Simon Reed

A great final, but will it get stale?

Djokovic and Nadal - againWhat a great men's final it was to end the 2012 Australian Open.

It will doubtless be forgotten that the two weren't at their best in the first couple of hours, still shaking the fatigue off — I thought that they had played their best tennis earlier in the tournament — but sure enough it sprung into life, full of incident, and it will rightly be remembered as a classic encounter. It turned into a thrilling match between two fighters, and Djokovic — just — was the last man standing.

I thought this year we would reach the point where the phrase 'top four' might soon be outdated as others stepped up, but the Australian Open completely changed my mind on that.

There's an argument that Bernard Tomic or Gregor Dimitrov might break through, but I think that's a couple of years away. Jo-Wilfried Tsonga had a strong end to last year, but does he have the consistency? And as for Juan Martin del Potro, while it's amazing how he's closed the gap after his injury, can he take the final step?

So if it's these four in the semi-finals and finals every time, will it all get a bit stale?

I don't think we've reached that point yet, but there's only so many times we can carry on talking about 'was it the greatest final of all-time?' — as we have for Wimbledon 2008, Australian Open 2009 and this match — not to mention some classic semi-finals between the big four.

There's a danger that we'll feel like we've read the book and bought the T-shirt — we've seen the show. We know the stories and personalities all too well, and they will doubtless meet each other several times again at the various Masters Series events before the French Open.

If these four keep playing against each other so often, it slightly lessens the impact it has.

There's a risk it could become a bit repetitive.

But whether you agree or not, we have an interesting story brewing for Roland Garros.

Djokovic will be aiming to win his fourth Grand Slam in a row, while Nadal remains the King of Clay.

I think Nadal is a better player so far this year than he was in 2011. He lost again to Djokovic, and I really thought he would wrap up the match having led 4-2 in the fifth set.

Whether losing from that position has a psychological effect on him or not remains to be seen — but knowing Nadal's attitude I think he'll take encouragement from the way he played as he prepares to defend the only Grand Slam title he currently holds.

I make Nadal a slight favourite for Paris, but Djokovic is capable of anything.

 

