Premier League - Johnson the late Liverpool hero at Chelsea
All the pre-match hype was about Chelsea striker Fernando Torres and, to a far lesser extent, midfielder Raul Meireles facing their former club but it was Glen Johnson, another player to represent both sides, who settled the match in the closing stages with a delightful individual goal.
That goal sealed all three points for Liverpool after substitute Daniel Sturridge had cancelled out Maxi Rodriguez's first-half opener.
It is Chelsea's worst start in the Roman Abramovich era: they have not lost four matches in their opening 12 games since 2000/01, and it's also the first time they have suffered back-to-back home defeats in the league since 2002, the year before Abramovich took over at Stamford Bridge.
The big team news before kick-off was that neither Torres nor the man who replaced him at Anfield, Andy Carroll were starting the match in west London. The two men cost £85 million between them on transfer deadline day in January, and have since scored just five goals each for their current clubs.
Many of the games between these sides over the past decade - during which time a significant rivalry has been cultivated - have been tight, uninspiring games, but this match was an open affair from the outset.
With 10 minutes on the clock Florent Malouda found Juan Mata with a high ball to the far post, and the Spain playmaker's volley back across the six-yard box could have gone anywhere, but it was guided clear by Liverpool.
Moments later Frank Lampard - equalling Sol Campbell's mark of 503 Premier League appearances - made a tackle that teed up John Obi Mikel to try his luck from distance, and the Nigerian's strike was decent enough for someone still awaiting their first English league goal as it fizzed over the crossbar.
Half of those in the ground thought Chelsea were ahead midway through the half when Drogba struck a free-kick around the wall with Pepe Reina rooted to the spot, but it had merely hit the rear stanchion and gone behind the net, not into it.
That trio combined in some style to take the lead in 34 minutes. Petr Cech played a goal kick short to Mikel, whose dithering on the ball saw him robbed of it by Charlie Adam. Bellamy brought it forward and played a one-two with Suarez before picking out Maxi, who lifted a neat finish over Cech for his first league goal of the season, although he has now netted eight in his last five starts
Given Abramovich's track record, Chelsea boss Andre Villas-Boas is already facing questions from some quarters about his job security, and the Portuguese coach acted decisively at half-time by replacing Mikel with Sturridge, leaving Torres on the bench.
The Blues set about their opponents with renewed vigour, and were rewarded 10 minutes after the restart when the impressive Malouda surged into the box and hit a low cross between Reina and his defenders that Sturridge turned in for his sixth goal of the season.
It was only Reina that stopped Chelsea going ahead two minutes later when he got down low to parry Luiz's glancing header with an excellent save.
Malouda fired wide with an agile overhead kick before he volleyed across the face of goal, leaving the waiting Lampard and Mata putting their hands to their heads in dismay.
That double-switch was largely ineffectual, and they were only on the field for a few minutes before Johnson eclipsed them both.
The England right-back - who moved from Chelsea to Anfield via a two-year spell at Portsmouth - picked up the ball on the right wing and nipped past Ashley Cole into the box, held off the covering Malouda before passing an inch-perfect low finish into the far bottom corner past Cech and Terry on the line.
It was Johnson's first goal since February, which was also the month when Liverpool last won at the Bridge, courtesy of a Meireles goal on that occasion. No doubt the irony of that will be lost on him, Villas-boas and Chelsea as they count the cost of a defeat which leaves them 12 points behind leaders Manchester City.