Neil Back

Backy: Pumas will boost Tri-Nations

Thu Sep 17 15:38

I think it was a really positive move Argentina being accepted into the Tri-Nations. Not only will it help rugby in Argentina and the southern hemisphere, it will give rugby across the world a boost. 

The Pumas have emerged as a real power over the past decade and proven they are good enough to take on the leading Test nations. They lost only one game at the last World Cup – their semi-final with champions South Africa – and were good value for their third-place finish. 

There might be one or two questions marks over whether Argentina rugby has the depth to maintain that level year in year out, but the only way they are going to develop is by playing against the best on a regular basis. They now have that opportunity. 

I have always admired the Pumas' power in the scrum and this is an aspect of their game that the southern hemisphere nations will welcome facing. And they know they will be in for a real forward battle because the Pumas take great pride in their scrum. 

I came across a few Argentine props when I was with Leicester and we also have one at Leeds in Juan Gomez. The Pumas foundation has always been the scrum and it is fair to say they have a real appetite for this side of the game. The types of athletes that come out of Argentina seem realty well suited to the scrum. 

To do things well you have got to get excited by it and the Pumas certainly get excited about the scrum. In fact, the only other player I know who relishes the scrum battle like the Pumas is Julian White. Maybe Julian has a bit of Argentine in him! 

The Argentine forwards I’ve come across have a different physique to most forwards playing in the Premiership, and this is a result of their live scrum training. They learn their technique through live scrums. Juan tells me it was not uncommon to do 40-50 scrums in a training session, not against a machine but against another pack.

Consequently they develop a different muscle structure, one that is not developed down the gym. It also means their muscle structure is slightly unbalanced and some of them have required a more structured programme to help develop their athleticism and other parts of their game.   

The Pumas also have some fine players in the backs with real flair and I think their introduction to the Tri-Nations will help rugby to flourish in Argentina.

  • Comments1 - 4 of 4
  1. The Pumas should just be the beginning. As a Four-Nation Championship it will be greater than the "ÜK - French - Italian" Goal Kicking marathons that currently blot the International Game.

    robertwright_2005From robertwright_2005 on Fri Sep 18 02:30

    Report abuse

  2. Hello my dear fellow rugby enthusiastic friends. My name is aucun_dispo, from France. Over there we also have a rugby blog, hosted by the legendary Pierre Salviac (a.k.a. "numéro zéro", a.k.a. "Le Maitre"). With over 1000 posts by article, come posting with us, you would feel less lonely than here. No need to speak french, Le Maitre is perfectly fluent in english.
    fr.sports.yahoo.com/rugby/pierre-salviac/.
    Looking forward to reading you.

    aucun_dispoFrom aucun_dispo on Fri Sep 18 09:51

    Report abuse

  3. Can this blog handle so many posts???

    aucun_dispoFrom aucun_dispo on Fri Sep 18 13:01

    Report abuse

  4. Dude,
    Southern Hemisphere rugby is awesome! Adding the Pumas to the tri nations is like adding Italy to the 5 but worse cause the other 3 nations already are miles ahead of the other 5 northern teams. How much help has that been for Italy? How did they fare in the RWC?

    Every year the Pumas tour SA and get pummled by their second string players. It has helped develop them but participating in a larger more popular tournament will severly damage their confidence, sponsorship opportunites and in the long run, their development. There needs to be a balance of wins and losses to help any development and confidence.

    Rather than follow the popular and politically acceptable rhetoric, I believe they should play other developing teams regularly and continue to tour to play harder more challenging competition as they do. It's served them well so far.

    The leap to the deep end may prove to do way more harm than good for the boys.

    nathallemansFrom nathallemans on Thu Oct 01 04:27

    Report abuse

    Comment on this article

    Please sign in to add your comments.