YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Oval Talk

    Premiership return dazzles and gives plenty to ponder

    The opening weekend of the 2012-13 Aviva Premiership did not fail to deliver, by any stretch of the imagination.

    Reigning champions Harlequins' incredible recovery from a 27-point deficit to win 42-40 against Wasps, Danny Cipriani's much-heralded return to English rugby commencing with a very sharp dose of reality in a 43-6 defeat for his Sale side against Exeter Chiefs, a single point separating victorious Bath and a disappointed Worcester at Sixways, and a very harsh introduction to life in the top flight for London Welsh give just a snapshot of some of the happenings in the first round of games.

    One of the major talking points after the weekend amongst the media, fans and naturally clubs and players is the new Television Match Official (TMO) review system.

    It's most apparent benefits (or hindrances, depending on one's receptiveness to what has been proposed as a logical progression in the way the game is policed) were in the spectacular Wasps v Quins encounter, with Wasps denied a try at a point in the game that would have put their advantage beyond the realistic realms of recovery.

    The major gripe with regards to that scenario are the boundaries of how far back the play can be reviewed. Currently the limit is the last stoppage, which has laid the basis for fears that referees could dig deep into the build-up to a score with any number of phases of play open to scrutiny.

    Thankfully common sense prevailed on the whole over the weekend, and with the system still being trialled there is room for manoeuvre and we could see more rigid parameters introduced. That's all part of the process.

    In Saracens' mauling of London Irish yellow cards for Chris Ashton and Ofisa Treviranus were both the result of the TMO being called into play, so on the fair play aspect it was also a crucial part of proceedings.

    Some will — and have begun to — complain that the employment of the TMO on a more frequent basis will interrupt the flow of the game and remove some of the human aspect of the decision-making process that has made rugby the passion-fuelled experience so loved by all. More credence should be given to referees who, by and large, are just as interested as fans and spectators in keeping the game flowing.

    It will be a process of trial and error but over the weekend enough examples of the positive effects of the new system were witnessed to suggest that a little stop-start and adjustment in the early rounds may be a small price to pay for a better-regulated and ultimately fairer game.

    About Oval Talk

    Rugby has to fight for its voice in the football-obsessed world of British sport, but thankfully there are enough fans of the oval ball to warrant a weekly look at issues affecting the game. Oval Talk cannot promise the same level of scurrilous tittle-tattle and unfounded rumour that emerges daily from football columns, but - casting off its Barbour and adopting the refreshing candour of an Aussie commentator – it can bring you the kind of debate that would have had old farts at HQ spluttering into their Fullers.

    POLL

    Did Jonny Wilkinson deserve to win European Player of the Year?

    Loading...
    Poll Choice Options

    FANTASY FOOTBALL

    • Free To Join
      Free To Join

      Think you can do better than Fergie or Mancini? Sign up now and pick your winning team. More »