Manchester United Message Board

ViewSummary |  Expanded
AsThreaded |  Message List
  • 3 Goal Valencia to Replace 23 goal Ronaldo?

    Vito Ceresa by Vito Ceresa . Jul 2, 2009 07:02 . Permalink

    Has Ferguson been taking his meds? Time to retire, me thinks.

    • Re: 3 Goal Valencia to Replace 23 goal Ronaldo?

      welshmu by welshmu . Jul 2, 2009 13:05 . Permalink

      Vito, SAF is a builder of teams. Valencia has not been bought as a direct like-for-like re...

      Vito, SAF is a builder of teams. Valencia has not been bought as a direct like-for-like replacement for Ronaldo. He has been bought for his own talent and skills and how that will complement the team and the squad. United have won many premierships without anyone scoring 42 or 23 goals from the wing.

    • Re: 3 Goal Valencia to Replace 23 goal Ronaldo?

      stefan t by stefan t . Jul 2, 2009 21:29 . Permalink

      Ian, Rooney is a very good player, but he is by no means the best attacking player in Euro...

      Ian, Rooney is a very good player, but he is by no means the best attacking player in Europe. He has to improve his touch, dribbling and scoring rate by quite a bit before he can even be considered to be that. The problem with the loss of Ronaldo and Tevez is that it takes the focus of the mess that is the central midfield, the weakest part of the team. Carrick has slow feet, and while his long range passing is great, his short range passing is average at best. Anderson's technical abilities seem to have diminished in the last season, Scholes is finished, Hargreaves has a chronic injury (and thus could be argued to be finished) and Fletcher, while having greatly improved, is still mediocre. Defence and attack has won us titles, the midfield has been pedestrian and workmanlike in comparison, meaning that there has been an over-reliance on counter-attacking football against the best sides.

    • Re: 3 Goal Valencia to Replace 23 goal Ronaldo?

      Neutral by Neutral . Jul 3, 2009 02:26 . Permalink

      Antonio Valencia had a decent season at Wigan, nothing spectacular. Is he CR caliber? Not ...

      Antonio Valencia had a decent season at Wigan, nothing spectacular. Is he CR caliber? Not by a long shot.

      Some examples:
      Berbatov was outstanding prior to joining MU, he still needs to prove himself.
      Robie Keane went from top asset at the Spurs, to mediocre after joining Liverpool.
      Deco/Sheva have been under performers for Chelsea.

      Valencia is a hard worker with decent skills, it fits the MU bill, but he is not a superstar.

    • Re: 3 Goal Valencia to Replace 23 goal Ronaldo?

      by A Yahoo! User . Jul 3, 2009 03:17 . Permalink

      AHHH IAN, I was laughing as soon as i saw that you had posted

      AHHH IAN, I was laughing as soon as i saw that you had posted

    • Re: 3 Goal Valencia to Replace 23 goal Ronaldo?

      by A Yahoo! User . Jul 2, 2009 22:25 . Permalink

      Ha!!! The mighty ian reduced to a fool by a farcenal fool and two dippers!!!!!!!

      Ha!!! The mighty ian reduced to a fool by a farcenal fool and two dippers!!!!!!!

    • View More Messages