• Liverpool Message Board

you are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the posts
  • dsteer_lfc_68 dsteer_lfc_68 Nov 21, 2011 15:18 Flag

    Team to face Man City?

    I got to admit I would not have gone with Maxi against Chelsea, and I'm still not sure I'd pick him again against City. So, for that have to give full marks to Kenny for a very brave move that really worked out.

    But my concerns for using him again are first his lack of pace, and that I think he did fade in the second half. While of course he can be replaced I never like the idea of starting someone who you know you have to replace as it reduces your tactical flexibility by using up one precious sub. But I do have to give the player credit as it was his skill, his movement, and most importantly his footballing brain that ensured he made an impact on Sunday, so for that he has to be considered.

    But my thoughts are we have to keep the same attitude and tactics of keeping the pressure on a side with quality, so they get little chance to actually play there own game. But that does not necessarily mean keeping the same personnel. City I think have many of the same ball playing qualities as Chelsea (arguably more quality) but also with more pace. So I'd go with:

    ----------------------------------Reina------------------- -----------
    Johnson---------Skrtel---------------Agger--------Enrique
    Kuyt--------------Lucas---------------Adam------------Downing
    ---------------------Suarez-------------Bellamy----------- -----

    Subs: Doni, Carragher, Gerrard, Kelly, Maxi, Downing, Carroll

    The only other change is maybe bringing in Gerrard if he's fit for Adam, so we can get better tackling in the middle, and a lot more pace.

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • no sign of henderson anywhere steer. i thought you were saying in some other posts, that he made a big impact on the chelsea game. i hear what you are saying about maxi, and think he is unlikely to start this next game. for this one i would actually bring carrol back, and have bellamy or maxi come on if it's not working out for the big man. He played very well against city last season, and for some reason i get the feeling he could give them a bit of a fright again. whenever he gets stuck on the bench for a game or two, he always seems to come back to play one good game, and then drops off again.

      i would go

      same back 5.
      ..................lucas
      ....henderson...adam
      suarez.................downing
      .............Carrol

      and if Gerrard is fit, bring him on as a sub at some point. unlikely to start after another layoff.

      subs: doni, carra, kelly, gerrard, maxi, bellamy, kuyt

      i notice you have downing playing as well as on the bench, maybe one of him is hendo?

      • 1 Reply to Greg
      • I do think Henderson what a major part of what stabilized the side after the initial Chelsea onslaught in the second half, so I thought it fair I should sing his praises, especially as most of the time I've picked Kuyt ahead of him in my own selections.

        But I don't think he was a major part, or would likely have been if he'd started, of what got us the result. I think that came early on by us no allowing Chelsea to play. It was solid work by Suarez, Bellars, Kuyt and Maxi to really pressurize Chelsea high up the pitch, not let them settle and force them into poor balls out of the back. That is why I went for the same attacking 4 with the exception of switching Downing for Maxi as I think he's got an edge in pace, and more ability to last the full 90.

        I did however toy with the idea of how I could play Carroll who I don't think has done anything wrong when he's been played. However I think like all the players he's got to accept his role, which ultimately is to help the team. My fear is that because the City side is so good with the ball at their feet, and has pace, that with Carroll on we may resort to long ball just to release the pressure. That is fine in the last few minutes if we've got a result (same role he had when he came on Sunday) but don't want that from the start. I'm eager to see him really get some playing time with Suarez, and get some real tasty service from Downing, Adam, Kuyt and or Henderson, but not sure the City game is the one to start experimenting on what could be, but more about using what we know we've got to try and get a result.

        Downing on the bench was a typo, I cut and pasted the original and remember to put Downing on the pitch, but forgot to get him off the bench and replace him with Jordan.