: "Ian Bell seems to be growing a moustache again, the sort of moustache that says 'my middle name is Ronald'." (Patrick Kidd)

USER COMMENT OF THE DAY: "Strauss is a cricketer of the Mike Brearley mould: he's there for his formidable captaincy skills­ predominantly, and occasionally weighs in with a score. With no­ Strauss in the side, England would be lucky to be the fourth best side in the world. Anyone that wants Strauss dropped could clearly write their knowledge of cricket on the back of a­ postage stamp." (Vinay)

SHOTS OF THE DAY: Monty goes in for the flying hug, something which rather stuns a startled Andrew Strauss. A couple of frames later, both had hit the deck.

Kevin Pietersen decides that the most efficient way of running out Asad Shafiq is to rugby tackle the Pakistan batsman before knocking over the stumps with a diving header. It works perfectly, but for the some reason the umpires took exception to it.

In stark contrast to every other day of the series so far, the fans turned out in their droves. They didn't just turn up, they also broke the world record for the most amount of people constantly waving for six hours. It was all worth it.

 

23 comments

  • GARY  •  Taunton, England  •  29 days ago
    Sir Ian Botham was special, Flintoff was good, Broad: I hope, in time; will be considered comprable; but, not one of them for captain.
  • amit  •  29 days ago
    Broad is England's pillar. A guy who has worked hard to become a genuine all rounder. He gets the most credit in bowling department for the golden era England is in.
  • Chuck  •  London, England  •  29 days ago
    He is Himself
    Lazy journalist speak re flintoff as he is a winker
  • craig  •  London, England  •  29 days ago
    I think he has the potential to be better then Flintoff, firstly he looks after himself better then Freddie did, and secondly he doesn't have the pressure that Freddie did when he came into Test Cricket, because England are actually a pretty good side even though there 1-0 down to Pakistan i am sure as long as thet plat the brand of attacking cricket thay have over the last 18 months or so they can get back into the series.
  • Sydney  •  29 days ago
    Broad is a real talent, and is improving all the time. Surely after today's performance he should be moved up the order?
  • Wally  •  29 days ago
    I think the answer is that Broad is a good way towards being a genuine international all-rounder. If he carries on like this there won't be any doubt...
  • No More Faith  •  29 days ago
    They called Flintoff an all rounder. I think Broad is better than Flintoff. So I would say yes he is an all rounder.
  • aitch  •  Nonthaburi, Thailand  •  29 days ago
    He has done very wel,l full credit to him, re-adjusted his attitude too, being Mr Angry was not doing him any good. Good article Cowers, user comment spot on except Strauss is a genuine top order Test batsman, his form will return. The Botham knockers, talking out of your backsides.
  • tony  •  Bangkok, Thailand  •  29 days ago
    Good article Cowers although "User comment" rather dubious. Yes, I believe we are seeing the development of a decent all-rounder in Broad. Let's hope he stays fit and takes his father's advice.
  • i'mnotrightuknow  •  London, England  •  29 days ago
    England are a formidable foe to any team. OK they had a bad game so do the Aussies and all the other top teams. All the England knockers are either not too bright or just want to wake up in a benny. As the N0 1 team let them enjoy it, its hard to get there and even harder to stay so give them the credit they have earned. The odd bad game shows how hard it is to stay there and how vulnerable we are at being dam good.
  • GARY  •  London, England  •  29 days ago
    Hope he drinks alot . And has a big opinion of himself
  • GARY  •  London, England  •  29 days ago
    Do not get this Flintoff was overrated. He did some great things but also let his country down through drinking and a 5 0 defeat in Australia where he had the great honour to captain his country.He got carried away by his own press and got into celebrity culture . Broad is more level headed and therefore will have a better career, but please do not compare him to a self proclaimed legend.
  • MICK DAVISON  •  London, England  •  29 days ago
    Ian Botham was a genuine, proven all-rounder. I'm not so sure "Freddy" was, certainly not in the status of "Guy". However, Broad's elevation as a genuine all-rounder has already surpassed Flintoff''s claim and, surely, with time on his side, he will equal the feats of the mighty Both!
  • ALLISON  •  London, England  •  29 days ago
    disagree with j broad is gorgeous and a wonderful all rounder he is a pleasure to watch!!!!!!!
    go stuart xxxxxxxx
  • hydrargyrum  •  Reading, England  •  29 days ago
    Not the new Flintoff - he's not a drunk.
  • peter  •  29 days ago
    put him at number five, like botham and flintoff
  • Lisping Ed  •  Bromsgrove, England  •  29 days ago
    That user comment of the day is a crock of #$%$ England would be a far BETTER team without Strauss. He's a useless batsman - and he's a useless captain.
  • Chuck  •  London, England  •  29 days ago
    botham & flintoff are both winkers
  • J  •  London, England  •  29 days ago
    freddie flintoff is gorgeous, stuart broad is not!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Chuck  •  London, England  •  29 days ago
    Flintoff is a #$%$ & a drunkBotham is a charity fraudster with all those walks but nothing else to talk about bar two timing his missus in the caribean

About Cow Corner

Cow Corner had a sheltered upbringing - it was educated from home and forfeited text books for hardback copies of Wisden Almanack with the only visual stimulation being the John Player League. "Cowers" is the illegitimate sibling of Early Doors and can often be seen on park benches around St John"s Wood trying to sell signed copies of Colin Dredge’s autobiography. Cow has been known to bowl some military medium whilst wielding the long handle at the bottom of the order and answers to one God and one God only, that known as Benaud.