• Liverpool Message Board

  • yahoo administrator yahoo administrator Sep 8, 2007 02:27 Flag

    GRADE our team

    let's have some fun, grade the season-to-date player performance (all compettions), 0-10 scale (i recommend you copy mine, paste in your reply and change with your grade )

    Agger 7
    Alonso 6
    Arbeloa 9
    Babel 6
    Benayoun 8
    Carragher 9
    Crouch 6
    Finnan 8
    Gerrard 8
    Hyypia 7
    Kuyt 6
    Mascherano 9
    Pennant 8
    Reina 9
    Riise 6
    Sissoko 8
    Torres 10

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • Agger 8
      Alonso 6
      Arbeloa 9
      Babel 7
      Benayoun 7
      Carragher 9
      Crouch 4
      Finnan 8
      Gerrard 8
      Hyypia 8
      Kuyt 7
      Mascherano 10
      Pennant 8
      Reina 9
      Riise 4
      Sissoko 7
      Voronin 8
      Torres 9

      I think that there are no guesses as to who I think need to pull their socks up, or piss off!

    • Reina 8

      Finnan 9
      Carra 9
      Agger 8
      Hyppia 8
      Arbeloa 8

      Pennant 10(on his performances this season)
      Gerrard 8
      Alonso 7
      Mascherano 9
      Sissoko 7
      Babel 7
      Yossi 6
      Riise 5

      Voronin 9
      Kuyt 9 (don't care if he has'nt scored in league he does so much for the team)
      Crouch 6
      Torres 10 (The perfect start to his liverpool life)

    • I'm not sure of the criteria, or scale your using. Some might find mine to be low, but while I've been impressed with many players, I've also got a feeling they have more to show. Especially true of the newer players who may not have fully settled yet:

      Agger 7 (solid, but improving all the time)
      Alonso 7 (great against Derby when he took the reins, more to come)
      Arbeloa 8 (simply great, but I'd say even more in the tank for us to rave about latter in the season)
      Babel 4 (not putting him down, but huge potential for improvement, just wait we are going to be amazed)
      Benayoun 6 (more to come from this lad)
      Carragher 8 (solid, but always gets better at cruch time)
      Crouch 5 (need to see more, so tough to judge)
      Finnan 8 (always solid)
      Gerrard 7 (I'd say his just warming up)
      Hyypia 9 (my hero so far)
      Kuyt 7 (its not all about goals, but team play)
      Mascherano 7 (need to see more of him)
      Pennant 7 (might need to increase scale as he's getting better by the day)
      Reina 7 (solid, but not really tested yet)
      Riise 7 (solid games so far, but not yet the threat I expect, but it will happen)
      Sissoko 8 (marked improvement from last year)
      Torres 7 (you ain't seen nothing yet baby!!!!!)

    • forgot voronin!

      Agger 7
      Alonso 6
      Arbeloa 9
      Babel 6
      Benayoun 8
      Carragher 9
      Crouch 6
      Finnan 8
      Gerrard 8
      Hyypia 7
      Kuyt 6
      Mascherano 9
      Pennant 8
      Reina 9
      Riise 6
      Sissoko 8
      Torres 10
      Voronin 8