Jim White

Giggs straddles two eras of English football

Ryan Giggs celebrates his landmark goalAt Craven Cottage on Wednesday night Ryan Giggs scored a goal. It was the third Manchester United strike in a five-goal rout, so in normal circumstances it would have been of no note.

Except it was the veteran winger's first league goal this season. And it meant that, as Gary Lineker was swift to point out on Match of the Day, Giggs had found the net in every single season of the Premier League's existence. Twenty years he has been striking - which is some achievement.

Giggs's strike at Craven CottageWhat a shame that his goal did not coincide — as, but for the intervention of Villa's Marc Albrighton elsewhere on the night, it almost did - with the 20,000th goal scored in the Premier League. What a thing that would have been. In his 20th year, scoring the 20,000th goal: you can't buy that kind of romance.

Except, though nobody seemed to note it at the time, the 20th year was not the really important thing to be recorded about his goal. Giggs's effort marked an even more extraordinary landmark: it was the 22nd consecutive league campaign in which he has found the mark. Because the truth is, he actually scored a few in the old Football League Division One.

Giggs in 1990I know: incredible, isn't it? Yes, there actually was football before the Premier League. And Ryan Giggs was scoring in it.

Such has been the Premier League's iron grip on our thinking, however, that it is easy to forget there was a fully functioning operation long before Richard Scudamore, Sky TV and Barclays even became involved. Sure, it was a long time ago — so long ago Leeds won the last non-Prem title — but that does not mean all records began when the top clubs broke away from the rest of the Football League. Whisper it, but there was a game out there before pro-zone, before hi-performance base layers. Astonishing as it may seem, there was something happening even before players wore gloves with short sleeved shirts.

Yet we in the media have been so blinded by the commercial leviathan we appear to have concertinaed everything into the timespan of the Premier League. All our statistical and historical thinking has been geared towards the Premier League era, as if that was when football started. Sky, the chief cheerleaders of the brand, have understandable excuse: their own history neatly parallels the Premier League's. But the rest of us have no excuse for buying into this ever-growing idea of a Stalinist new dawn.

Let's remind ourselves of a couple of things: Alan Shearer may indeed be the leading goalscorer in Premier League history, but he is only fifth in the all-time records, behind Jimmy Greaves, Dixie Dean, Steve Bloomer and Gordon Hodgson. Liverpool may not have won the Premier League, but they have the small matter of 18 championships to their name accrued before the breakaway.

Perhaps 20,000 goals have been scored in the Premier League, but more than six times that number were recorded in the top flight even before the Year Zero, or 1993 as it is sometimes referred to. Oh, and should Manchester City win the title this season, yes, it will be the first time players in the sky blue shirt have lifted the trophy, but it will not be the club's first ever victory in the league. It will be their third.

History matters. It places the present in proper context. You only have to remember the risible manner in which the Milton Keynes Dons claimed to have been FA Cup winners to appreciate that altering past facts is the province of the scoundrel through the ages. We have a proud, extensive and significant football history in this country.

The truth is, noble as they may have appeared, Giggs and Albrighton's records this week were wholly artificial, invented for promotional purposes. Our leagues have been in operation for more than 140 years. Wilfully to shoehorn all that into a mere two decades solely to satisfy the commercial imperatives of those currently holding sway over the game is to diminish all that came before.

 

60 comments

  • LG  •  5 months ago
    Decent article Jim, but a small comment if I may. You note in the article that there was a football operation long before "Barclays even became involved". Surely you don't need reminding that Barclays used to sponsor The Football League for a short while back in the late eighties and early nineties? (1987-1993 to be precise, thanks Wikepedia.)

