Pitchside Europe

Could Celtic really survive without Rangers?

There are several jokes doing the rounds at the moment about Rangers' troubling financial plight. "I'm a Celtic fan, but I just want to express my sadness about the boys in blue going into administration," goes one. "Such a great club, with such a proud history, such wonderful players and such fantastic supporters. All the best to everyone at Portsmouth Football Club."

Gallows humour has always played a part in the life of the long-suffering football fan, but there is something altogether different about the reaction that has been sparked in certain quarters by the turmoil affecting Rangers. The potential £75 million tax bill they face has raised the very real possibility that the Ibrox club could go out of existence, but rather than showing sympathy, supporters of their great rivals, Celtic, are revelling in it, and the club have even claimed that it would make no difference to them if the other half of the Old Firm was to disappear.

"The way we would look at it is, we don't need Rangers," said chief executive Peter Lawwell last week. "We have a strategy that we have embarked on that's independent of Rangers or any other club in Scotland."

It is fair to say that Celtic's history would look very different if Rangers had never existed. With only one team in Glasgow, the Bhoys would have dominated Scottish football to an unhealthy extent and fans of the game north of the border would have been deprived of some of the most evocative encounters in the history of British sport.

The 118,567 people who crammed into Ibrox to watch the Old Firm derby on the second day of 1939 would have had nowhere to go. Celtic's famous 7-1 annihilation of Rangers at Hampden Park in the 1957 Scottish League Cup final — Hampden in the Sun — would never have happened. With no great foes to sharpen their minds and keep them on their toes, it is even doubtful that Celtic would have emerged as a European force in the late 1960s.

If Rangers were to fold, another team could conceivably step into their shoes, but it seems unlikely. No other Scottish team can compete with the two clubs in terms of fanbase or international profile, and the television deals in place with Sky Sports and ESPN rely heavily on the cachet of the Old Firm rivalry. Scottish football has already begun to slip off the map in European competition in recent years. Rangers' demise would only expedite matters.

To suggest that Celtic could carry on regardless without their old rivals is like claiming that Othello would be the same play if Iago or Othello were abruptly scratched from the script. Both teams define themselves by their opposition to the other. It can, on occasion, spill over into repellent sectarianism, but the great rivalries — be it Ali and Frazier, Prost and Senna or Nadal and Federer — are what enable sport to transcend the perfunctory accumulation of points, wins and trophies that it might otherwise be. John McEnroe and Bjorn Borg played out one of tennis' great rivalries but after three years of fierce contests, the Swede retired in 1981 and McEnroe admitted that his career was never the same again.

The rich irony is that, with Rangers on the brink of oblivion, Celtic are enjoying a 15-match winning streak in the league that is their best run since the incredible 2003-04 season under Martin O'Neill. Sunday's 5-0 success at Hibernian took them 17 points clear of Rangers at the summit and the Scottish Premier League title now appears a formality.

The victory at Easter Road was celebrated against a backdrop of delirious schadenfreude, with fans unfurling a huge replica shirt bearing the letters 'HMRC' and unveiling a banner that read: 'We're having a party as Rangers die.' Given the deep enmity that exists between the clubs, it is no surprise to see one celebrating the misfortune of the other with such glee, but Celtic's supporters should pause to reflect that it can sometimes feel lonely at the top.

- - -

European Team of the Week

 

