The Israel international was on target in a 3-3 draw with Norwich as he curled home a fantastic shot in only the second minute.
His effort at Emirates Stadium claimed 37 per cent of the vote among Eurosport-Yahoo! readers.
Yaya Toure came a close second with his first goal against Newcastle, while Clint Dempsey's free kick against Sunderland saw the Fulham star come in third.
1. Yossi Benayoun (Arsenal) v Norwich - 37%
2. Yaya Toure's first goal (Manchester City) v Newcastle - 33%
3. Clint Dempsey (Fulham) v Sunderland - 15%
4. Yaya Toure's second (Manchester City) v Newcastle - 9%
5. Phil Bardsley (Sunderland) v Fulham - 6%