Liverpool Message Board
Rather than start a new thread with every single name seen, heard or wanted, which I still expect to happen anyways, I'm just going to use this one for my own purposes..
Obviously this appeares on the LFC site, but to be honest, I'd really be hoping we would have a look in France and that was perhaps my biggest disappointment in Commoli/Kenny having that connection and ability to go there and we never really did aside from some rumors of Aly Sissokho at LB before signing Enrique..
Anyways, Bafatembi Gomis... not sure if everyone is familiar or not, but certainly someone you'd want to know about should it ever materialize, since he's a very very good striker, has been for several years now at Lyon and in the Champions League. Very good pace, very strong physically, quite clinical and can play the ball in the air..
I watch Ligue when I can, so I know enough of the big players and I have a few others I'd like, Such as Gamiero, Gouffran and Roux, but I'll stick with this for now. I really don't know how the French sports media goes in comparions to England and the states, with all our BS respectively, so I don't know the reality of this, but here it is in French and I asked a good friend, born in France (Arsenal fan no coincidence) to translate and it does say, Liverpool have contacted Lyon about him, with 8M being the number.. Again it could be complete rubbish, or perhaps they're right, I don't know but I asked for a translation at least to supplement the original news in English.. here it is
And if you're not familiar or think he's a waste without knowing, have a look..(music sucks!)
He's 27, 9 goals and 2 assists in 14 games and starting to really peak now.. had 19 last year in all comp, including 6 in the UCL ..
- 1 Reply to A Yahoo! User
Rodgers can't go in for any more players per his agreement, unless they have a release clause, which is how we got Allen for 15M. And, I don't think at this point he would, or if he could have earlier we'd had been right in for Scott Sinclair.
I love Michu, and when I saw Laudrup rob him from La Liga for 2M, it seemed like a sick joke, and to that effect, I don't think they'd let him go hell or high water, and at the same time, they probably couldn't find themselves a replacement with the 13M profit to match what he's done, above and beyond anything expected..
Like the idea though..
He's been around the block quite some time but never been my cup of tea. He reminds me a bit of Kenwyne Jones in that he's a pacy, powerful handful but I can't really see him at LFC or find myself particularly excited about him. I heard a lot of noise over the weekend about renewing our interest in Shane Long, that's something I find very appealing.
- 1 Reply to Hobitez
Does seem he's been around a while doesn't he.. But not a bad thing considering he's 27 and having his best season to date, and along the way, he has scored big goals including Champions League vs the Epic Failures from Spain themselves in a knockout round 2-3 years ago..
I do like him as a player, think in the right team he could be a 20 goal scorer. Wouldn't shock me to see him on Arsenal, obvious reasons, and do well. So, while he amongst others isn't my first choice, for 8M, if true, I would have him because he's clinical, experienced and can mix it up in the box..
For me, at this point, unless it's some super hot prospect anymore, and the same fees, I'm always leaning towards a European player vs British these days, and I mean that w/ no disrespect, then again, aside from Dempsey, Donovan and Altidore.. why would I .. So, 8M for Gomis vs 6-8M for Long, easy one to me..
If we're talking some fancy winger who may be perceived as a little lightweight vs a player like Zaha, than I'll go the other way.
Based on the last several years now, maybe 3.. there's been so few big name, big money, European/foreign players that have flopped vs British just moving teams, and in general..
I thought Ramires would break into pieces, Mata would take 2-3 years, Cabaye and Ben Arfa not strong enough etc etc.. All wrong, and as much as I loved and wanted him, David Silva worried me, but since he basically never goes anywhere near being a winger despite lining up there, he's absolutely brilliant..
Our best existing players, and most important ones gone in recent years, says it all..
Sturridge, Walcott & Bent would be the players we need.. all of them..
Before people proclaim "where's the money coming from?".. FSG were happy to blow £35m on Carroll.. I'm sure they won't mind buying the 3 players I mentioned..
If we offload Cole, Downing and a few others that are "dead wood".. then we could get the 3 I mentioned..
Afterall FSG claim to love the club and want success.. well buying Sturride & Walcott are young players and fit our mould.. Bent just would keep us in the top 6.. Until we get rid of him.. .. in a few yrs
What annoys me is that we seem to be a feeder club.. We get the players in young, and rather than nurture their skills ourselves and keep them.. other clubs then get them off us.. then we're back to square one again..
- 2 Replies to LFC_Armchair_Supporter
Really all 3? You know they can't all play at once, especially if you want Suarez and or Sterling to get a look in, I don't think anyone has used a 5 man front line in over 50 years!
But also I would question where the money is coming from, but let’s put that aside. If we do have this kind of money, why go for 3 players, at least 1 of which, if not 2 we really don't need. Heck if the money grows on the trees outside the FSG office building in Boston, the way you seem to assume (Jason fancy a little road tip to pick some ripe special green back fruit?), then why not ask for another 10M or so and get Cavani, Falcoa or the like?
I cannot see how bent will fit in, I wouldn't disagree as a plan B for Suarez but then he's just sitting on the bench most of the time and considering he wont be less than 15mill it seems silly. Sturridge like Borini and Suarez I guess is an auxiliary front man and I would expect only that sort of player to arrive. Zarate is a rumour that interested me, and also getting Rossi even though he's injured (I think I already said on this thread!) but realistically Sturridge and Wallcot are known quantities and match the profile of player we are looking for so if the price is right it makes scene.
Just wanted to correct myself in the size comparison, he's not nearly as tall as Lukaku, but he's a strong boy, maybe close to 6'1..