97 comments

  • A Yahoo! User  •  1 month 26 days ago
    ..
  • kenneth  •  Inverness, Scotland  •  3 months ago
    this is all very hypothetical, the position rangers find themselves in is not the fault of Celtic or anyone else, and the comparisons between other sporting rivalries are very poor, were any of these other rivalries caught cheating? were any caught avoiding to pay tax to the tune of £70 million? i'm afraid if you cheat to that extent you pay the price, Celtic fans may as well enjoy it, and rangers should be stripped of many of their titles, cups and wee stupid stars.
    • peter b 3 months ago
      Could not agree more up to the point where you want to strip them of titles.
      I as a Celtic supporter would not want a title by default or by cheating. Leave that to them.
      Let them have their wee stars as well. They don't and never will have the big star on their jerseys and it was chasing that one lone star that dropped them in this mess.
      HAIL HAIL
    • kenneth 3 months ago
      Peter, Celtic don't need to accept them, they should just be stripped of them.
  • derek  •  Cork, Ireland  •  3 months ago
    hmmmn.. coincidentally.. and somewhat tabloidly trivial, if ye read from 4th to first in the SPL.. Hearts, Motherwell, Rangers, Celtic. HMRC
  • peter b  •  Paisley, Scotland  •  3 months ago
    Why is it so many people who are unconnected to Celtic F.C. presume to tell Celtic and its supporters what is good for them.
    I really don't care if Rangers go completely bust. Simple fact is they never paid their taxes. Nobody forced them not to pay, They themselves took a conscious decision to defraud HMRC to try and benefit themselves not Scottish football and whatever comes their way is of their own making.
    If Rangers go bust Celtic will go on make no mistake about that.
    As for the tv arguement who cares the current deal is derisory compared to other leagues anyway. If there was no SKY or ESPN maybe grounds would be fuller, maybe we could do unusual things like kick off on a Saturday at 3pm every week.
    One more point in my years watching football I remember the 80's when Rangers were not at the races. Likewise I remember the 90's when Celtic were not at the races. Scottish football survived then. Some might even argue it was better and more competitive.
    If Rangers go under they go under they only have themselves to blame
    HAIL HAIL
  • James  •  3 months ago
    Survive they certainly will,thrive is a different matter.
    I have no sympathy for Rangers at all,they cheated they have been caught.While they spent £12,000,000.00 on players like Tore Andre Flo and at the same time put little Airdrie into administration by having the gate money from a cup match arrested knowing full well that they themselves were fleecing and engaging in every underhand trick in the book.
    What goes around comes around and now you know how the players,management,people and town of Airdrie felt when your lot pulled the plug for a pittance by comparison.How much sympathy did the Ibrox board and Rangers fans have for Airdrie...none,it`s payback time.
    • peter b 3 months ago
      Good point well made. Also lets not forget how many teams were relegated while Rangers were lets say bending the rules. Playing players they could not afford.
      If Rangers were playing by the rules everyone else did. Could these teams maybe have gotten a few more points off them and survived. How much did it cost these teams financially being relegated.Whilst other teams were denied promotion due to grounds etc and having to adhere to the rules.
      No more poor Rangers they deserve what comes their way.
      HAIL HAIL
  • UB40,LOCHEE  •  Dundee, Scotland  •  3 months ago
    AT THE BEGINNING OF THIS SEASON,IT WAS ALL ABOUT GERS THIS GERS THAT 14POINTS CLEAR, WHATS IT ABOUT KNOW? FEEL FOR THE GENUINE GERS FAN, FROM THE WORKING CLASS THOUGH..
  • john  •  3 months ago
    I WAS AT HAMPDEN CELTIC V LEEDS 130,000 + 20,000 LOCKED OUT
    NEVER SEEN A LEEDS FAN, THEIR IS A FEW CELTs ABOUT, NOW DOES
    THAT HAPPEN IN THE E P L, O CELTIC WON THAT WAS THE BEST THE BRITs HAD
    • Hugh 3 months ago
      i was also there,jinky made terry cooper look like tommy cooper
    • danger_moose 3 months ago
      What the hell are you on about? That happened years ago, before the EPL even existed. I could bang on about past results of my club but that doesn't matter to anybody but a historian and somebody living in the past.
    • Hugh 3 months ago
      what clubs that danger-moose ? plenty of historians in england, still banging on about 1966 that even outdates CELTIC AND LEEDS
  • Martin  •  Leeds, England  •  3 months ago
    Only team in Glasgow. Are Partick and Queens Park in danger of being closed? If pitchside isn't aware of the existence of these 2 clubs is there much credibility in the rest of the article?
    • V 3 months ago
      Don't forget the mighty Albion
  • john  •  3 months ago
    **** IF THE BUNs GO OUT LETS HOPE IT SLOW DONT WANT IT OVER TO QUICK NICE AND SLOW YA
  • OTRAS  •  Madrid, Spain  •  3 months ago
    Who cares about FC Disgrace,kick them into row Z.
  • Guy  •  London, England  •  3 months ago
    It's all to do with Rangers overspending, just like the Eurozone!
  • perfd  •  Reading, England  •  3 months ago
    Frost and Senna? Alain Frost?
  • weeMartian  •  Manchester, England  •  3 months ago
    The utter hypocricy from the Rangers fans on this thread is astounding. If Celtic were in this predicament are you telling us you would NOT be taking the pish ? GET REAL !!!!
  • Chris  •  Irvine, Scotland  •  3 months ago
    To be honest. It wouldn't be the worst thing to happen if the spl died. It's an absolute joke of a league. Devoid of any real talent.
    Every match is just 20 hacket men running around aimlessly, without a shred of talent between them. Generally the winner is the team that kicked their opponents the most.
    That's not how football is supposed to be played.

    If the SPL does die and takes the sectarianism with it. The best thing to do is revive it, but simular to what Major league soccer did. Salary caps and it'll keep the teams even.

    Then it won't be just "Rangers and Celtic". But Ten possible champions every year.
  • Dasa  •  3 months ago
    total rubbish
  • Boris.  •  Edinburgh, Scotland  •  3 months ago
    I don't think Scottish football will survive nevermind Celtic, Sky won't show the SPL on TV without Rangers and I'm not sure ESPN will either, why would anyone pay to get SPL games on TV when there's only ever going to be one winner in Celtic and they will win the title by about 20-30 points season after season? not just TV deals aswell, what main sponsor wants to put money into a 1 team league?

    The only saving grace for the SPL for some time has been the Old Firm and I think it's naive of Celtic to have the who cares attitude because the money they are used to getting with Rangers will dry up so give it time and I'm sure after a year or two Celtic will care because without the TV money and probably a weaker main sponsor Celtic will suffer.
  • scunny lad  •  Sheffield, England  •  3 months ago
    I think you overstate the abilities of both these teams, I dont think either of them would gain automatic promotion from the championship, play offs at best. Just remember neither club is used to playing 50 competative and I repeat competative games a season and that would be their downfall, beating 10 less than ordinary teams twice or three times a year just dosn't cut it. They play in a third rate league on a par with the league of Ireland, also who in England would want them. Even as a Scot living in England I would not want what they bring to the table, who would want thousands of religious bigots roaming in their town or city on a saturday be they blue/white or green/white, not too many thats for sure.
  • tony  •  Nonthaburi, Thailand  •  3 months ago
    scottish football is rubbish only ever been two teams like watching paint dry
  • john c  •  3 months ago
    what the f are talking about
  • jim  •  London, England  •  3 months ago
    instead of a man in his mid 40s buying an unfunny scarf why not get brases for those disgusting misshapen teeth he has carried around for 40 odd years horrible specimen

About Pitchside Europe

Pitchside Europe brings you the inside line on Europe"s major leagues. From Lisbon to Berlin, Glasgow to Naples, we look at the teams, players, coaches and fans making an impression across the Old Continent. Be it teenage sensations in La Liga, managerial outbursts in Ligue 1, improbable haircuts in the Bundesliga or innovative tactical trends in Serie A, if it's happening in Europe, you'll find out about it here.

POLL

Should Roberto Di Matteo be given the Chelsea job full-time?

Loading...
Poll Choice Options