I would agree with your first choice 11, If our team had managed to stay fit throughout the season those 11 would be my first choice. 'IF ONLY'
I like your second 11 or back up, I know that Jenas/Corluka have their haters, but personally I don't think many EPL teams have back up players who are of similar quality. I know some other people have flogged this to death, but I would love to have seen Gio get a chance. I guess the fact he hasn't tells us something about his attitude.