Again, no idea how far the dialogue has gone just sahin what's been said here, and the factuals/quotes stating LFC involvement are from both his agent, and the club.. Vitesse that is, not LFC. It's probably made it's way to the internet/uk media by now then twisted into more than it is..
End of the day, seems like an up and coming player, but not my choice along with Sturridge/Walcott.
Hmmmmmmm.........Mario Gomez is 6'2". Now a Mario Gomez type lethal finisher would fit the bill rather nicely here at Anfield.
Forgive me , I'm just idly daydreaming. Might as well dream big
OK , back to reality.
It would help you a lot if you actually read what people have said above Armchair. Jason has pointed out your Ivory Coast man two / three replies up.
Gomez is an odd one for me. His record and reputation says mountains but every time (very few) I've seen him play I've not been impressed at all. I'm actually surpised that Armchair hasn't asked for Zlatan. :o) Of course he's second best to the mighty Bentnar anyway.
I'm finding the Walcott / Arsenal thing quite interesting. No idea what will happen and he's not my favourite option but when I look at what Rodgers wants from his wide forwards he fits the profile very well indeed.
Walcott has a lot more steam building up around his name over on this side than Sturridge does, of course when mentioning the two. (Not obsessing) Though, neither are my cup of tea.. Both injured as well.. Theo's seems to be something short term, and then his situation seems to be a loaded one from all angles..
As for Bony, it seems he absolutely wants out but Vitesse don't want to let him leave, so ultimately it could just become a bidding war with other teams involved, and that's too risky in my opinion..
Gomez was obviously a pie in the sky comment, like me saying Cavani, though not apples to apples. Cavani will move at some point, I don't think this year, but I'm not sure I see Gomez leaving any time soon, if ever. Most of the Bayern players, particularly the academy through and through, or German born, don't really seem like they'll leave.. maybe a couple. Gomez is a world class poacher. He's not a spectacular striker, but a spectacular striker of the ball. He makes some 10-12 yd finishes look like 30 yd hits. He is very good, but he is very streaky and very over reliant on service. Nonetheless, no point in talking about him, when fit, he's first choice for a club who could/should win UCL
Just going on the general news/noise from the media here, not really much other than Ince, Bony, and the 2 injured London wantaways mentioned every day.. Some really funny/rubbish in the papers though! I think we're on red alert for Sneijder since he won't take a pay cut from his 180k at Inter..!
I'm wondering if the constant stories of Walcott and Sturridge are not a smoke screen. I still think one or the other is the most likely outcome, but I'd not put it back BR to bring in someone few of us have heard of.
On a similar note, does anyone know the estimated date of when Borini might be back? If he can get back into contention during December it might tell us what kind of striker we're really looking for. I know some have already written him off, but considering the number of players others also talked about being nothing but deadwood putting in some fairly decent shifts lately, I think we have to consider his contribution as part of the attacking force.
That is not to say we don't still need another striker, but do we go for a winger, a traditional center forward, someone who can partner Suarez, or someone who is just a backup player. Do we go for someone who is experienced and can contribute goals right now, or some younger/not proven in the prem, who will be part of the attack force for seasons to come.
- 2 Replies to dsteer_lfc_68
Don't really think there's much smoke screen, and it's absolutely possible for BR to sign someone at least some of us have never heard, though not as likely in January I'll concede..
Gomis, who I started with, was something I'd seen over here in French and asked a friend to translate it. Very good player, no idea if the French media speaks a word of truth. Wilfried Bony, it seems it's 100% truth that there's interest and dialogue both ways.. who gets him (many suitors) is anyone's guess..
For Sturridge and Walcott, both are injured, both are never ending persistent names. I'd say over here, Walcott is the one seeming to be the more likely, if there's any truth. Another layer to Sturridge aside from injury and probably costing more, is would Roman sell him our way? We're not directly competing with them, but over the past 2 years, we've been a handful and thorn in their side. Rafa loves Liverpool, but perhaps he fancies Sturridge, perhaps not, perhaps he holds some ill will for never getting an interview with us this summer?
To answer on Borini, they said sometime early February. He's working on all his cardio and leg strength, but won't be doing any real type of football running/action until Jan probably. I think it was fracture on top of his foot, so one wrong step or rough challenge and it could just crack again. And before anyone follows this up w slating him, leave him alone.. he can't be bad when he's not playing..
As for the window, I think we need a quality, attacking, winger who can score and create just as much as a striker, so for me 1 of each please.
If you look at Swansea last year and their goals/assists.. Graham, Gylfi, Sinclair, Dyer.. Compared to ours now Suarez and Sterling, 11 combined.. not enough. Swans this year, with by in large part the same team, only adding in Michu and Pablo, ... Dyer, Pablo, Routledge, Michu and Graham.. alot of chances for goals from several..
To supplement my theory on the winger, if anyone was to slate any player, I'm actually surprised it's not Assaidi. His recent showings have been late minute cameos and not that impressive and he's not even getting himself in the squad for the league, so we have Sterling who is young, promising but not much end product yet, Suso who is more a cutting in, sit in the hole type, and then Downing/Enrique and Cole.. Not good enough..
Just to throw this out there, since he's played maybe 1 minute all season, perhaps we could approach City for Sinclair, get involved for 4-5M they paid since Mancini clearly has no use for him, and he must be miserable with his choice.
Adding potentially Ince and Sinclair would be really nice for the wide areas, and then let's say Walcott..
All could be done under 30M, and tremendously upgrade for now and allow us to really push hard towards the top and then show the owners Rodgers knows what's what and allow him to spend much bigger in the summer
- View More Messages