• Charlton Athletic Message Board

  • james james Jan 31, 2008 20:11 Flag

    Andy Reid

    So are you that depressed to see Andy Reid go?? Possibly the fattest and most unathlectic looking defender since Gary Mabutt? Not to mention overrated.

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • What's all the nonsense about Reid being a fatty ? If he is, then there must be a few million fatties in the World who have the same amount of energy as him.
      He's never been a defender, but as a midfielder you cannot doubt his over-all ability, and he will be a big loss to Charlton in their 'Run-in.'
      Nevertheless it was a good piece of transfer business for the club, as they got a 4m.fee plus the services of an accomplished defender in Greg Halford.
      Good luck to Reidy, and welcome to Greg, having seen him score yesterday in the reserves v Millwall I think he will be an excellent acquisition.

    • Defender? Andy Reid is a defender? Obviously u are a well informed and I look forward to hearing some more of your useful observations..Perhaps Pele was too short to be a goalkeeper or Wayne Rooney is a bit light-weight?