There were no flowing tiki-taka moves or individual runs from the halfway line among the candidates which included two goals from women's football.
FIFA said the goals (http://www.fifa.com/ballondor/puskasaward/index.html) were chosen "by a panel of experts and members of FIFA's football committee."
The list included Zlatan Ibrahimovic's speculative 25-metre overhead kick for Sweden against England, scored late in a friendly when his team were already winning 3-2.
There was also a spectacular effort from the Mexican league where Pachuca's Argentina midfielder Daniel Ludena scored from inside his own half against UANL after spotting the opposing goalkeeper off his line.
Receiving a looping diagonal cross, Di Natale sent a left-foot volley crashing into the far corner in the match against Chievo.
There were also acrobatic efforts from Peter Ankersen (Esbjerg), Nemanja Matic (Benfica) and Panagiotis Kone (Bologna). Matic's effort followed a bout of head-tennis, described by FIFA as an "awesome circus-like goal".
There were long-range goals from Neymar (Brazil) and Juan Manuel Olivera (Nautico).
The women's goals included a long-rang effort from Louisa Nacib (Lyon) and a bicycle kick by Australian Lisa de Vanna (Sky Blue FC) in the United States' National Women's Soccer League.
The winner will be announced at the FIFA Player of the Year award ceremony in Zurich on Jan. 13.