67 comments

  • Foxy15  •  Birmingham, England  •  3 months ago
    How can this guy simon reed say that the finals in tennis will get stale ? When was the last time you had four guys in the top 10 in tennis history that competed in matches as top draw as we have been watching unfold in the last 5 years.
    I have been following tennis all my life 40 years and I can never remember, apart from Borg, Mcenroe, Connors and through the Sampras era and that was for me no great spectacle.
    • Alex 3 months ago
      Good point. Mister Simon Reed had said before the tournament that Federer will win so no he needs to discredit Novak and even Rafa by writing such an article, shameful! Fed won many titles having Roddick, Gonzalez, Nalbandian as his key rivals... The guy was extremely lucky not to have Rafa in top form from the very beginning and Novak. Ever since novak came on stage and won first aussie open in 2008, "the mighty fed" won only 4 out of his 16 slams..
      Kudos to Rafa, and mega bravo to number 1 player of the World, Nole!
    • Jay Lewis 3 months ago
      The point about getting 'stale' is not where the match-ups are right now, but what if it's always the same results at all the tournaments they play together throught the season. Those who decry that the men's game could be stale should read what Mr. Reed is actually saying. Certainly express your opinions, please -- and you may well be right. But I think it's only fair to see where the season is 10 months down the line before being vitiolic to the article writer. He may turn out to be right (even if that is a first!) -- champagne can be sooo good, because it's special and rarely drunk (by most). If you were served it everyday, it wouldn't have the same sparkle. Let's wait and see if the top 4 are competitive with each other this year, or if the same 2 contest the finals, with the same result, and the same 2 lose the semis each time.
  • Francisco Gere  •  Budaörs, Hungary  •  3 months ago
    Shame on you Mr Reed!
    • Jay Lewis 3 months ago
      Why...? Mr. Reed hasn't been arrested on suspicion of a heinous crime, has he? Is it just me, or does this comment seem a little strong with nothing to add or back up why you say this (perhaps it is just me -- I see 22 likes and only 1 (me) dislike!).
  • Fred  •  London, England  •  3 months ago
    why can't people stop harking back to the good old days! we have four fantastic tennis players at the top of mens tennis and they're taking tennis to a new level. why can't people just enjoy that?!
  • Milan  •  3 months ago
    So? Should we stop watching tennis? What about football, Barcelona and others...should we stop watching that too as it becomes boring...
  • Stephen  •  3 months ago
    There is no doubt in my mind that the men's game is as competitive and intriguing than it has been for a long time. To have such depth and talent from all the top 4 ranked players and to have such a strong top 10 is to be commended, not denigrated. This is not to mention other such permutations in the game in the top 4: The rivalry between Nadal and Djokovic, the 'veteran' Federer who constantly looks to improve and challenge the top guns and Murray with his newly found partnership with Lendl and us all wondering where that might lead. The Nadal-Djokovic rivalry for me is the most compelling and to a degree it has the potential to become 'stale' if there is ever only going to be one winner, but I don't think that will continue in the way Djokovic has proved over the last 12 months or so. Nadal is a fighter and will constantly seek ways to improve his game, just as he did when playing Federer in the infancy of their rivalry. Djokovic of course had to make that breakthrough and it's precisely because of Federer and Nadal and their dominance at the top that Djokovic has become a better player. Personally, I think Djokovic will win the French Open this year but I think the Masters Series events are wide open, particularly Indian Wells and Miami.
    We must also recognise players such as Tsonga, Ferrer, Berdych, Del Potro and Raonic who add spice and variety to the sport and have the potential to be world beaters on any given day. We should celebrate this incredible rivalry that is brewing between all of the top 4 while it lasts because when it's gone we may wish we had it back.
  • achur o  •  Lagos, Nigeria  •  3 months ago
    Oh dear!! Mr Reed has just given Nadal his famous KISS OF DEATH. Now we will see a new French open champion having made Nadal a slight favourite.
    • Jay Lewis 3 months ago
      This kind of 'witty' comment has been made by so many before, that it's rather lost its relevance...
  • TH81  •  Toronto, Canada  •  3 months ago
    The only thing stale in Tennis right now is the women's game....the Men's Semis and Final was top notch Tennis!!
  • GM  •  Manila, Philippines  •  3 months ago
    I am excited about the current top 4. How can you think it's going to get stale when now there's 4 of them, and all of them are so talented and yet so different? For many years before this, it was just about Federer and Nadal. Then last year, Djokovic came into his own and the rivalry became a trivalry. And now, with a new coach and a more mature attitude, Murray is showing that 3 can become 4. 4 is better than 2, right? I certainly think so.
  • Runner  •  3 months ago
    Simon Reed's prejudice is unabated. He makes wishful thinking type juvenile predictions and then when they don't come true he is the only person who sulks about the glorious tennis we saw. All of this because his hero Federer was given another whooping by Nadal and his hated Novak not only won but was an unquestionable star of the tournament. Reed is such a trash fellow, he won't even do a mea culpa as to his predictions all being disproved.
    • legolas dorcol 3 months ago
      Thank you Runner, like you took the words from my mouth...ALL BEST from Belgrade
    • YiannisP 3 months ago
      You guys don't know what you're talking about. Simon does NOT like Federer, he definitely not his "hero" lol. the only reason simon picked Fed to win was because he knows he'd jinx him and he'd never win this way!
  • branko  •  Belgrade, Serbia  •  3 months ago
    I belive Djoko will prove that he is definitely capable of wining RG too!!! But let just wait and see...:-)
  • dele  •  Cape Town, South Africa  •  3 months ago
    what is ur definition of stale, mr REED?Stale is if its one sided, believe for all djoko, grand slam wins, aside last year's aussie open (2011) he had to fight tooth and nail, meaning it was not a walk over, pure competition all through, STALE?!!! u must be kidding.now everyone is waiting to see what happens in RG, can Djoko win his first, will Nadal relinquish is king of clay title, about murray, federer, del potro etc............c'mmon!!!!!
  • alan  •  Manchester, England  •  3 months ago
    Will some one hit this idiot in the back of the head with a bit of 4x2 if every final is like that then lets have then
  • sasa  •  Belgrade, Serbia  •  3 months ago
    I just want to ask , WHAT NOVAK DJOKOVIC NEED TO DO , THAT WILL MAKE YOU TO SAY THAT HE IS THE BEST RIGHT NOW AND THAT HE IS A FAVOURIT. Eurosport, please do something wirh this gentlman, he is doing his job very bad... i cannot belive that someone is writing this #$%$ ....
  • devic007  •  3 months ago
    Speaking at a tennis academy, in New York, on Wednesday, McEnroe said, "Djokovic has lifted his game to a point where I think his return has now maybe surpassed [Andre] Agassi. It used to be [Jimmy] Connors and Agassi. Now it's like beyond belief, what [Djokovic] can do with the return."