    Still, I remember Saturday evenings back then with the results service referring to "Barclays League Division 1" and the like. Yes, I'm old :-)
    • toby 5 months ago
      Although your desire for the facts is notable LG, I feel you've missed the point.
    • LG 4 months ago
      Toby, you say I've missed the point, but yet you don't explain why you feel this to be the case. All I did was point out a true fact. What's your problem?
  • ANDREW G  •  London, England  •  5 months ago
    Yes there WAS Footie before Sky/Premiership ruined it(a hundred years in fact) and what another fine mess they have got the once'beautifull game' into!!
  • Jez  •  Singapore, Singapore  •  5 months ago
    Could some one please show me where the headline actually fits in the story! Or is this yet another cheap and pathetic attempt at journalism that is actually a summary of footballing facts with no link to the to the title whatsoever!
    • SG 5 months ago
      Did you skip over the part that spoke about Giggs having played, and scored, in the top English league prior to the inception of the Premier League? That is the link between title and story, two generations of English football, pre Premier League and now, and Giggs is one of the few active players to have been involved in both eras. That simple enough for you? Wonders what can be achieved with the ability to not only read the words, but also comprehend them.
  • go forth and  •  Melbourne, Australia  •  5 months ago
    Not the only thing Giggs straddles,
  • aobakwe  •  5 months ago
    commercial or not... giggs has archieved what most players dream of doing.. u cant ever diminish that fact..
  • robert  •  4 months ago
    who cares (people from london, usa or china mainly), im sick of yahoo getting all the dirty scummers, to write pointless #$%$
  • appu  •  Dublin, Ireland  •  5 months ago
    good boy
  • d.j.  •  Cork, Ireland  •  5 months ago
    In his 20 th year - incorrect , he has 22 years in a row in the top league. His private life is just that , he's not the head of any church.
    • toby 5 months ago
      Did you read the whole article? It clearly states that he has been scoring goals in the top flight for 22 years. And emphasises that this is a far better accomplishment.
  • ROGO  •  Brighton, England  •  5 months ago
    well it beats straddling welsh reality TV stars
    • Sean R 5 months ago
      didnt she straddle him?
  • Rex  •  Castletown, Isle of Man  •  5 months ago
    Are these two Eras a couple of Spanish girls we haven't heard about (yet)?
  • garibaldi  •  St Albans, England  •  5 months ago
    Mmmm, why are Man U fans always ready to point out that they have won the title more times than Liverpool but conveniently forget the European Cup/Champions League
  • A Yahoo! User  •  5 months ago
    "Giggs straddles two eras of English football"... among other things of course.
    • firasm 5 months ago
      His Sister in Law #$%$ I feel soo sick about writing about it I have just seen mine two days ago I hate you Giggs for making me feel sick
  • Politician Stole My Money  •  Manchester, England  •  5 months ago
    Giggs , Giggs he's the greatest
  • Politician Stole My Money  •  Manchester, England  •  5 months ago
    What Giggs has achieved at Manchester United no one will ever again achieve
  • Lawrence  •  Milton Keynes, England  •  5 months ago
    glyn b you mean the drunken abusive pub brigade
  • David  •  London, England  •  5 months ago
    What Giggs has achieved will never be replicated. He is a footballer-I judge him on football. In days past there was not the scrutiny of the media on footballers-who knows what they got up to and who cares. I am proud to support Giggs and Utd and most real football fans would admit they would have loved to have a player like him in their team.I have been watching him weave his magic for over twenty years and he is still capable of running a game and producing moments of pure class that take your breath away.Pure Legend.
  • DAVID  •  Birmingham, England  •  5 months ago
    WHERE THE HELL HAVE MY POSTS GONE,,, OH I KNOW THE THOUGHT POLICE AT IT AGAIN
  • EEEEEEEEE  •  Scunthorpe, England  •  5 months ago
    Depressing fact: Most of the clowns commenting haven't even got the intelligence to work out that this article isn't even about Giggs. That's why the modern fan is on to a loser,
  • Tom  •  Dublin, Ireland  •  5 months ago
    All ye people talking about Giggsys indescretions in the bedroom rather than the phenominal achievement that is his career need to grow the hell up. Its nobodies business but his. I presume all the comedians are bitters and dippers.
  • Richard  •  Burlington, Canada  •  5 months ago
    For us, the fans and you people in the media, Giggsy's 20 years is a milestone, an event. He is probably looking at it as just another day at the office. Strange that way.

About Jim White

An award-winning columnist with the Daily Telegraph for which he has covered all the world’s major sporting events – Jim is well known and highly regarded in all parts of the media. A long-serving contributor to Radios 4 and 5, he consistently appears on BBC television and Sky for which he has recently written, and presented, documentaries on Jose Mourinho and Sven-Goran Eriksson. He is the author of the best-selling You"ll Win Nothing With Kids, the memoir of his time as a wholly unsuccessful junior football coach.

  • Hodgson hamstrung by foreign influx

    Hodgson hamstrung by foreign influx

    Well, we know what Harry Redknapp would have said had he been appointed England manager and been in charge for tomorrow's friendly against Norway: 'We're down to the bare bones.' And Harry would have been right. As rude awakenings go, … Continue reading → More »

    Jim White - Fri, May 25, 2012 13:01 BST
  • Hodgson lowers England expectations

    Hodgson lowers England expectations

    "You don't have to use short passes. Not if you want to use your big man up front." It could be a line ripped straight from the script of 'Mike Bassett: England Manager', that affectionate yet searingly honest deconstruction of … Continue reading → More »

    Early Doors - Fri, May 25, 2012 09:10 BST
  • Over and out for Pep

    Over and out for Pep

    It's a good time to be a Real Madrid fan. Jose Mourinho has signed an extension which will contract him to the Bernabeu until 2016. Sir Alex Ferguson might think about moving on by then.  Having displaced Barca as Spanish … Continue reading → More »

    Andy Mitten - Thu, May 24, 2012 17:46 BST
  • Coaching or TV? Neville must choose

    Coaching or TV? Neville must choose

    Gary Neville's appointment to Roy Hodgson's England coaching staff surprised me, because I'm not sure he can combine the job with his punditry for Sky. If he is working as a link between the squad and the manager, he needs … Continue reading → More »

    Paul Parker - Thu, May 24, 2012 13:02 BST
  • Barton gazes into the abyss

    Barton gazes into the abyss

    Twelve Nietzsche quotes for Joey Barton to ponder during his suspension: 'If there is something to pardon in everything, there is also something to condemn.' 'Talking much about oneself can also be a means to conceal oneself.' 'And if you … Continue reading → More »

    Early Doors - Thu, May 24, 2012 09:01 BST
POLL

Should Roberto Di Matteo be given the Chelsea job full-time?

Loading...
Poll Choice Options