• Liverpool Message Board

  • Yellow Bob ring ring hahahahahahha Yellow Bob ring ring hahahahahahha Oct 9, 2009 02:53 Flag

    ...MEDIC for dsteer....FINALLY Lost It...

    ...from the UTD Board...

    ..''agree, Liverpool does not have the depth I'd like us to have. Especially compared to Chelsea, and to a lessor extent Utd. I'd say Liverpool as about 14-16 players who can go toe to toe with anyone in the league or Europe, but beyond that, we've got players who are either mid table level like Voronin, or may have the potential to great things, but are just not experienced enough yet to actually become regular starters like N'Gog.''

    ..WTF...14-16 players who can gho toe to toe with anyone in the league and EUROPE....

    ...now this list ive got to see............is he on DRUGS??

    ...List em up steer, i need a laugh ...(boy, this is gonna be good)..........

    ANYONE else agree with him...????

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • dave, come on mate.... shame on you for this one....

      "Q - Did the squads I name beat Man U, and Chelsea?
      A - Yes

      Q - Are Chelsea and Man U amongst the best in the league (and Europe)?
      A - Yes

      Q - so do Liverpool have a squad of players (between 14 and 16) capable of going toe to toe with the best?
      A - Yes "

      answering in the positive to the first two do not imply the positive response to the third..... it does not stand the typical inductive logic test...... and it quite obviously isn't deductive logic..... your reasoning is flawed.... this is how this reads to a student of logic / philosophy / law / math:

      Q - Did Liverpool beat Man U, and Chelsea on XX and XX <insert dates here>?
      A - Yes

      Q - Are Chelsea and Man U <considered by many> amongst the best in the league (and Europe)?
      A - Yes

      Q - Did Burnley beat Man U on XX <inser date here>?
      A - Yes

      Q - Did Liverpool draw with Arsenal on XX <insert date here>?
      A - Yes

      Q - so do Liverpool have a squad of players (between 14 and 16) capable of going toe to toe with the best?
      A - No idea since the facts don't support the argument

      obrigado friend!!!

    • just thought would try and answer the question with players still at the club without mentioning ex players as i think that is what sean is looking for, feel free to give me reasons why these players wouldn't stand up to the best in europe when the majority done it last season. The only real loss is alonso and i believe i have substitued him adequately. Note: no lucas, didn't want to fall into that trap lol

      ok maybe not 14-16 but would you agree that this 11 would give most teams a good go:

      reina
      johnson
      carra
      agger/skrtel (i think all 3 are as good as each other; skrtel and agger are the future)
      aurelio (i think he still has a tiny edge over insua)
      kuyt
      masch
      aquaman (i'm going on his billing rather than what i've seen as he hasn't played yet obviously)
      riera/benayoun
      gerrard
      torres

      or

      same keeper and defence but
      benayoun
      masch
      gerrard
      riera
      kuyt
      torres

      i know i've mentioned more than 11 players but you get the jist

    • If winning is getting the last word in, and is so important to you, then absolutely you can win. Your posts are like static from the radio, so why would I want to keep reading them. I've had my say, and made my point. And you have made your noise. So please yes, take the last post, I'm sure it will be riveting.

    • Yellow Bob ring ring hahahahahahha Yellow Bob ring ring hahahahahahha Oct 10, 2009 05:00 Flag

      ....in other words...........i won, as usual.....

      ........and without even breaking into a sweat...........he he

    • All teams can have their off days, just like the Burnley result you mention. But the logic of my statement is quite simple.

      Q - Did the squads I name beat Man U, and Chelsea?
      A - Yes

      Q - Are Chelsea and Man U amongst the best in the league (and Europe)?
      A - Yes

      Q - so do Liverpool have a squad of players (between 14 and 16) capable of going toe to toe with the best?
      A - Yes

      I've decided to let Sean have a think about it for a while, but as you posed a direct challenge, I thought it worth responding. You also, as usual, did it in a polite way without the need for expletives, caps, etc. But if you and Sean want to chase your tails on it, that's up to you. I've had my say, and think I've well and truly backed up my statement. If others disagree because they can't see the logic of my method, well that's down to them from this point.

    • Yellow Bob ring ring hahahahahahha Yellow Bob ring ring hahahahahahha Oct 10, 2009 04:32 Flag

      ...slayer my point is crystal....

      ...You CANNOT CHERRYPICK players out of one winning team to the next, cast aside those that contributed in those games, that have now left and replace them from players from other winning games................

      ..........and now say they have a winning squad to go toe to toe with the best.................its BOLUX

      ..ITS FANTASY LEAGUE FOOTBALL......................FIFA 2010

      ..............................T|T.......................................

    • "You wanted 14-16 players who could go toe to toe from the Liverpool squad. I actually name those players, and demonstrate they can actually go toe to toe, by posting the actual team sheets from games won against the best, yet for some reason you still don't get it. I completely give up."?

      dave, what?

      I'm not taking sides in this tit-for-tat but I honestly think your logic is flawed for the following reason................Burnley 1-0 Man U

      It's just like saying Burnley can repeat their feat against Man U if they replay that game again, fact of the matter is they may not be as luck as their first attempt 9 times out of ten tries.

    • "You wanted 14-16 players who could go toe to toe from the Liverpool squad. I actually name those players, and demonstrate they can actually go toe to toe, by posting the actual team sheets from games won against the best, yet for some reason you still don't get it. I completely give up."?

      dave, what?

      I'm not taking sides in this tit-for-tat but I honestly think your logic is flawed for the following reason................Burnley 1-0 Man U

      It's just like saying Burnley can repeat their feat against Man U if they replay that game again, fact of the matter is they may not be as luck as their first attempt 9 times out of ten tries.

    • Yellow Bob ring ring hahahahahahha Yellow Bob ring ring hahahahahahha Oct 10, 2009 04:02 Flag

      ...your drowning in your own bullshyt............

      .........and im happily watching................

      ...........................NNNEEEEXXXTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT............

    • Irrelevant? Actually showing the team list of the squads that did go toe to toe with the best is Irrelevant? It’s exactly what you asked for you fool.

      You wanted 14-16 players who could go toe to toe from the Liverpool squad. I actually name those players, and demonstrate they can actually go toe to toe, by posting the actual team sheets from games won against the best, yet for some reason you still don't get it. I completely give up.

      NEXT,

    • View More Messages