    "I think it's an incredible time, actually," said McEnroe. I think we [had] better enjoy it while it lasts. The shots that these guys can come up with ... is phenomenal. They've taken the baseline game to a whole new level.

    So much about "stalling" times!!
    "Stolen" from the ATP World Tour - MCENROE HAILS DJOKOVIC, TENNIS' GOLDEN ERA
  • Iordanis  •  Athens, Greece  •  3 months ago
    I will actually agree for once with what you say (at least the 1st paragraph). Djokovic and Nadal are indeed fighters, that is what they are.
  • HeadShoot  •  Värmdö, Sweden  •  3 months ago
    Federer and Kvitova ha......c c c c c DUDE :D:D
  • Mihajlo  •  Belgrade, Serbia  •  3 months ago
    Sir Simon why do you hate the Serbs?
    Is that your continuation of diplomacy from the `90's?
    Shame on you ... you dog
  • Ammar  •  Amman, Jordan  •  3 months ago
    Dear Simon, I think your last sentence has summed it up, quite rightfully !! Nadal, I believe, will take positives from his gruelling fight against djokovic, and he is, to be frank, favorite to win the French Open, but the Djoker is truly capable of anything.
  • b  •  3 months ago
    "I make Nadal a slight favourite for Paris, but Djokovic is capable of anything."
    ####
    Like he has ever made Djokovic a favourite. Please Mr Reed save your character counts when you are writing an article on Djokovic vs Anyone else,because we all know the anyone else will be your favourite.
  • mirela  •  3 months ago
    shame on you nacist Reed!

About Simon Reed

Simon Reed"s career began with BBC Radio in the late sixties when he worked for BBC Radio Sport, BBC World Service and BBC Radio London. From 1973, he was a presenter and reporter for Thames TV before freelancing in the early days of Sky Sports. In 1995, he became Head of Commentators for Eurosport specialising in tennis. He has covered three Olympic Games and has commentated on the last eight Wimbledon Championships.

Latest tennis blog post

  • French Open preview: Clay not for D …

    With the French Open starting this weekend, Eurosport analyst Mats Wilander looks ahead to the action. The seven-times Grand Slam winner considers how clay is the least … More »

    Mats Wilander
  • It’s inconceivable that Nadal won’t …

    It’s inconceivable that Nadal won’t …

    Rafael Nadal's form during this clay-court season has been absolutely frightening, and I cannot see anyone beating him at Roland Garros. The world number two overcame … More »

    Simon Reed
  • Smart money on Serena for Roland Ga …

    Smart money on Serena for Roland Ga …

    There are numerous candidates for the French Open on the women's side, but one stand-out performer who will surely prevail: Serena Williams. The American has only won … More »

    Simon Reed
  • Serena is back – and she deserves i …

    Serena is back – and she deserves i …

    Having swept to victory in Charleston, Serena Williams won in Madrid after battering world No.1 Victoria Azarenka in the final - signalling the return of the century's … More »

    Patrick Mouratoglou
  • Blue clay cannot return

    Blue clay cannot return

    There's no doubt that the blue clay at the Madrid Masters was a mistake. Watching the Rome Masters today, you can see the difference clearly — the ball is more difficult … More »

    Simon Reed
POLL

Is Rafael Nadal set to challenge for the No.1 ranking again?

Loading...
Poll Choice Options