Manchester United Message Board

ViewSummary |  Expanded
AsThreaded |  Message List
  • Why does SAF fight with his players?

    fred j by fred j . May 11, 2006 18:45 . Permalink

    When most players who have served thier clubs well leave, they get nice friendly goodbyes. But it appears SAF has a reputation for fighting with his.
    They don't leave happily after years of good service. They end up being 'kicked' out. Why? It appears Ferguson is the problem. Even if there are issues btw players, part of his job is to sort it out amicably

    • Re: Why does SAF fight with his players?

      by A Yahoo! User . May 11, 2006 18:51 . Permalink

      and part of his job is to pick the team.His house rules are no one upsets team spirit.He n...

      and part of his job is to pick the team.His house rules are no one upsets team spirit.He never says anything about players publicly,he protects them so when someone like stam for instance writes a book critisizing everyone at the club,he should go,however good he is.Ruud thought he was untouchable in the first 11,and when he was complete shit against liverpool,and before,fergie dropped him.Now he's dropped giggs,neville,fletcher,ronaldo,silvestre,etc,and their reaction was to fight for their places?Ruud didnt,he went round sulking,and if reports are true insulting many players,you cant have that

    • Re: Why does SAF fight with his players?

      by A Yahoo! User . May 11, 2006 18:53 . Permalink

      your asking why they were kicked out or in Ruuds case "being kicked out" - no one can say ...

      your asking why they were kicked out or in Ruuds case "being kicked out" - no one can say what goes on behind the scenes its all speculation - alot more could have gone on which no one knows about - as for the players you have mantioned above - i think we have moved on pretty well from their departure.

    • Re: Why does SAF fight with his players?

      Heathfield15 by Heathfield15 . May 11, 2006 20:05 . Permalink

      Absolutely spot on Ian. We never lacked talent but he came in and set massive standards t...

      Absolutely spot on Ian. We never lacked talent but he came in and set massive standards that our younger players chose to adopt and success followed. I don't care what you want to call him, to me he is the best player to ever wear a united shirt in the last 40 years.

    • Re: Why does SAF fight with his players?

      jim w by jim w . May 11, 2006 20:09 . Permalink

      Because he is the archetypical control freak. Also a perfectionist driven by insecurities....

      Because he is the archetypical control freak. Also a perfectionist driven by insecurities. Very common traits in a born leader rather than a consensual manager.
      Will give those he views as exceptional ( Giggs, Scholes, Cantona, Keane) extreme loyalty. Those as he regards as just 'very good' ( Beckham, Stam, RVS,Ince) will be expendable in his grand scheme.
      He expects to be able to 'change the world' to his view, hardly ever will he change his view to line up with a consensus.

    • Re: Why does SAF fight with his players?

      pool by pool . May 11, 2006 22:04 . Permalink

      u have one fearce, jock. and some primadonas, it is bound 2 happen, as for saf, keeping ev...

      u have one fearce, jock. and some primadonas, it is bound 2 happen, as for saf, keeping every thing under covers, and yip yap, spilling all in his book, u ever read saf,s book ?

    • View More Messages